Joel Goldenberg

CSLDS presents The Wizard of Oz

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Wicked, the “prequel” to The Wizard of Oz, has been getting the lion’s share of attention lately in Wizard lore, owing to the highly successful Broadway musical and last year’s movie spectacle.

But the original L. Frank Baum Wizard of Oz book and, especially, 1939 movie endure, especially as the latter has been a TV perennial since the 1950s. (Fun fact: This was one of the very, very few programs CBS presented in colour in the 1950s.)

Now, the wonders of The Wizard of Oz can be seen live and in person by audience members of all ages. The Côte St. Luc Dramatic Society is presenting the classic at the Harold Greenspon Auditorium, at the Bernard Lang Civic Centre from May 29 to June 15 — 17 performances. The cast is multigenerational and includes six children, as well as elements of puppetry. The co-producers are Mayor Mitchell Brownstein, and councillors Andee Shuster and Mitch Kujavsky.

Brownstein, who plays the Wizard, says that “in a world that often feels uncertain, The Wizard of Oz reminds us that intelligence, compassion, and courage are the keys to finding strength—not only within ourselves, but in the power of community. This heartwarming journey is exactly the kind of story we need right now; one that inspires us to believe in each other and the magic of home.”

Anisa Cameron, artistic director of the CSLDS and director and choreographer of this production, told The Suburban that The Wizard of Oz has “been on our wish list for quite some time, and this felt like the perfect moment to bring it to life.

“This past year marked the 85th anniversary of the beloved film, a milestone that reminded us just how timeless and meaningful this story continues to be. At the same time, Wicked has captured the hearts of a new generation, proving how deeply the world that began with L. Frank Baum’s book still resonates with audiences today. We also wanted to offer something truly magical for audiences of all ages—a show that families can enjoy together, filled with imagination, heart, and, of course, courage.”

Cameron also enthusiastically pointed out to The Suburban that the CSLDS production will have the same amount of music, and other elements, as the 1939 movie.

“We won the rights to The Royal Shakespeare Company version of The Wizard of Oz – which has all of the iconic characters, storyline and music you know and love from the film,” she explained.

Asked if the play will closely follow the movie, or if there will be any differences, Cameron responded that “the live show has a few changes, but for the most part is exactly in line with the film. There is a number from the 1939 film that ended up on the cutting room floor called The Jitterbug that will be back in our show. It’s a really fun song and dance sequence!”

The 1939 movie has many special effects — how will this be handled for a stage production?

“Lots and lots of theatre magic,” Cameron says. “We have a very small but mighty space, and I think we do a pretty good job of transforming it for each production. We will be using puppets again this year, designed by Lily Lachapelle and all audiences should take note there will be liberal use of stage smoke and lighting effects. We have a tremendous team of designers who support us in our productions.”

We also asked if the CSLDS would eventually present Wicked itself.

“Absolutely, if the rights ever come available,” Cameron told The Suburban. “Wicked is still playing on Broadway and the West End, so other, smaller companies don’t have access until the rights houses are allowed to sell to all of us who are eagerly waiting.”

For more information and to purchase tickets, go to www.csldramaticsociety.com. n

CSLDS presents The Wizard of Oz Read More »

Jewellery distraction scam hits CSL seniors

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A plethora of scams in the west end and West Island, and across the province, in which people are robbed of their jewellery through distraction crimes, has also hit Côte St. Luc.

A senior resident there had his Rolex watch — valued at between $20,000 and $25,000 — stolen in broad daylight.

The resident’s daughter, a CSL resident who did not want her name or that of her parents used, said the incident took place May 11 on Kellert, right near Hebrew Academy.

The Suburban was told by the daughter that her parents, 76 and 78, had returned from a trip to Costco and were tired.

“As they were finished unloading the car, a couple in a car suddenly stopped right in front of them,” the daughter wrote in an email to The Suburban. “The woman leaned out and, without so much as a proper hello, asked, ‘Where can I find an Arabic supermarket?’ My mom replied with a bit of confusion, ‘Adonis?’ The woman said, ‘Yes! My mom started explaining where the store was to the man that was in the driver’s seat.”

The daughter added that while her mother was giving directions, a woman who appeared to be wearing a hijab approached her father and began to cry, claiming her own father was very sick, “like a scene straight out of a scammer’s training manual.

“Then she told my dad she has her dying father’s watch and begged him to bless it. My dad, being decent and probably caught off guard, went along. She literally took his real watch off his wrist and slipped on some cheap plastic garbage like it was nothing. She even lowered his head as if she giving him some spiritual blessing — all while robbing him blind.” The parents then discovered the Rolex was gone.

The daughter told The Suburban that the police told her “this has happened multiple times across the city.

“When I asked why they haven’t been caught yet, the answer was simple — not enough evidence and no opportunity to catch them in the act. So I have to ask… is our city even safe anymore?”

In a phone interview, the daughter said these scammers are targeting elderly people, “which is very sad.

“I was more disappointed in the police, in their reaction. I understand they have a lot going on with the rallies going on all the time. Montreal is not the same, and CSL is being threatened too. I grew up here, and we never had these issues. It’s scary. This time, they didn’t hurt my parents, tomorrow, they’re going to start hurting if somebody refuses to give.”

The daughter said members of the community should be wary of people asking for directions and breaking down in fake tears, and called for more security measures in CSL.

Mayor Mitchell Brownstein pointed out to The Suburban that CSL has volunteer Citizens On Patrol (vCOPS), Public Security, as well as Station 9 police, “which is more than other cities, so our city is safer than most.”

CSL Public Safety Director Philip Chateauvert told The Suburban that “given our significant elderly population and our priority on safety, we have instructed CSL staff to remain especially vigilant during patrols.

“Mayor Brownstein is right to point out that with Public Security (PS) and vCOP, we have put ourselves in the best position to maintain a safe and peaceful community. I must acknowledge that this type of crime is particularly challenging to prevent, as it often occurs rapidly, and victims may not even notice immediately. Rest assured, we will continue to collaborate with the SPVM to adopt the best strategies and practices to combat distraction theft.”

The SPVM has also issued tips regarding such scams, advising the public to “travel in a group whenever possible, hide your valuable jewellery until you reach your destination” and “refuse a gift from a stranger and do not let that person come close to you.” n

Jewellery distraction scam hits CSL seniors Read More »

Drabkin,Oberman see hope in West End political horizon

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By:Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

After a troubling first week of the new federal Liberal government with ministers angering many Canadians on the issues of housing, pipelines, the budget and the Gaza-Israel war, The Suburban heard from the two Conservative Neils of the past campaign who ran strong campaigns. They both reflected hope and optimism.

Neil Drabkin ran in NDG-Westmount and Neil Oberman ran in Mount Royal, both achieving impressive numbers against incumbents Anna Gainey and Anthony Housefather respectively.

“The strong numbers indicate that Montrealers are starting to come around,” Drabkin said. “Although we haven’t won a seat on the island of Montreal in 37 years, voters seeking change came out for us in large numbers this time due to the strong leadership of Pierre Poilievre. That bodes well for the future and our ability to make inroads in Montreal after all these years,” added Drabkin, who has had a long and rich history with the Conservative Party. A lawyer and former federal prosecutor Drabkin is well known to the community not only as a political commentator on CJAD 800, but also as someone who has served at the highest levels of government in the Brian Mulroney and Stephen Harper administrations including as Chief of Staff to Stockwell Day.

Barbara Kay, in the National Post, called Drabkin a “proven political commodity.” Rabbi Reuben Poupko of Côte St. Luc’s Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue has said, “Our community is extremely proud of the contribution that Neil has made and to the extent to which he has always been there to assist.” Despite accepting to run at the request of the Party in what is considered to be one of the safest Liberal strongholds in the country, Drabkin tripled the Conservative vote to over 10,000 or some 20%, the highest in decades.

Oberman engaged in one of the most formidable campaigns in many years in Mount Royal, which has been a Liberal stronghold since 1940. The candidate, best known for protecting some 47 Jewish institutions with the injunctions he won against anti-Israel protesters, sought debates with Housefather and campaigned vigorously throughout the riding, which includes Côte St. Luc, Hampstead and Montreal West, gaining a historic 40% of the vote

Oberman says that his commitment “remains unwavering.Sometimes setbacks are tuition in the school of leadership,” he added. “I will persist in collaborating with all constituents, which includes approximately 41 percent of our riding who are actively seeking change. This desire for transformation is palpable and significant. Change is indeed on the horizon — however, it often comes with challenges and requires perseverance.”

Oberman added, “Simply put. The current liberal government is doing exactly what it promised. Nothing. So to all Canadians who voted for the liberals you got what you asked for. Now the question is will Canadians take back their country and stand up for change. Hopefully this government will be dispatched from Ottawa sooner than later. As for the young people I encourage you to keep advocating for your future just don’t expect the liberal baby boomers to help you. What can we do as Conservatives? Show Canadians that change is possible when we stop following old ways that yield no positive result. Your vote your voice your choice brings change.” n

Drabkin,Oberman see hope in West End political horizon Read More »

Call 311 and get results!

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The advice police all over the world give, “if you see something, say something,” does not only apply to looking out for suspicious people and calling local authorities.

It can also apply to potential hazards in neighbourhoods that could harm members of the public.

On May 13, on the north side of Queen Mary Road between Earnscliffe and Clanranald in Snowdon, I saw that a sign prohibiting parking between 3:30 and 6:30 p.m. in a bus zone was almost hanging by a thread. One of the bolts the sign was attached to had broken and it was tilted diagonally, looking like it could come off completely and cause major harm to a passerby.

Major harm had come to the area just days before. A block and a half to the west, a branch from a tree at the corner of Queen Mary and Macdonald in neighbouring Côte St. Luc fell and killed a 76-year-old woman.

Not wanting another tragedy to take place, I called the 311 city portal, a number used to inform the City of Montreal of potentially dangerous situations, at 9:43 p.m. May 13. A representative answered right away, took down the information, and promised to send someone to fix the sign.

By the time I returned to the area at around 6:30 p.m. May 14, the sign was fixed and firmly secured, proving that calling 311 for a potentially hazardous situation results in a very rapid response. Montrealers should be on the lookout for other potential dangers and call the service as soon as possible. n

Call 311 and get results! Read More »

West end Mayors press Girard on Cavendish, Hippodrome

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Mayors from Côte St. Luc, St. Laurent and Town of Mount Royal recently met with Quebec Finance Minister Eric Girard to press the case for the long-awaited Cavendish link and for a proper mobility plan for the Hippodrome site, Councillor Dida Berku reported to CSL council.

Berku, who was also part of the meeting with Girard, pointed out that as far as back as 1962, there was an agreement between CSL, St. Laurent, TMR and Montreal to build Cavendish, but Quebec shifted the focus to the then-future Décarie Expressway.

Switching to the present, Berku said the meeting with Girard took place the week before the council meeting.

“Now that the federal election is over, the provincial and municipal leaders are scrambling for infrastructure money,” she pointed out. “The Mayors asked the Minister to respect the 2017 Hippodrome sale agreement [to include the Cavendish extension in the overall project], and to understand that even if infrastructure money was to come, that it should not be given unless it’s also attached to the Cavendish project.”

Berku said the Mayors also told Girard that the Hippodrome project, in which 20,000 homes are planned for the site, needs a proper mobility plan.

“We were given a presentation by the City of Montreal two weeks ago where the mobility plan was completely unrealistic,” she explained. “It’s a non-starter. There’s one access for Jean Talon, and another for Devonshire. However, the fire department insists, and this is perhaps something that works in our favour, that there be three separate egress and access points for the Hippodrome project.”

Berku said there are two access options being considered.

“One is an underpass on Clanranald [from Jean Talon in Montreal to Côte St. Luc], but in my view it would be very difficult to have a fire truck go under [the rail tracks] on Clanranald. That would be a major underpass.” She later said a Clanranald underpass would be optimal for pedestrians, even possibly with a moving sidewalk.

The other. previously reported by The Suburban, would be for Jean Talon to go to Mackle in CSL.

“They keep pushing it, but we keep telling them it doesn’t make any sense. You’d have to cross nine tracks, parking lots, wetlands, and probably build an underpass double the length of the existing Cavendish underpass. It’s going to be much more expensive, much longer and more difficult to build than the underpass they would build if they did the Cavendish extension.” The more realistic option, she told The Suburban, is to extend Jean Talon to an extended Cavendish, “which would be less expensive than the Mackle option.”

Berku said the City of Montreal “has to understand that they have no other option” but to also build the Cavendish link.

“I told Girard, why would we invest even $1 into the infrastructure if there’s no viable mobility plan?” she told The Suburban.

What was Girard’s response, we asked.

“It was ‘It’s going to take a long time, and the federal government hasn’t given any money yet,’” Berku said. “The Mayors are going to insist that when Prime Minister Mark Carney meets [Montreal Mayor] Valérie Plante, that he understands very well that investing in the Hippodrome infrastructure could be a priority for the City of Montreal, but it should not be realized unless it’s linked to Cavendish, because there’s no viable road network to service the Hippodrome.”

Mayor Mitchell Brownstein said not building the Cavendish extension along with the Hippodrome project would represent a breach of contract.

“We’ll keep on pushing.” n

West end Mayors press Girard on Cavendish, Hippodrome Read More »

St. Laurent, Jacques-Cartier MNAs support Rodriguez for QLP leader

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

St. Laurent MNA Marwah Rizqy and Jacques Cartier MNA Gregory Kelley have declared their support for Pablo Rodriguez as leader of the Quebec Liberal Party.

Rodriguez, who has appeared at several local events lately, was former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Quebec lieutenant. He made the latest endorsement announcement accompanied by Michelle Setlakwe, campaign co-chair and MNA for Mont-Royal–Outremont.

Kelley and Rizqy are a married couple. Kelley, also the Official Opposition Critic for Energy, for Natural Resources, and for Relations with English-Speaking Quebecers, stated that Rodriguez is “someone who brings people together, not someone who divides.

“He has the experience and know-how to help continue to rebuild the party and I feel confident supporting someone who has faced down the Trump administration as a federal minister and has contacts all across Quebec and Canada. He can make Quebec a leader in the Canadian federation again, something we need in these unstable times.”

Rizqy, who announced months ago that she is not running for re-election, said Rodriguez is “the right man for the Quebec Liberal Party.

“His experience and drive will allow us to build a strong Liberal team to offer Quebecers a credible alternative to François Legault.”

Rodriguez himself stated this week that “I have a plan, I have the experience, and I definitely have a strong team to take on François Legault and the PQ in the next election.

“In order for the QLP to win the next election, it is absolutely necessary to unite all the Liberal forces. It is thanks to competent and high-quality people like Greg and Marwah that I will succeed. I’m really lucky to be able to count on their support and, above all, to have the privilege of calling them my friends,” says Pablo Rodriguez.

Rodriguez has already received endorsements from MNAs Désirée McGraw, Linda Caron, Setlakwe, Frédéric Beauchemin, Brigitte Garceau, Sona Lakhoyan-Olivier, Elisabeth Prass and Marie-Claude Nichols

Rodriguez is running against Karl Blackburn former President of the Conseil du Patronat du Quebec (2020–2025) Director General of the QLP (2009–2013) and MNA for Roberval (2003–2007) and Charles Milliard former President of the Fédération des chambres de commerce du Québec (2020–2024). Also in the race are attorney Marc Belamger and economist Mario Roy. n

St. Laurent, Jacques-Cartier MNAs support Rodriguez for QLP leader Read More »

Festival Sefarad to attract all generations this year

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The 45th edition of the very popular Communauté Sépharade Unifiée de Québec’s Festival Sefarad de Montréal started yesterday May 13 and will run until May 28 at various venues.

Avi Krispine, the festival’s president, told The Suburban in a phone interview that the goal of the festival is to attract “every generation possible, who is capable of attending.

“We want to attract more than 5,000 to attend the many events this year,” he added. “We’re offering a variety of cultural events — lectures, musical performances, theatre and comedy. What we’re doing differently this year is we’re using the talent we have in this city. We call it ‘Made in Quebec.’ We also decided to go ahead in very strategic venues, and the tickets have been selling quite fast.”

A highlight of the festival will be a gala May 25 at Théâtre St. Denis featuring famed Israel singer Eden Hason making his debut in Canada and a roundtable discussion featuring a media personality from France, a former member of the Canadian Special Forces, and others. The proceedings begin with a VIP event at 5 p.m. and then the Hason concert at 8 p.m.

This event is sponsored by the Benita Family Foundation, founded by Didier Benita, which was created after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel. Its mission includes the restoration of Israeli homes and essential infrastructure, reviving the country’s economy by attracting investments and creating jobs and supporting youth “through mentorship, education, and professional development programs.”

Benita, the gala chairman, told The Suburban the roundtable will not only discuss what took place Oct. 7, 2023, “but also how we can rebuild the country and how we can save lives.”

Some of the other festival events include:

• May 15, 7 p.m at the Gelber Centre: The free lecture is called Discovering the Song of Songs, a Biblical text, and includes a presentation by professor and author Dr. David Bensoussan, in conversation with Dr. Marc-Alain Wolfe. This event is being presented as part of the Jewish Public Library’s “Authors from Home” festival and series. Painter Anne-Marie Marrache will exhibit her works on the theme of the conference and singer Hazan Sion Chriqui will perform.

• May 16 and 17, at various Montreal synagogues: A Shabbat Tous Ensemble” that is described as a “true tribute to Sephardic heritage.”

• May 18, 2 p.m. at the Gelber Centre: A free lecture called Le Carnet de Rachel, focusing on “the unusual journey of an exceptional Moroccan Jewish woman seen through Judeo-Arabic proverbs.”

• May 18, 8 p.m.at the Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem Synagogue: A singles evening for ages 25 to 35 that includes a wine tasting and buffet.

• May 20, 8 p.m. at Théâtre Plaza, 6505 St. Hubert: Séfarade du Rire 2 featuring comedian Neev.

• May 27, 7:30 p.m. at Théâtre Plaza, 6505 St. Hubert: The play Un 6-Plex Pas Très Kasher, directed by Ariel Ifergan, about Côte des Neiges six-plex owner Armand Benadoun, who, “despite his eloquence, energy, and fine speeches, is finding it increasingly difficult to navigate today’s world.”

For more information on all the events, to reserve spots and purchase tickets, go to festivalsefarad.ca

Festival Sefarad to attract all generations this year Read More »

Quebec med school applicants posted antisemitic, racist messages

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A public Discord server called Med serveur on the Internet has become a “cesspool of antisemitism, racism, misogyny, and hate,” B’nai Brith Canada has revealed.

“For months, a number of aspiring doctors openly posted Holocaust denial, praise for the ‘Final Solution,’ hurled racial slurs, glorified terrorism, and degraded women,” the organization said. “This content wasn’t buried. It was shared in open channels, visible to over 1,400 members. Almost no one spoke up. These aren’t anonymous trolls. They are future doctors. And this kind of hate doesn’t stay online. It follows them into classrooms, clinics, and operating rooms.”

B’ani Brith Canada added that “silence enables this rot to spread. Institutions must act—now.Hate like this has no place in healthcare—or anywhere in Canadian society.”

The organization revealed some of the offending posts, which say “the Islamic State of Quebec,” “they are just Negroes”, “imagine a woman under antidepressant and f–king Ritalin who [performs?] surgery on you. She’ll vomit mid-surgery because it’s ‘too stressful’ and she needs a ‘mental health break’” and “Don’t worry. You can trust me as long as you don’t have kippa under your wig.” There are also cartoon depictions of Jews reminiscent of those in the Nazi publication Der Sturmer.

B’nai Brith added its own message in a graphic, saying “you’ve been exposed” and “would you trust these doctors with your life?”

Lior Bibas of the Association of Jewish Doctors of Quebec stated, “If these accounts are really from future physicians, we need an immediate investigation to identify those responsible and ensure they are not admitted to our medical schools or allowed to practice medicine. It is essential that the institutions involved act swiftly, transparently, and decisively to restore public trust.

“Hate has no place in medicine. These reported comments are not only unacceptable—they are dangerous. Admitting individuals who hold such views into the medical profession poses a real risk to Quebec patients, especially those from vulnerable communities. Medicine must be grounded in ethics, respect, and inclusion. Those who do not uphold these values should not be entrusted with the care of our population.”

A 106-page report that is circulating amongst Jewish doctors, most of which contains examples of the numerous offensive postings, alleges that at least one Dawson College student and a current Quebec medical student have posted some of the messages. The Dawson administration is reportedly looking into the matter.

The report adds that “themes commonly mentioned included claims that Quebec medical students discriminated against Arab/Muslim medical applicants and in favour of Jewish medical applicants….Most concerningly, no other bystanders [on Discord] stepped in to challenge these narratives, raising questions as to the moral fibre and character of the medical student applicant pool in Quebec and their ability to correctly identify and stand up to racism, sexism and Jew hatred.” n

Quebec med school applicants posted antisemitic, racist messages Read More »

Coroner, CSL investigating after senior killed by tree branch

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Quebec Coroner and the City of Côte St. Luc are investigating after a branch of a city tree fell on the head of a 76-year-old woman at the corner of Queen Mary Road and Macdonald early Saturday afternoon.

The victim was in critical condition as of Saturday night, but later passed away. There are many older trees in the area, which borders both Hampstead and Snowdon.

Police, paramedics and firefighters responded to the scene. The SPVM does not believe the incident was criminal, and the Coroner has taken over the investigation.

The City of Côte St. Luc issued a statement, saying officials are “shocked by the tragic incident.

“Côte St. Luc EMS first responders arrived quickly on scene, and the individual was transported to hospital by Urgences-Santé. This is a shocking and rare tragedy and CSL will be conducting a full investigation to determine what happened.”

The CSL statement added that an arborist was conducting a full investigation and the city had blocked off the area until necessary pruning had taken place.

“Public safety is our highest priority. We are committed to understanding what happened and taking all appropriate measures.”

At the May 12 CSL council meeting, Mayor Mitchell Brownstein expressed condolences to the family of the victim, Ljubica Milicevic, who came to Montreal from Serbia and was the French librarian at Solomon Schechter Academy as well as an author.

“It’s a great loss to the community,” Brownstein added.

The Suburban noted that there were fairly high winds in the vicinity on Friday. As well, two years ago, in the aftermath of the 2023 ice storm, a branch fell off a tree right next to myself as I was seated on a bench in nearby Macdonald Park in Snowdon. n

Coroner, CSL investigating after senior killed by tree branch Read More »

Hampstead’s Levi, Steinberg clash over parkspace

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The May 5 Hampstead council meeting was almost filled to capacity, and featured a clash between Mayor Jeremy Levi and his predecessor William Steinberg over the potential future of park space at the corner of Queen Mary and Northcote.

Before the meeting, Steinberg circulated a flier based on meeting agenda item 9.2, the “awarding of a contract to Profusion Immobilier Inc. for real estate broker services for the sale mandate of four lots owned by the Town of Hampstead.” Steinberg, who got more information about the item from a source, claimed in the flier that Hampstead is about to sell the Northcote park space “so that two enormous homes can be built there.

“No consultation, no referendum, no notice — just a small item on the agenda which does not even identify which lots are being sold,” the flier says.

At the meeting, before question period, Levi explained that the item was being deferred because of public reaction the previous weekend and that there was never any vote intended at that meeting for the sale of the land, “full stop.”

The Mayor explained that council brainstormed last summer over the possibility of selling the piece of land, potentially a $6 million transaction, and the town then gathered more information. A public consultation would then follow, he added.

“For Item 9.2, the purpose of giving out a mandate was to have a real estate firm create a rendering of what potential two single-family homes at that corner would look like. Council is trying to be extremely objective. What we’re trying to do is come up with creative ways that the town can increase revenue to fast track [ways to] better our infrastructure, parks and recreation services, community services and, in doing so, we need to find a balance of what are acceptable parameters that the public accepts.”

Levi also pointed out that the town’s intention is to “come up with options, present them to the public and discuss them. If it works, great, if it doesn’t, put it to the side.”

The Mayor also pointed out that the park land is actually zoned as residential, and thus not subject to a zoning referendum if the town decided to sell the land for housing; and even if there was a referendum, the entire town would participate, not just area residents. Levi said he would not feel comfortable selling the land if just over 50 percent of residents voted to do so, because so many would have opposed the selling option.

“We are not trying to hide anything.”

Residents at the meeting strongly expressed their opposition to the selling of the parkland, with one urging the town to zone the area as a park almost immediately. Levi said the flier had misinformation, which Steinberg strongly denied.

Steinberg, during his second time at the microphone, quoted an email written to him by Levi saying that council would “probably” have a consultation. Levi said he wrote the email at midnight. “I don’t think we should get caught up on semantics,” the Mayor said.

“When I put information out, I’m very careful and I say only what’s true,” Steinberg responded.

“And you said that ‘this is your last chance to stop it’ in the flier, which is not true!” Levi said. “You said that they were going to build enormous homes, which is not true! We haven’t even seen a rendering, how do we know?!” n

Hampstead’s Levi, Steinberg clash over parkspace Read More »

Jewish Unity Expo was a Vegas-style success

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Montreal Jewish Unity Expo, bringing together 212 businesses and firms and thousands of attendees including Ensemble Montreal leader Soraya Martinez Ferrada for a day of networking, took place May 6 on Côte de Liesse Road in St. Laurent.

The event attracted a wide variety of companies, including real estate, sellers of cameras, power cleaning, 3D printing, a real estate virtual reality photographer, law firms like Choueke Hollander and Spiegel Ryan, mattress companies and many more.

Isaac Blackman, co-founder of the event with Martin Weiss, told The Suburban the expo was conceived six months ago and is the first such event at this scale — a previous event five years before had 30 booths.

“Fast forward, take a look around, at [about 1 p.m,], there were 3,688 people at this venue, and counting, thank God,” he said. “The concept of the event is supporting your fellow Jew, supporting another business, supporting another friend, bringing together every single community. Everyone is here to have a good time — network, support each other and walk out with connections.”

Blackman added that “everyone here so far, that I’ve heard, has built businesses, got contracts and leads. It’s amazing!”

Weiss, the co-founder of the event, said the original idea was that the “glue of the show was going to be real estate, that the exhibitors could talk to one another in that world.

“But we also expanded to have a little bit more fun, some food, some plant-based meat, things like that. But most of the show is real estate-based.”

The Suburban spoke with some of the exhibitors, and they were very pleased with how the event was proceeding.

Adam Spiro, who specializes in commercial restructuring and insolvency at the Spiegel Ryan law firm, said the firm decided to be part of the event as “we contribute to the Jewish community, we have a lot of Jewish clients, and wanted to be part of such a beautiful event!

“We couldn’t not be here. I met people I’ve spoken to on the phone a hundred times, and I met so many new people who will hopefully become clients, and hopefully friends too. I hope they do this event next year!”

Brian Breitstein of Wrap Demons, which transforms the look of vehicles with custom wraps as well as car colour changes and commercial vehicle graphics, said the event has been beneficial for the company.

“I’ve met a lot of people, I made a lot of contacts and a lot of people have taken my card, and I encountered a lot of businesses that need their trucks wrapped. There are more people here than I expected!”

Alina Tertychna of Groupe Monerix, an employment consultant, said “it’s a very nice event, lots of nice people and great information. Very useful!” n

Jewish Unity Expo was a Vegas-style success Read More »

Montreal police chief defends handling of Cavendish anti-Israel protest

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Montreal police chief Fady Dagher responded to The Suburban about the SPVM’s handling of the April 7 anti-Israel protest at Quartier Cavendish in Côte St. Luc.

While the police moved the protesters away from the CineStarz theatre where a special showing of the documentary October 8, about the rise of antisemitism since the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel, took place, the agitators were allowed to stay in the mall for more than two hours.

Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein and the mall ownership had called on the police to eject the protesters, citing Criminal Code provisions against intimidation, and Brownstein and Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather reinforced this point in a letter to the Plante administration. Police on the scene said they could not take this action unless the protesters committed a crime, and that they could stay in a public access on private property.

Dagher was asked about this by The Suburban following his April 25 visit with students at Gardenview Elementary School in St. Laurent.

“It all depends on the situation, every situation is different,” the police chief said. “We have lawyers who work with the police department and they let us know when it is the time to act. We have some events where the police act right away during those demonstrations and in the last year and a half, we made more than 120 arrests.”

Dagher said police actions depend on the timing and the rules officers follow — each situation is different, and sometimes non-intervention is appropriate.

“It’s always depending on the circumstances. The police department never wants to start something, we want to resolve the issues, so we have to find the right time.”

Housefather and Brownstein had also written to the Plante administration that the SPVM’s decision not to eject the anti-Israel protesters “stands in stark contrast to the police response in other jurisdictions where trespassing on private property has led to prompt enforcement. It also underscores a broader and deeply troubling inconsistency in how public safety is being ensured on the Island of Montreal.”

Dagher acknowledged to The Suburban that different cities in Canada have different policies emanating from the rules of their municipality.

“But for the Criminal Code, we always get assisted by our lawyers. The Criminal Code is for everyone in Canada, but again, we have to find exactly the right moment, the needs for what is happening and when we have the right tools — then we intervene. Sometimes it feels very frustrating for the people to see that the police are not acting, but it’s not because they don’t want to. They have to make sure they have the right legal argument to be able to advance.” n

Montreal police chief defends handling of Cavendish anti-Israel protest Read More »

8,000 Montrealers celebrate Israel!

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

More than 8,000 Montrealers turned out in picture perfect spring weather to celebrate Israel’s 77th rebirth, and to show their strong support a year and a half after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack and solidarity with 59 hostages still held by the terrorist group.

The popular event began this year at Macdonald Park in Côte des Neiges-NDG, and a joyous parade of blue and white — with superb security provided by the SPVM— paraded down Dupuis to Décarie Blvd., Plamondon, Westbury and finally to Van Horne Park.

The festivities, organized by the Jewish Unity Partnership, were led by Cantor Daniel Benlolo and James Karls Entertainment.

Numerous dignitaries and notables were on hand, including Israel Consul-General Paul Hirschson in his final Montreal Yom Ha’atzmaut celebration before returning to Israel, German Consul-General Susanne Aschi-Glesius, Romanian Consul-General Tullia-Imola Balla; leaders of the Filipino community, who are longtime supporters of Israel; Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather and former Conservative candidate Neil Oberman; D’Arcy McGee MNA Elisabeth Prass; Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein; Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi, former Mayor William Steinberg; Canadian Magen David Adom national president Arlène Madar-Abitan, and students from Montreal’s Jewish day schools, amongst many others.

Moments of silence were held for the over 2,000 Israelis killed since Oct.7 and for the 59 hostages still held by Hamas including the late Canadian Judi Weinstein Haggai.

The attendees also paid homage and stood in solidarity with the Filipino community after the tragedy that occurred in Vancouver with the car ramming attack against members of the Filipino community that resulted in eleven deaths and dozens injured.

Hirschson told the massive audience the sad news of the major fire which destroyed the Jewish National Fund’s Canada Park, in existence since 1975 and largely established by the Montreal Jewish community.

“We will rebuild Canada Park completely!” he said.

Hirschson also pointed out that the terrorist leaders who attacked Israel Oct. 7 and before and after, including the leaders of Hamas and Hezbollah, are now dead.

“Iranians have been exposed as weak! As is described in polite society, f–k around and find out!”

The Consul-General added that the remaining hostages are being “held in torture. Until they come home, this war cannot begin to end!”

Regarding Judi Weinstein Haggai, whose body remains in Gaza, “I would like to hear the Canadian government, media and society in general care a little more about her!”

Hirschson also said Jewish unity “is not just a core value, it’s fundamental to our winning, without which we’ll be in trouble.”

He also encouraged members of the community to make aliyah to Israel, “just to make me happy!

“Come home! Come be a player on the winning team of the 21st century!”

Of nearby anti-Israel protesters, he said, “they’re losers! Don’t ever be scared! They are louder than they are many! We have far more friends in Montreal, Quebec and throughout Canada than they have or ever will have! We are builders and winners!”

In a video message, Israeli President Isaac Herzog said “we cannot but be aware of the constant sacrifices [the Jewish state] demands of us, they are many!

“Since Oct. 7, 2023, we in Israel have been engaged in a fight for the safety and integrity of our society!” he added. “So many from across Israel – and communities around the world – are still on the frontlines, fighting the dark force of terror that threatens us all, and defending the very fabric of the free world!”

The Israeli president added that the country’s hearts break “each moment anew at the ongoing atrocity of our sisters and brothers buried deep underground, dead and alive, in a brutal violation of every legal, human, and ethical code. There is no question that we cannot begin to truly heal – nor can we be whole – until every last one of them is freed. At the same time, antisemitism has come charging forward in so many forms throughout the globe. It has radically challenged the basic sense of safety of communities everywhere.”

Federation CJA board chair Steve Sebag urged the crowd to look at Israel’s flag, “…this beautiful flag! A symbol of a people that refuses to disappear! The symbol of victory! Israel is strong!

“Israel is powerful, moral and it’s ours! When you try to isolate us, we get louder! When you try to shame us, we lift our heads high! Our generation knows exactly where we stand! We stand with Israel, we stand with its people, with its soldiers, with its future! Today, while rockets fall and lies spread, Israel stands stronger, smarter, braver and more beautiful than ever! Wear the flag like armour, because when you raise the flag, you raise every generation! Am Yisrael Chai!”

The event concluded with drawings for a trip to Israel and a Visa gift card for a student, and the singing of O Canada and Hatikvah. n

8,000 Montrealers celebrate Israel! Read More »

Montreal police chief enthrals St. Laurent elementary students

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Montreal police chief Fady Dagher enthralled students at Gardenview Elementary School in St. Laurent last Friday, telling them about his life in Montreal and with the SPVM.

Dagher, a longtime resident of St. Laurent, pointed out that his three children attended Gardenview. The police chief was joined at the school by St. Laurent Mayor Alan DeSousa and councillors Vana Nazarian, Aref Salem and Jacques Cohen, and from the English Montreal School Board, Director-General Nicholas Katalifos, Board Vice-Chairman and St. Laurent Commissioner James Kromida; Demetrios Giannacopoulos, Regional Director (West), and Assistant Director-General Pela Nickoletopoulos.

Dagher told the students and staff that returning to Gardenview was an emotional experience.

“Gardenview was always in my heart, and will always stay in my heart,” he said to much applause. “This is also the first time I’ve come to an elementary school and met with the kids.”

Dagher was first interviewed by Mike Cohen, manager of marketing and communications at the EMSB, and then answered very intelligent and perceptive questions from the students. The police chief, who speaks five languages perfectly, told Cohen that when he was growing up, he aspired to be an architect.

“But to be honest with you, I wasn’t good in mathematics. Then I wanted to be the manager of a big store in Montreal. But one day, a police officer in uniform came in to a store to buy a pair of glasses.”

Dagher then asked about the officer’s work, and was invited to join him on a ride-a-long, and the future chief’s career path was set. He also went back to school at the age of 42 to get an Executive Masters degree in Business Administration at McGill and HEC.

“I remember sitting in our dining room doing my homework and my three kids, who were here at Gardenview, were doing their homework at the same time as me. They said, ‘Dad, why are you studying?’ I told them ‘I didn’t finish what I wanted to finish when I was 20 years old.’”

Now, he leads more than 5,000 police officers, and a total of 6,500 people in the SPVM. He advised the students to pursue their dreams and not give up.

The students were then asked what a police chief does. One student said, “he tells every other officer what to do, like he’s the king.”

“Are you the king?” Cohen asked.

“No, I’m not the king,” Dagher said. “But yes, you’re right, I tell my police officers what we are to do, where we’re going. I guide my people, but I’m not the king.”

Another student asked why Dagher wanted to become police chief.

“In 2009-2010, I was the commander of a police station, and I saw what we were able to do with the community, and I didn’t just want to do that in one neighbourhood.”

One student asked, “what is the coolest part of your job?”

“It’s a tough job,” Dagher said. “But the coolest part of my career was when I was undercover, buying drugs to get them off the street, so that kids wouldn’t have any access to them. I loved that period of my life, because I was able to make the city safer. That was a great time, from 1992 to 1996, one of the best times of my career.”

Then came the most provocative question. “Do you ever use your gun?” asked a student.

“I’m surprised that question didn’t come earlier,” Dagher joked. “Yes, I used it, but I never fired it. I took it out, but I never shot anybody, and thank God.” n

Montreal police chief enthrals St. Laurent elementary students Read More »

Senior dies after accident at Place Vertu

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

One senior died and another one was seriously injured after being pinned against a car by a motorist in an accident that took place at around 3:15 p.m. Thursday April 17 in the parking lot of Place Vertu in St. Laurent, near the entrance leading to the Uniprix pharmacy and Canadian Tire.

This was the second major incident to happen in one day at the borough — hours earlier, overnight, a man was stabbed to death in a building in the area of Beaudet and Décarie Blvd. A 40-year-old man was arrested in that incident.

When The Suburban arrived at Place Vertu in the early evening, the SPVM investigation was still underway with police tape surrounding a large area of the parking lot. The two cars involved in the accident were still in the lot, including one that was severely damaged. The motorist involved was still being interviewed by police inside the mall.

SPVM spokesperson Marianne Allaire Morin, who was on site, told The Suburban that police received a 911 call at about 3:15 p.m.

“What we know is that a driver was backing up when he collided with the two pedestrians, and they were seriously injured and brought to hospital in critical condition,” she added.

The 97-year-old women was out of danger but seriously injured.

The 89-year-old man, prominent member of the Montreal Greek community and a mechanic by profession George Spanakis, was in critical condition and was first said to be out of danger, but he passed away April 19, police announced April 21. His daughter Maria Spanakis spoke out after some cruel posters on social media alleged that the victims were driving. She wrote on Facebook that “I am fiercely protective of my dad and it angers me that people are jumping to conclusions and showing anger and judgment about a whole lotta stuff -like the facts they do not have….Where did truthfulness, integrity and human compassion go?”

She told CTV News that “I just felt it was devoid and empty and only sensationalizing the event without any humanity associated to it. We have to remind ourselves there are human beings who are grieving and suffering at the other end of those mean-spirited comments.”

The driver, who is 80 years old, was not charged and police consider the incident purely an accident. He was not treated for shock, nor was he injured. n

Senior dies after accident at Place Vertu Read More »

Montrealers commemorate Yom Hashoah

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg

The Montreal community turned out in large numbers last Wednesday at Côte St. Luc’s Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem synagogue for the annual Yom HaShoah ceremony to commemorate the Holocaust.

The Montreal Holocaust Museum (MHM)-organized event, with this year’s theme being “I want you to remember… a childhood lost,” attracted numerous dignitaries, including Israeli Consul-General David Levy, Premier Philippe Couillard, numerous consular officials, MPs including Anthony Housefather of Mount Royal and Emmanuella Lambropoulos (St. Laurent), D’Arcy McGee MNA David Birnbaum and his predecessor Lawrence Bergman; and mayors and council members from such cities and boroughs such as Côte St. Luc, Hampstead, St. Laurent, Dollard des Ormeaux and others.

Ruth Najman, co-chair with Doris Steg of the MHM’s Yom HaShoah Committee, told the large audience that “we are the last generation to hear the voices of Holocaust survivors in person, and to meet and know them. This is both a privilege and a responsibility.”

Couillard praised the Jewish community’s contributions to Quebec, and included Hebrew and Yiddish in his opening greeting. He also recognized Lawrence Bergman’s role in having Yom HaShoah recognized in the National Assembly more than 18 years ago.

“Today, Quebec is your home,” the Premier told the Jewish community. “You are justly proud of your unwavering commitment to sharing with those less fortunate, to building and nurturing communities, and justly proud of this defiant, hopeful and lasting response to the ultimate tragedy of the Holocaust.”

Levy, the new Israeli Consul-General, said that the purpose of Yom HaShoah “is not just to state the facts as they are, but to ensure the memory of the Holocaust remains part of our collective consciousness, ingrained in the very fibre of humanity as a whole. This becomes more important year after year, as each day brings us closer to that moment when the Holocaust will cease to be a living memory.”

Six Holocaust survivors, with members of their families, lit memorial candles. They included:

• Mario Polèse, born in 1943 in the Netherlands, who survived with his parents thanks to “the heroism of thousands of Dutch people — but also thanks to luck, I see no other word.”

• Zissel Farkas, born in 1928 in Romania, who survived Auschwitz with the help of her older sister Suri. Farkas now has three children, 26 grandchildren and 70 great-grandchildren.

• Muguette Myers, born in 1931 in Paris, who survived in the town of Champlost and was liberated by the Americans in 1944. “During the war, I was never afraid when I was with my mother because she had a very strong character and took care of everything,” Myers said.

• Ernest Ehrmann, born in 1928 in the former Czechoslovakia, who survived 10 months in four concentration camps but lost his parents and one of his sisters at Auschwitz. “I consider it to be a great gift that I survived, a gift not to be taken for granted,” he said.

• Eva Verebres, born in 1935 in Hungary, who survived in Budapest as the Soviets battled the Germans in January 1945. She lost most of her family, including her mother. “My children and grandchildren are the living example that Hitler did not succeed completely,” she said.

• Leo Kliot, born in 1929 in Lithuania, who narrowly escaped the liquidation of the Vilna ghetto, and was liberated by the Russians in 1944.

Readings were provided by past March of the Living participants Jeremy Levett and Samantha Bloom, as well as granddaughter of survivors Nancy Sculnick. Cantor David Sebbag of the Adath congregation led the Memorial Prayer, Rabbi Boris Dolin of Congregation Dorshei Emet recited the T’hillim and survivor Max Kulik led the Kaddish prayer. Musical accompaniment came from the Jewish People’s and Peretz Schools Grade 6 choir as well as survivor Fishel Goldig, directed by Jason Rosenblatt.

Montrealers commemorate Yom Hashoah Read More »

Dr. Lawrence Rosenberg named by Newsweek as one of world’s top hospital CEOs

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Newsweek magazine has recognized Dr. Lawrence Rosenberg of the Jewish General Hospital, president and CEO of the CIUSSS West-Central Montreal, as one of the world’s 25 top hospital CEOs.

Rosenberg is also a Professor of Surgery and Medicine at McGill University, and was one of three Canadians honoured. The American magazine named Rosenberg’s many accomplishments and pointed out that the author of Patients Matter Most: How Healthcare Is Becoming Personal Again “implemented the first provincial connected health innovation & research incubator (OROT) as part of his ‘Care Everywhere’ vision. Dr. Rosenberg has extensive experience as a clinician-scientist, educator, and consultant in value-based health systems and management of change.”

Newsweek, in an article describing how they chose the top hospital CEOs, explained that “while each of these executives have their own skill sets and stories, they have managed to lead their organizations to great success….A few common themes recurred throughout our conversations: a concern for delivering the most impactful patient care, a curiosity about artificial intelligence and what it could mean for the future of medicine, and a real warmth when discussing the team members that they work alongside.”

“While the CEOs stand out for their acumen regarding health care management, they acknowledge that working among a capable team focused on bettering the lives of their patients is what makes these hospitals among the world’s best.” n

Dr. Lawrence Rosenberg named by Newsweek as one of world’s top hospital CEOs Read More »

Liberals win Mount Royal, Outremont, St. Laurent

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The federal Liberal strongholds in the west end of Montreal maintained that status Monday night, although for a large part of the evening, the Mount Royal race was quite tight.

Anthony Housefather was declared the winner at around 12:15 a.m. Tuesday, but the evening started off as a nailbiter between him and Conservative candidate Neil Oberman. The riding has been Liberal since 1940, but has previously come out strong for the Conservatives, particularly when Stephen Harper was Prime Minister. As of Tuesday morning, with 203 of 204 polls reporting, Housefather had 50.9 percent of the vote to 40.67 percent for Oberman, 4.65 percent for the NDP and 3.3 percent for the BQ. In 2021, Housefather won with 57 percent of the vote to 24.46 percent for the Conservatives.

“Thank you to the people of Mount Royal for once again putting their trust in me, serving my riding and country is the honour of a lifetime,” Housefather posted.

Oberman, reacting to the call during the evening of a Liberal minority government, told The Suburban, ”people have a vote, they have a voice, they have a choice and they want change.

“This is not a referendum on a single person,” he added. “This is a referendum on a party, on their policies and on their politics.”

At Housefather headquarters, his supporters reflected on the short but intense campaign in Mount Royal.

“I thought the campaign at times was not as respectful as I would have liked,” said Côte St. Luc councillor Steven Erdelyi. “Anthony Housefather has been an excellent MP, the best MP I’ve ever had the chance to work with.”

Also at his headquarters were CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein, Marvin Rotrand of United Against Hate and former D’Arcy McGee MNA Lawrence Bergman, the co-chair of Housefather’s campaign.

“We reached a lot of people throughout the campaign, and had a great group of volunteers,” Bergman told The Suburban.

The Liberals won more easily and quickly in the St. Laurent and Outremont ridings, where Emmanuella Lambropoulos and Rachel Bendayan respectively were declared the winners before midnight. As of Tuesday morning with 170 of 171 polls reporting, Bendayan won with 55 percent of the vote, to 12.6 percent for the Conservatives, 12.2 percent for the BQ, 10.6 percent for the NDP and 9.67 percent for the Green Party and its co-leader Jonathan Pedneault.

“Thank you from the bottom of my heart for your trust,” Bendayan posted along with a video showing her reaction to her victory.

In St. Laurent, with 164 of 166 polls reporting Lambropoulos was the winner with 59.1 percent, to the Conservatives with 28 percent, the BQ at 5.7 percent, the NDP at 4.5 percent and the Green Party at 1.6 percent. n

Liberals win Mount Royal, Outremont, St. Laurent Read More »

Hampstead council questioned on pool fees

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Hampstead resident Adriana Decker questioned council last week on the town’s increased pool fees, which have been previously justified as a way to keep property taxes as low as possible.

Residents had complained in 2023 about a daily pass for the pool at Hampstead Park being $15 for residents three years old and up, with one resident saying it would cost $75 to bring her family. In late July, the price structure was changed to $10 for residents 18 and under, and $35 for a family pass as long as all members could provide proof they were Hampstead residents. The daily pass price has been $25 for non-residents.

Decker, who was a prominent voice in principle against the redevelopment of an apartment building on Côte St. Luc Road in 2019, said that according to statistics, 4,692 daily passes for the pool were purchased when the price was lower, with income totalling $30,727.

“In 2024, there were only 837 tickets sold, which is insane how increasing the price has limited access to the pool, and the total revenue was only $17,431,” she would. “Why have we increased the price of the single ticket if it hasn’t increased revenue? If you look at the family pass in 2022, the revenue was $23,944 and in 2024, it was $28,240. The difference is nothing. This has decreased the amount of people who can enjoy the pool. I’m one of those people. Please have a discussion about this.”

Mayor Jeremy Levi said the intent of the current fees was never to limit access to the the pool.

“I understand that might be the appearance of it, it was certainly not the intent,” the Mayor explained. “The intent is to try to be as fiscally responsible as possible. Even though there may not be a significant change in revenue, there is a significant change in the operating costs. We do not need as many lifeguards, because there’s not as many people” using the pool.

Levi also said the pool does not need as much maintenance and upkeep as previously.

“What has the difference [in savings] been, does anyone know?” Decker asked.

Levi said he did not have that information.

“I’ve had many discussions with many people — when I grew up in this town, the pool was very different than what it is today,” the Mayor explained. “The neighbourhood was very different. We issue permits for about 12 private pools every year now. In terms of this mandate, that’s about 50 to 60 new private pools, which means 50 to 60 families no longer using the public pool.”

The Mayor said the town is trying to find a balance.

“I know that when we had day passes of $2 or $3 for non-residents, a very big part of the users were non-residents and there was a very big opinion that if we were losing $100,000 on the upkeep of the pool, why we are we subsidizing it to non-residents? We wanted to make it amenable, where it’s geared towards residents. Everything we do, our interest is for the residents. Not to limit access, for sure not.”

Hampstead council questioned on pool fees Read More »

American director says Montreal seems like Ground Zero for Jew hatred

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Wendy Sachs, the American director and executive producer of the documentary October 8, came to Montreal last week to show solidarity with Concordia and McGill students victimized by anti-Israel protesters and to denounce a lack of police action against those protesters.

The film chronicles the explosion of antisemitism that took place after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel, in which 1,200 people were killed and 250 kidnapped.

Sachs was outside Concordia’s downtown Hall Building, along with Concordia Jewish student Anastasia Zorchinsky, also head of the student group StartUp Nation; and Muslim McGill student Raihaana Adira. The group was near Concordia’s Azrieli Institute of Israel Studies, which was vandalized just before the Jewish holiday of Passover.

At Canadian showings of the film, Sachs says, “we’re seeing insane protests — people who were trying to see the film were stopped by protesters, security and police had to be called in.” One of those protests took place at Quartier Cavendish in Côte St. Luc April 7.

“The level of antisemitism exploding here in Montreal, it seems like Ground Zero for Jew hatred right now,” she added. “That’s why I came here, I’m getting DMs (direct messages), text messages and emails from people in Toronto and Montreal, saying to me ‘I want to see your film, I’m afraid to go to the theatre in Montreal because of the hate.’”

The Suburban asked Sachs for her reaction to the Quartier Cavendish protest, during which police said they could not eject the activists because they had not committed a crime, notwithstanding CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein citing to them the Criminal Code provision against intimidation.

“It’s really disappointing, and this is what we’ve seen with campus protests around the world, and in the streets of London and New York where they’re just not shutting it down,” Sachs said. “There’s sometimes a confusion between free speech and hate speech, and that’s what we’re seeing on university campuses in the States. When you’re crossing the line into harassment, bullying and real threats, it’s very scary. It seems with the Jewish community, it’s more permissive to harass.”

Adira, 21, said there is a double standard taking place regarding protests. “If this was the Jewish community protesting the Muslim community, it would be shut down so fast,” she said. “The situation on campus has been horrible. I was bullied and harassed off of student government for saying October 7 was not heroic and for calling it what it was — a terrorist attack.” The McGill student added the situation at Quartier Cavendish is “really reflective of what’s happening at our campuses and synagogues. At [last year’s] event at the Shaar Hashomayim Synagogue, the protesters were chanting ‘Raihaana, Raihaana, you’re a terrorist!’ I was horrified! They knew my face and my name. On campus, they take pictures of me and post them on social media. I’m regularly called a baby killer, a genocide lover and a Zionazi. This doesn’t happen to students who glorify terrorism.”

Zorchinsky, 20, said everyone should follow the law. “I saw what happened at Cavendish Mall, and I was really disappointed with the reaction of the police,” she told The Suburban. “We see that on campus with protests almost every single week. I’ve been harassed, my life has been threatened many times and there have been no consequences to those students.” The Concordia student also said she was not allowed on campus during Rage Week, during the first anniversary of the terrorist attack, despite having an injunction.”The police stopped me, saying ‘it’s not safe for you.’ Every person who had a Palestinian flag, who had a keffiyeh, was able to pass by and protest right here. There’s some sort of double standard.”

Sachs agreed. “The double standards are just so alarming.” n

American director says Montreal seems like Ground Zero for Jew hatred Read More »

Montreal, Mayors want feds to preserve airport greenspace

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The City of Montreal, the borough of St. Laurent and the City of Dorval are asking the federal parties vying for election to commit to preserving the green space north of Trudeau Airport.

Mayors Alan DeSousa (St. Laurent), Marc Doret (Dorval), Montreal executive committee member responsible for large parks Alex Norris and Clifford Lincoln, former Quebec environment minister and MP, held a press conference recently at Golf Dorval to present a united stand.

As previously reported by The Suburban, a brief presented by Aéroports de Montréal last December indicates plans to exclude 155 hectares, equivalent to four lots, from the Sources Nature Park and to develop an area of over 100 hectares that would include Monarch Fields, a habitat for the endangered monarch butterfly. The ADM has also said it is preserving 25 hectares of land, and that having part of a nature park and its wildlife located so close to the airport and its runways would create a danger, such as birds flying close to or into planes.

DeSousa told The Suburban that the groups want the lands owned by the federal government north of the 85-year-old airport to be preserved “for generations to come.

“These are green spaces that total about 170 hectares and would be the nexus of a great way to preserve biodiversity in the greater Montreal regions. It has the potential of being one of the largest parks on the island of Montreal. It protects biodiversity, endangered species and it’s easily accessible from the new REM — Montrealers would definitely see the benefits.”

The group also says that “the areas zoned as ‘green spaces’ include lots 3, 4 and 5 on the St. Laurent side, as well as lot 20 attached to Dorval, which is under federal control and leased to ADM. This 121-hectare area, corresponding to the former Dorval golf course, remains open to commercial development, and ADM plans to set up a decarbonation plant on that location.”

Doret said that “protecting biodiversity is an issue that we deeply care about, and the destruction of such a precious environmental area would be disastrous. We invite federal representatives to recognize the richness of this ecological gem in our backyard.”

Lincoln pointed out that the federal government “committed to creating a National Urban Parks (NUP) program as early as 2020, a project that received a $130 million contribution following a 2021 meeting between Parks Canada and the mayors of the country’s major cities.

“Unfortunately, Montreal is not on Parks Canada’s list of projected NUPs. This is an omission that must be urgently corrected.”

Norris said that the natural environments involved are “among the most biodiverse on the Island of Montreal.

“Our position is clear — these federal lands must be protected. By working together, we are convinced that we can reconcile the needs of ADM, an important economic partner, while ensuring the protection of this green lung.”

David Fletcher of the Green Coalition told The Suburban that he was pleased with the case made by the group.

“The motivating factor, we think, for the ADM is the profitability of leasing out these lands to companies, and these don’t have anything to do with airport operations. That hasn’t been expressed by the ADM, but we have to ask the questions. The issue of bird strikes and the security of passengers, the record worldwide shows there is not a great probability of those incidents happening.” n

Montreal, Mayors want feds to preserve airport greenspace Read More »

McGill obtains injunction against SPHR

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill University has announced that Quebec Superior Court granted its request for a provisional injunction against Students for Palestinian Honour and Resistance (SPHR).

The injunction had been sought just after a three-day student strike at McGill during which classes were interrupted, Jewish students intimidated and much vandalism committed. The university pointed out that the injunction was needed at this time as exams are underway.

McGill president Deep Saini pointed out that the ruling states “McGill has a clear right to an order that allows it to carry out its academic activities without obstruction” and that “McGill is entitled to the protection of its property.”

More specifically, the court ruled that SPHR and any person aware of the judgment, “must not block or obstruct the entrance to any building where McGill is operating; must not engage in protests within five metres of any building where McGill is operating; and must not obstruct the delivery or performance of academic activities such as courses or exams.”

The provisional judgment was put in force for a 10-day period.

“The university applied for the injunction following SPHR’s involvement in classroom obstructions and vandalism during a three-day student strike April 2-4, 2025,” Saini explained. “In his decision, the judge recognized the harm done to the McGill community by protest activities that resulted in vandalism, violence, and intimidation tactics.”

The ruling also stated that “violence, intimidation and the destruction of property cannot be tolerated in this country, least of all at our universities, whose very mission is to foster learning and the expression of opinion through peaceful, respectful dialogue.”

Saini reiterated, as he did in his previous message to the community on this issue, that he will “vigorously defend everyone’s right to free expression and peaceful assembly, while also protecting our campus from abuses of these freedoms, especially when they hurt our academic mission or cause injury to others.

“Many of you are working steadfastly to maintain stability in our community despite differing viewpoints on a range of very challenging and sensitive topics. Thank you so much for this work, which supports the teaching, learning and research that we so cherish.” n

McGill obtains injunction against SPHR Read More »

Man stabbed to death in St. Laurent

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The SPVM are investigating after a man was stabbed to death in a building at Beaudet and Décarie in St. Laurent at about 4:10 a.m. April 17.

The murder is the ninth to take place on the island of Montreal this year. The 30-year-old victim was rushed to hospital in critical condition but succumbed to his injuries, SPVM spokesman Jean-Pierre Brabant said. A 40-year-old man has been arrested, and is being questioned by officers. The case is in the hands of the SPVM’s Major Crimes Unit. Police say the two men know each other and are looking into the circumstances that led up to the incident.

The victim apparently made it outside the building before collapsing on a sidewalk. He had suffered injuries to the upper part of his body, from a sharp object, police said. Brabant added that a perimeter was set up in the area, resulting in the closure of Décarie between De l’Église and Beaudet.

This incident is the latest of many violent crimes committed in the borough in recent years, including shootings, stabbings, and fires set to cars at homes and businesses.

Recent similar incidents have included:

• In January, a 25-year-old man stabbed while eating in a restaurant at the Norgate Shopping Centre at the corner of Côte Vertu and Décarie.

• Last April, an employee of the Ultramar gas station at Côte Vertu and Marcel-Laurin was stabbed by an assailant. The SPVM said at the time that the assailant, for unknown reasons, climbed over the counter and stabbed the employee several times in the upper body. That area of the borough was the scene of arson attacks on restaurants.

• In March 2024, a stabbing took place during a fight amongst 20 people on Crépeau Street. People were on the street after a fire alarm was pulled in their building. n

Man stabbed to death in St. Laurent Read More »

CSL looking to honour Oct. 7 victims

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Côte St. Luc council is looking into ways to honour members of the Bibas family who were brutally murdered by the terrorist group Hamas following their Oct. 7, 2023 attack on Israel, and potentially other victims as well, CSL councillors told The Suburban.

The city has already honoured Alexandre Look, a former CSL resident, who was killed by Hamas terrorists at the Nova music festival as he defended others. A greenspace, located between Beth Chabad Synagogue and Bialik High School (now JPPS Bialik) at the eastern tip of Kildare Road, was dedicated at a very well attended and emotional ceremony last September.

The Suburban made the inquiry about honouring other victims after seeing a posting on the Côte Saint-Luc Families Facebook page in which a resident referenced a previous suggestion that a Côte St. Luc park or street be named after members of the Bibas family. Shiri Bibas, and her children Ariel, 4, and Kfir, 10 months old, were found by Israeli authorities to have been murdered by Hamas. The bodies of the children were paraded through Gaza before being returned to Israel.

The Facebook poster suggested that the wading pool at Yitzhak Rabin Park in District 5 be named in honour of the Bibas family. Rabin was the Prime Minister of Israel who was assassinated in late 1995. Some respondents suggested emailing area councillor Mitch Kujavsky for his thoughts.

The Suburban emailed members of council about the wading pool idea. Mike Cohen, who has the toponymy (city landmark naming) portfolio on CSL council, said, “we have not discussed this, but the intention of the city regarding victims of Oct. 7 is to do so at Alexendre Look Place.”

Kujavsky told The Suburban that he was emailed about the wading pool by a constituent and said the idea was definitely worth discussing in council. “We originally thought it would be nice to have memorials related to Oct. 7 in one central location, which would be Alexandre Look Place near Chabad, but we’ll be discussing all possibilities in the near future.” n

CSL looking to honour Oct. 7 victims Read More »

Cotler home split in Mount Royal election

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

As those who follow politics know, it’s not unusual for close family members to differ on who they support in elections, but that is usually expressed within the confines of a home or perhaps amongst close friends and relatives.

The most famous case of a very public family split, and a good-natured one, has been between James Carville, the folksy and sometimes wild campaign strategist for former President Bill Clinton; and his wife Mary Matalin, who served under Presidents Ronald Reagan, George Bush and his son George W. Bush. They’ve appeared on TV together over the years to express their differing opinions.

The Mount Royal riding has its own prominent husband and wife who are voting different ways, and are expressing their choices publicly.

Former federal Justice Minister and former Mount Royal MP Irwin Cotler has been quoted as supporting his successor, Anthony Housefather, for re-election. Housefather posted the quote and a picture of himself and Cotler on April 6.

The Irwin Cotler quote says, “Anthony Housefather has been an exemplary Member of Parliament. His business and legal career, as well as his time as a councillor and Mayor, prepared him to truly deliver for his constituents. He fights for the communities he represents and does so with commitment and integrity. It is my pleasure to work closely with him and to endorse his reelection.”

(Notably, Cotler made another personal – not party – endorsement of Bloc Québécois Lac Saint-Jean MP Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe, saying he “has been an outstanding member of Parliament, a leading voice for the struggle for human rights domestically and internationally, and one who works across party lines in search of the common good. His candidacy warrants support regardless of party affiliation.”)

But on April 8, Conservative Mount Royal candidate Neil Oberman posted a video on Instagram featuring himself and Cotler’s wife Ariela, on her lawn, both holding an Oberman poster.

“So happy to be here on this snowy April day, on my lawn, and with you,” Ariela says.

“Today everybody, your voice, your choice, will be heard for Neil Oberman and Ariela Cotler,” Oberman says. “I want you to come out on April 28, I want to make sure we take our voice back, that we’re safe, secure and prosperous, because there are no more choices. Do not stay at home, come out and we will have a better country and a better community.”

Ariela then says, “I add my words and I urge you, come out and vote, it’s the future of our families, our children, our grandchildren, and about all of Canada.”

Oberman then says, “I guess it’s going to be voting for Neil Oberman, and voting for the Conservative Party!”

Ariela adds, “Of course it is! Vote, of course, for Neil Oberman and the Conservative Party, and I wish you luck!”

“Thank you,” Oberman replies.

On April 9, Oberman posted a picture of himself shaking hands with Irwin Cotler, posting, “thank you Irwin Cotler for taking the time to share your wisdom and guidance on humanitarian issues that do and should matter and to your dear wife Ariela for joining our Canada First Conservative voices for change.”

The political differences, since this story first appeared April 9, became national news. Irwin Cotler, in terms of his and his wife’s voting choices, says he lives in a “pluralistic household.” n

Cotler home split in Mount Royal election Read More »

Concordia’s Institute of Israel Studies vandalized

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The SPVM is investigating after masked vandals smashed the windows and wrote anti-Israel graffiti at Concordia University’s downtown Azrieli Institute of Israel Studies around 9 p.m. Thursday, just ahead of the Jewish holiday of Passover.

Police say they were alerted hours later and arrived on the scene at 3 a.m. Friday. They are looking at video footage.

This incident follows extensive anti-Israel vandalism at McGill University during a recent three-day student strike, and an anti-Israel protest at Quartier Cavendish in Côte St. Luc in an attempt to intimidate moviegoers attending screenings of the documentary October 8, about the rise of antisemitism after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel.

Concordia president Graham Carr, in a message to the community, wrote that social media posts “celebrated the incident while specifically targeting a Concordia faculty member.

“Such violent actions, which are rooted in hate and intended to intimidate, have absolutely no place in our community,” Carr added. “The SPVM hate crimes unit is investigating. In the coming days, officials at Concordia will continue to collaborate closely with Montreal police to identify anyone who has broken the law, violated the Code of Rights and Responsibilities or failed to adhere to the university’s behaviour guidelines.”

The university president also wrote that “society is facing many urgent and deeply polarizing challenges.

“I ask the university community to join me in addressing them peacefully. Together, we must actively model respect and compassion for all who are suffering, and we must commit to keeping Concordia safe and welcoming for everyone.”

The anti-Israel SPHR Concordia celebrated on Instagram the vandalism against what it called the genocidal “Azrieli institute of israel (sic) studies. The students will never abandon Palestine!”

As for the faculty member targeted, one student on Instagram objected, saying the professor in question “has only ever been a kind and loving soul, most open for any type of discussion.” Some other students expressed similar sentiments.

The institute was founded in 2011, and “supports the advancement of Israel Studies through educational programs, publications, and financial support for students and faculty,” says Concordia’s website. n

Concordia’s Institute of Israel Studies vandalized Read More »

McGill seeks injunction against anti-Israel group

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill University has filed a request with Quebec Superior Court for a provisional injunction against the anti-Israel group Students for Palestinian Honour and Resistance (SPHR), university president Deep Saini announced.

In a message to the McGill community, Saini wrote that the legal step was taken “to protect the rights of students and staff to pursue their studies and work free from threats, obstructions and harassment. The judge heard our request and we are awaiting his ruling.”

The injunction was sought just after a three-day student strike at McGill during which classes were interrupted, Jewish students intimidated and much vandalism committed.

Saini added that with student exams underway, “McGill is asking the Court to prohibit protesters from intimidating or harassing people trying to enter McGill buildings or classrooms, from obstructing academic activities, or from obstructing access to buildings. The university also requested that protesters remain five metres away from buildings used for its operations, whether on or off campus.”

Saini further explained that the injunction request “clearly states that the university considers protest by McGill students and staff, within reasonable limits, to be not only permissible but also important. McGill seeks to uphold freedom of expression and peaceful assembly while protecting the rights of students to continue their academic journey without obstruction.

“The goal of the injunction is to ensure that the integrity and stability of our academic activities are preserved during this critical period of the school year. We are first and foremost a university, and we must focus on our mission and the rights of our students to undertake their academic pursuits in a peaceful environment that supports their well-being and success.” n

McGill seeks injunction against anti-Israel group Read More »

Poilievre promises action against street chaos, disorder

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A Conservative government will take strong action against the chaos and disorder prevalent in Montreal and across Canada from anti-Israel protesters, Conservative leader and candidate for Prime Minister Pierre Poilievre told The Suburban Monday during a press conference at the downtown Holiday Inn Monday.

Poilievre, accompanied by several Conservative candidates and flanked by those directly victimized or affected as family members by violent and deadly crimes, was in town to announce that a Conservative government would give judges back the power to sentence those who committed multiple or mass murders to consecutive prison sentences without parole eligibility for 25 years.

“For the worst mass murderers, a life sentence should mean what it says, a sentence for life,” Poilievre said. “These monsters should face the full consequences of their actions.”

Poilievre also spoke about chaos and disorder, and The Suburban pointed out that there has been a great deal of both in Montreal on the part of anti-Israel protesters. That includes recent vandalism at McGill and the protest at Quartier Cavendish in Côte St. Luc, where anti-Israel activists demonstrated against the showing of the movie October 8, which chronicled antisemitism following the 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel that left 1,200 dead.

We asked Poilievre what a government led by him would do to encourage local police to enforce the Criminal Code in such situations.

“After the lost Liberal decade of crime and chaos, and breakdown in our society, we can’t afford a fourth Liberal term,” he told The Suburban. ”We need a change to bring law and order and respect.”

Poilievre also condemned what he said was the Liberal approach of dividing Canadians.

“You see Mr. Carney playing Justin Trudeau’s trick of saying one thing to one group and exactly the opposite to the other, inflaming sides to cause division, while refusing to enforce the law. That will end when I’m Prime Minister. I will say the same thing to everyone everywhere!”

Poilievre emphasized that he will stand up for the right of Jewish Canadians “to proudly live their lives, practice their faith and enjoy their freedom.That includes wearing a Star of David, a kippah or having a mezuzah on their door, doing all of those things in total security.”

The Conservative candidate specified that a Poilievre government “will be bringing in tougher laws that crack down on hate-based vandalism, and on violence targeted at places of worship.We will bring in more security for places of worship and we will deport from Canada anyone here on a visitor visa who carries out any crime and we will prioritize the deportation of those who carry out hate crimes and violence on our streets.”

For permanent residents or citizens who commit such crimes, “they will go to jail and on top of that, there will be massive crippling financial penalties for hate-based vandalism. I can assure you that there will be penalties that are so massive that there will never be again some punk thinking even once about throwing a Molotov cocktail into a Jewish business or firing a gun at a Jewish school. They will pay a severe price for that. My message to the Jewish community — change is coming and that change will mean you will feel safe, you will feel respected and you will feel at home again in Canada.” n

Poilievre promises action against street chaos, disorder Read More »

Montreal community to observe Holocaust, Israel commemorations

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Montreal community will be observing several commemorations in the next few weeks, including Yom Hashoah (Holocaust Remembrance), Yom Hazikaron (remembrance of fallen Israeli soldiers and victims of terrorism) and Yom Ha’atzmaut (Israel’s anniversary of independence).

The annual Montreal Holocaust Museum Yom Hashoah Vehagvurah ceremony will be taking place 7 p.m. April 23 at the MHM, 5151 Côte St. Catherine Road. The event is also marking Heroism Remembrance Day. Reservations are encouraged, and can be made at the MHM website, museeholocauste.ca.

“On this day and every day, we remember the victims of the Holocaust, honour the survivors, and learn the difficult lessons of the past,” says an MHM announcement.

This year’s Yom Hashoah theme is A Changing Face, A Timeless Fight. The commemoration will include “video testimonies of survivors describing their experiences of antisemitism before the Holocaust, as well as a keynote address from the Honourable Professor Irwin Cotler, the International Chair of the Raoul Wallenberg Centre for Human Rights, an Emeritus Professor of Law at McGill University, former Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada and longtime Member of Parliament, and an international human rights lawyer. Commemorative songs in Yiddish, Ladino, and Hebrew will be performed alongside traditional prayers.”

The Yom Hazikaron ceremony, honouring Israel’s fallen and the victims of terrorism, is hosted by the Consul-General of Israel and Federation CJA. The solemn event takes place at 7 p.m. Tuesday April 29 at the Gelber Conference Centre, 5151 Côte Ste. Catherine. Doors open at 6 p.m. For free tickets, go to jlive.app/events/8538.

On the next day, 1:30 p.m. April 30, also in commemoration of Yom Hazikaron, the Sylvan Adams YM-YWHA is presenting Montreal’s third annual ZikkaRun, an international memorial for Yom Hazikaron, Israel’s National Remembrance Day.

“Guests are invited to run or walk on Wednesday, April 30 in memory of Israeli fallen soldiers and victims of terror,” an announcement says. “This is a walk or run with no fanfare, no tracking of running times, no music, no fee to participate. All participants will receive the name of an Israeli fallen solider or victim of terror to pin to their shirt. Everyone is invited to participate with one intention — to remember. Register for the run with your friends, family, and loved ones today. This global event will take place in Jewish and Israeli communities around the world, in cooperation with the Department of Organization and Relations with Israelis in the Diaspora in the World Zionist Organization.”

Register at jlive.app/events/10352.

The annual Israel Day celebration, organized by the Jewish Unity Partnership, will be celebrating the 77th anniversary of the country’s independence. The event will be taking place, uniquely this year, 10:15 a.m. May 1 at Macdonald Park on Clanranald Avenue corner Dupuis in Snowdon. The event usually takes place downtown.

Free shuttle buses will be available at Congregation Beth Tikvah in Dollard des Ormeaux at 9:30 a.m., Shaar Shalom Synagogue in Chomedey at 9:30 a.m., Beth Ora Synagogue in St. Laurent and Shaar Hashomayim in Westmount at 9:45 a.m, the Van Horne Shopping Centre in Côte des Neiges at 10 a.m., Quartier Cavendish, Décarie Square and the Côte St. Luc Shopping Centre in CSL at 10 a.m. and Federation CJA and the YM-YWHA in Snowdon at 10 a.m.

For more information, go to israelcelebration.ca.

At 4 p.m. May 1, there will be a Yom Ha’atzmaut celebration at Federation CJA’s West Island headquarters at 96 Roger Pilon in Dollard des Ormeaux.

“Bring your family and friends and get ready for an afternoon filled with carnival games, delicious food, and tons of fun,” an announcement says. For more information and to register for free, go to jlive.app/events/10712, n

Montreal community to observe Holocaust, Israel commemorations Read More »

Election 2025: Outremont

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The riding includes Outremont itself, the Mile End and the eastern part of Côte des Neiges. Unlike many other Montreal-island ridings, Outremont has been represented by a variety of parties. Tory Jean-Pierre Hogue won it during the Mulroney era. The NDP’s Thomas Mulcair won in 2007 and held the riding until he retired from politics in 2018. The Liberals then reclaimed the riding when Rachel Bendayan won a by-election earlier in 2019, and she won the 2021 general election with 44.36 percent of the vote.

Liberal

Rachel Bendayan, most recently appointed Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship by Prime Minister Mark Carney, was first elected in 2019 and re-elected in 2021. She was previously Minister of Official Languages and Associate Minister of Public Safety, as well as Parliamentary Secretary to the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Tourism and Associate Minister of Finance, and Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Small Business, Export Promotion and International Trade. Before entering politics, Bendayan was a lawyer with Norton Rose Fulbright in the fields of litigation and international arbitration, specializing in international trade law. She taught at the Faculty of Law of the Université de Montréal.

Conservative

Ronan Reich studied finance and information technology at Collège Jean-de-Brébeuf and HEC Montreal, and previously ran for the Conservatives in the Laurier–Sainte-Marie riding. Reich says his experience equips him “with the skills needed to understand the economic challenges of our country.” He adds that “my family has lived in this riding since my ancestors came to Canada in search of the Canadian promise.” The candidate also says that the Liberal government “with its rising taxes and capital gains tax that discourages investment, is putting our collective future at risk. I want to offer all citizens, young and old, the opportunity to build a better future for themselves, their children, and their grandchildren.”

NDP

Ève Péclet, who ran for the NDP in Outremont in 2021, was previously the party’s MP representing the La Pointe-de-l’Île riding from 2011 to 2015. The candidate says she is focused on “the values of justice, inclusion and equality.” While in Parliament, she sat on the Human Rights Subcommittee, the Foreign Affairs Committee and the Justice Committee of the Parliament of Canada. She worked on such issues as the use of rape as a weapon of war in armed conflict zones, respect for human rights by Canadian companies abroad, and access to justice. Outside politics, she is a lawyer, and has worked with domestic and sexual violence victims. Nowadays, she works at the Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse, handling discrimination and racial profiling cases. She also works with with Pro Bono Students Canada and the YWCA Legal Clinic.

Bloc Québécois

Rémi Lebeuf has been involved in numerous community and activist organizations, joined the Bloc Québécois Youth Forum in 2019 and is its Vice-President. He has a Master’s degree in Public and International Affairs from the Université de Montréal, and worked for MP Gabriel Ste-Marie in Joliette. Lebeuf joined the BQ parliamentary team as parliamentary assistant to MP Julie Vignola. He says that this election “will be crucial for the future of Quebec, in the face of the two major Canadian parties worn and disconnected from our local realities.”

Green Party

Jonathan Pedneault is co-leader of the Green Party with Elizabeth May, and it has been reported that he is taking on “singular leadership roles” for the party and representing the Green Party at debates. He says that “those in power who could make a difference continue to let us down. Canadians deserve a real alternative—one that defends our values and safeguards the future we all want for our country.’” As a journalist, he has reported from Somalia, Yemen, Ethiopia, Egypt, Libya and Israel. He has recently condemned Israel for its actions during the war with Hamas, posting: “Words of condemnation on social media fail to capture how despicable, criminal and reprehensible Israel’s conduct is. Human rights abusers deserve sanctions, condemnation and jail. Not accolades, excuses and normalization.”

Election 2025: Outremont Read More »

Rights tribunal finds no proof of racial profiling in CSL traffic stop

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Quebec Human Rights Tribunal recently ruled that there was no proof Montreal Black community member Eric Moses Gashirabake was subjected to racial profiling in a March 23, 2018 traffic stop in Côte St. Luc.

Gashirabake, at the time of the incident a CSL resident, was seeking $27,450, including $20,000 for the “income he allegedly lost between June and September 2020, as the [encounter] had such an impact on him that it led him to leave his job in April 2020 to move to Gatineau”; $2,450 for moving expenses and $5,000 in punitive damages “to discourage police officers from profiling in their interactions with racialized people.” A previous Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse ruling said the plaintiff could have his case heard before the Quebec human rights tribunal.

The defendants — the City of Montreal and the SPVM — argued that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction to rule on the case — this was rejected by Judge Magali Lewis. The city and the SPVM also said the plaintiff went through a red light when turning left from southbound Cavendish Blvd. in Côte St. Luc onto eastbound Côte St. Luc Road.

The judge ruled for the defendants stating that the constable “did not say the words Gashirabake claims he did; and that Gashirabake had not established that he suffered material and moral damages that would justify awarding him the amounts he was claiming.

“Gashirabake’s testimony does not offer sufficient guarantees of reliability to satisfy the criterion of the preponderance of evidence.”

According to the details of the case, Gashirabake calmly disputed the reason for the traffic stop, saying the light was green when he drove through the intersection, and handed the officer his driver’s license and vehicle registration. The constable gave the driver tickets for running the red light and not having proof of insurance in his possession. The plaintiff was determined in municipal court to be not guilty of the first infraction, but guilty of the second. The officer was not present in municipal court to testify.

In his original 2018 complaint, Gashirabake said the officer made discriminatory remarks and did not consider his explanations for the infractions that resulted in both tickets.

“I explained to him I had a new car and was waiting for the slip to be emailed to me, but he did not want to listen to me,” the plaintiff explained. “He said something in French along the line of ‘les des mensonges’ (sic)’ I am not fluent in French but I know he wanted to generalize that all black people tell lies!” The officer denied calling the plaintiff a liar.

But the court found that the plaintiff was inconsistent in his account of the incident, and “gave several versions, both as to when the [officer’s] remarks were allegedly made and their content.” For instance, Gashirabake claimed at one point that the officer spoke French, and then claimed the officer spoke English except when stating the allegedly discriminatory remark.

The court also ruled that the plaintiff stated at different times that the discriminatory remarks were made at the beginning, the middle and the end of the encounter; and also stated different versions of the allegedly discriminatory remarks.

“The Tribunal finds that throughout the period before he gave the tickets to Mr. Gashirabake, Officer Courteau was courteous and that there were no exchanges between them other than those concerning the reason for the interception and the request for Mr. Gashirabake’s papers.” n

Rights tribunal finds no proof of racial profiling in CSL traffic stop Read More »

Election 2025: Mount Royal

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Mount Royal riding has elected Liberals since 1940, but some elections in recent years have seen fairly close results, particularly as Côte St. Luc and Hampstead voters came out strongly for the Conservatives, because of former Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s strong support of Israel.The riding encompasses Côte St. Luc, Hampstead, part of Côte des Neiges and the Town of Mount Royal. The Liberal vote has been stronger in the latter two areas. In the 2021 election, the Liberals won Mount Royal with 57.71 percent of the vote.

Liberals

Anthony Housefather has been the Liberal MP for Mount Royal since 2015. Before that, he was Mayor of Côte St. Luc, a CSL councillor during the merger era from 2002 to 2006 and a Hampstead councillor in the 1990s. Housefather considered leaving the Liberals after his party voted for what many considered an anti-Israel motion, but ultimately stayed with the party. He was also the only MP to vote against Bill C-13, the revision of the Official Languages Act that by reference recognizes Quebec’s language law and gives it application over federal areas of jurisdiction, for which he was briefly demoted. Last year, Housefather was appointed the Special Advisor on Jewish Community Relations to former Prime Minister Trudeau.

Conservatives

Neil Oberman, a lawyer with Spiegel Ryan, is a partner in the firm’s civil and commercial litigation group and his practice is focused on commercial and civil disputes. Oberman is best known for successfully obtaining numerous injunctions to keep anti-Israel and antisemitic protesters well away from Jewish institutions. This followed a blockade of Federation CJA by protesters in 2024 and his work resulted in over 45 Jewish institutions being protected. Oberman has also successfully taken up the cases of Jewish students encountering harassment and antisemitism at Concordia and McGill.

NDP

Adam Frank was born in Canada, educated in Britain and France, and was a volunteer at an orphanage in Kenya. He has been a teacher of history, music, English and French at international schools in several different countries. “It was always my dream to become actively involved in politics once I returned to my native land,” he says.

Bloc Québécois

A Mount Royal candidate has not been named yet as of press time..

Green Party

Jacqueline Chamberland is the party’s candidate for Mount Royal.

People’s Party of Canada

Daniel Gervais was born in 1984 in Laval and is now a Town of Mount Royal resident. Gervais studied economics, business, and political science, and left university to help grow a family and friend-run private company, which was later successfully acquired. Gervais also co-founded a Canadian pet care company and, in China, managed operations and quality control for a prominent dog waste bag brand before returning to Montreal. Locally, Gervais serves on the EMSB parent committee and the Dunrae Gardens Elementary School governing board. n

Election 2025: Mount Royal Read More »

Task Force’s Caddell denounces investigation by QMC

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Andrew Caddell, president of the Task Force On Linguistic Policy, is denouncing Quebec’s system allowing anonymous complaints, whether related to Quebec’s language laws or, in his case, a Quebec Municipal Commission complaint.

“We should be concerned about the use of anonymous complaints and concentration of power as they are signs of authoritarianism,” Caddell wrote recently.

Caddell, who is also a councillor in Kamouraska, has, with the Task Force, been fighting Quebec’s language law Bill 96 in court. A recent Superior Court judgment said that the federal government cannot be forced to become a respondent in that case.

The complaint to the QMC alleges that Caddell breached ethics and professional conduct rules late last year, violating his municipality’s code of ethics. Caddell allegedly posted in defence of the Quebec anglophone community, “go f–k yourself. C’est évident que vous etes un vrai ‘’loser’’ et pleurnichard.” (“It’s obvious you are a real loser and crybaby.”)

Caddell responded that while there have been accusations of “creeping fascism” as relates to the Trump government and right wing voting trends in Europe, “here in the Quebec ‘nation’, we see a rise in authoritarianism, illustrated by Premier François Legault’s government’s embrace of extreme nationalism, and its desire to concentrate power in Quebec City.

“For example, the creation of the new health agency, Santé Quebec, eliminated the autonomy of hospital boards, while the closing of school boards placed authority in the bureaucracy. Furthermore, Bills 21 and 96 became law under the cloak of the notwithstanding clause, imposing rules of dress and language on Quebec’s minorities. And now the government’s new Bill 84 offers directives on behaviour and culture, outlining ‘appropriate’ ways of integrating into Quebec society.”

Caddell also cited the Quebec government’s allowance of anonymous complaints in relation to the language law and, potentially, the secularism law.

Regarding the specific complaint against him, Caddell provided context, saying his postings were in defence of the rights of English Quebecers.

“At the end of December, I was attacked with insults like ‘raciste,’ ‘Rhodesien,’ ‘KKKanada’, and ‘supremaciste.’ Anyone who knows me would attest I am none of those things. I replied I am a francophile with roots back to 1640, who chose to return to Quebec from Ottawa in 2020. I noted my work on Kamouraska town council is entirely in French. As the insults escalated, I ramped up my replies with a few choice words. After a few days, I forgot about it.”

Caddell said he received a call from someone alleging to be from the Quebec Ministry of Municipal Affairs, and he demanded to see the complaint in writing, which he later received.

“Since then, I have been communicating with the Inquiries Division of the Municipal Affairs Commission, expecting they would ignore such a malicious complaint,” Caddell wrote. “Instead, on March 12, they wrote to say they are pursuing me, and I could be fined up to $4,000 or be suspended from my seat on council. An administrative tribunal, conducted in French, will decide my fate. Needless to say, it has been stressful.”

Caddell wrote that some of the evidence against him includes statements he made in his capacity with the Task Force, implying that “there was an ethical conflict between my work as a town councillor and as volunteer head of an organization dedicated to serving Quebec anglophones.

“This whole episode is troubling: the use of anonymous complaints as evidence is contrary to the historic principle everyone has the right to face their accuser in court. And although this is a quasi-judicial proceeding, I have no right under Section 133 of the Constitution to have my hearing in English. It’s appalling someone can attack me with malice aforethought, and I have no recourse to respond.” n

Task Force’s Caddell denounces investigation by QMC Read More »

Superior Court halts SSMU antisemitism resolution

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Superior Court Judge Bernard Larocque granted McGill University student Samuel Levkovsky and many other complainants permission to proceed with its case against the Students’ Society of McGill University regarding what they consider to be its biased policy on what constitutes antisemitism.

The judge also issued a six-month restraining order against the SSMU, halting the ratification of the policy. The students are represented by Spiegel Ryan lawyer Neil Oberman, and Choueke Hollander’s Michael Hollander. As reported by The Suburban last December, Superior Court Judge Daniel Urbas granted a 10-day injunction halting the ratification of the policy.

The SSMU policy against antisemitism, which on the surface appeared to be a straightforward denouncing of the portrayal of all Jews as evil and blaming them for actions by Israel, did not include disproportionate criticism of Zionism and Israel. “This narrow framing effectively permitted an environment where hate could persist on campus, as it excluded any negative sentiments aimed at Israel and its inhabitants from being classified as antisemitic,” Oberman told The Suburban.

Generally, the lawyer explained that the case involved “the fundamental right of students to express their voices and concerns as stipulated by the bylaws and regulations of the SSMU.

“Unfortunately, despite having secured an injunction aimed at safeguarding their rights in December, the SSMU chose to disregard this legal protection. They proceeded with actions that were deemed unlawful, specifically seeking to ratify a controversial policy known as the null policy. This particular policy was poised to have detrimental effects on Jewish students on campus, raising serious concerns about discrimination and antisemitism.”

Oberman added that the complainants had no choice but to stop the ratification process. “We sought justice for those affected and aimed to ensure that all student voices were heard in matters directly impacting their community.”

In light of the March 5 judgment, Oberman said the SSMU policy on antisemitism cannot be legitimized or upheld moving forward. “The need for a more inclusive and accurate definition is crucial in order to combat all forms of hatred effectively and ensure that all individuals feel safe and respected within the community.”

Superior Court halts SSMU antisemitism resolution Read More »

Mount Royal election debate a mystery

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

B’nai Brith Canada and Anthony Housefather’s Liberal campaign are declining to confirm whether a federal election debate in the Mount Royal riding had been planned by the organization and cancelled because the incumbent was not available.

The last debate in the riding took place in 2019, was organized by B’nai Brith Canada and was between Housefather and former Conservative candidate David Tordjman. Debates had also taken place during the 2015 Mount Royal campaign.

The Suburban has seen a graphic and an alleged B’nai Brith post announcing that their Mount Royal debate was cancelled because Housefather had a scheduling conflict, but we could not find either on the organization’s social media page.

Asked to confirm whether a debate was to take place, B’nai Brith Canada Quebec regional director Henry Topas told The Suburban, “we thank you but have no comment at this time.”

Former D’Arcy McGee MNA Lawrence Bergman, speaking for Housefather’s campaign, told The Suburban that any request for an appearance at an event would “have to be based on the merits and Anthony’s time.”

Earlier last week, Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi posted on social media that he had heard Housefather could not participate in a debate because of scheduling conflicts.

Also asked about the issue, Conservative candidate Neil Oberman told The Suburban, ”I am prepared to engage in discussions or any other methods necessary to ensure the electorate is fully informed about their rights and the key issues affecting their daily lives. Canadians have long been silenced, and it is crucial for every citizen to amplify their voices regarding their rights so they can make informed choices at the polls.If the Liberal Party and its agents choose not to debate me, it is their decision. However, the residents of Mount Royal deserve the opportunity to understand who the candidates are and what they stand for.” Stay tuned. n

Mount Royal election debate a mystery Read More »

St. Laurent receives $7.3 M from feds to fight flooding

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The federal government recently gave St. Laurent $7.3 million in funding to help reduce the effects of any future flooding, following two downpours last year in quick succession that especially affected borough residents and area traffic.

The announcement that came from the federal Department of Housing, Infrastructure and Communities, was announced by then-Environment and Climate Change Minister Steven Guilbeault, St. Laurent MP Emmanuella Lambropoulos and St. Laurent Mayor Alan DeSousa; and is being funded through the federal Disaster Mitigation and Adaptation Fund.

The funding, says the announcement, “will be used to build water retention structures in Bois Franc Park and the Midtown project, as well as to continue the development of the St. Laurent biodiversity corridor. This innovative project aims to increase the stormwater network’s capacity and reduce overflows into the Rivière des Prairies during heavy rainfalls. Additionally, it integrates nature into urban environments to mitigate the effects of heat waves while enriching local biodiversity.”

More specific aspects of the project include:

• The expansion and modernization of the permanent Noroît reservoir and its surrounding areas through phytotechnology (the use of plants to solve scientific and engineering problems), which will increase its capacity while using natural solutions for water management.

• The addition of a retention basin in Midtown Park, providing an alternative to direct stormwater runoff by promoting natural infiltration, thereby reducing pressure on the drainage system. These ecological measures play a key role in flood risk reduction and contribute to sustainable water conservation.

• The extension of the St. Laurent biodiversity corridor, which aims to facilitate species movement, enhance ecosystem resilience, and help mitigate urban heat islands, making public spaces more comfortable for residents. This corridor is designed to create ecological connectivity between Montreal’s natural areas, parks, and green spaces.

Guilbeault stated that in the federal government’s efforts against climate change, “nature is our greatest ally, as this innovative project proves through its use of phytotechnology and its consideration of biodiversity in design. The St. Laurent biodiversity corridor is a concrete example of how we can protect Canada and build more resilient, sustainable communities for generations to come.”

Lambropoulos said the biodiversity corridor “presents a forward-thinking solution by integrating natural water management methods and enhancing our water retention infrastructure. As climate change intensifies, investing in sustainable, tangible solutions is essential to building resilience in our communities.”

DeSousa said that with climate change and last year’s floods, “it is crucial to adapt our safety mechanisms to protect our residents, their properties, and their living environment.

“That is the goal of the three developments in this project, which will also help limit damage to the environment and infrastructure during heavy rainfall. I sincerely thank the Government of Canada. This funding comes at the right time, as St. Laurent enters the second half of its 2021-2030 Climate Emergency Plan, which aims to prepare for climate change and protect biodiversity. This project will also support biodiversity growth by expanding the St. Laurent biodiversity corridor in a very tangible way.” n

St. Laurent receives $7.3 M from feds to fight flooding Read More »

CSL Mayor, longtime volunteers awarded King Charles III medal

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein and longtime volunteers Susie Berkson-Schwartz and Joy Rodgers were presented with the King Charles III Coronation medal during a ceremony at the Harold Greenspon Auditorium recently.

The award is given for outstanding achievement in public service to the community and to Canada.

The medals were presented by Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather. CSL council was on hand, as well as longtime councillor Glenn Nashen, the founder of volunteer Citizens On Patrol and Emergency Medical Services, and Brownstein’s wife Elaine.

Brownstein, who was first elected to CSL council in 1990 and became Mayor in 2016, was honoured for his achievements on council, including establishing the CSL Dramatic Society, co-chairing the CSL Demerger Committee, promoting Canadian unity through a Staying Canadian resolution just after the 1995 Quebec referendum, and introducing the Fun Card providing access to recreational facilities. His was also the first city to legislate that masks be worn in public places during the COVID pandemic in 2020. Brownstein has also called on Montreal to take strong action against anti-Israel agitators.

Brownstein said Elaine has always been there for him, whether for personal, health and business issues.

“If anybody needs an advocate, just call her,” the Mayor added, to loud applause.

Brownstein also thanked his parents for instilling in him the value of community and becoming involved at a young age.

“Whether it was with Federation CJA, or politics at the federal, provincial or municipal level, I was always inspired to do more….I always say ‘enjoy every moment of life.’ That’s all we can do and do the best we can by trying to make other people happy.”

Brownstein said the award also goes to the CSL council and city directors.

“I can’t be a good Mayor without the staff and the council behind me. I am really lucky because all the directors who were there are still with me nine years after I became Mayor.”

Berkson-Schwartz was honoured for being a part of the volunteer Citizens On Patrol since 2006. She is also at almost all CSL council meetings.

Housefather said that in her role with vCOP, “Susie has taken on many important tasks, including organizing the vCOP presence at major events such as the Winter Carnival, Ruth Kovac Blood Drive, Canada Day celebrations, and Remembrance Day activities. She also coordinates the vCOP representation at local events in places like Trudeau Park and Ashkelon Gardens. Susie works closely with city staff to make sure these events run smoothly and are enjoyable for the public, making her a key figure in the community.

“Susie’s exceptional service and commitment to her community make her a very deserving recipient of the King Charles III Coronation Medal.”

Rodgers was honoured for her 26 years at CSL’s Emergency Medical Services, having joined at the age of 18 after working at local pools.

“She’s always had service to her community in her blood,” Housefather said. At EMS, “she is an experienced medic, driver and instructor. She led the quality assurance team and was in charge of recruiting, all while continuing to dedicate hundreds of hours of volunteer service to help others. While not on shift at EMS, Joy is an active mom of two, a wife, an elementary school first aid coordinator, a CPR instructor and a cancer survivor and advocate.” n

CSL Mayor, longtime volunteers awarded King Charles III medal Read More »

Court rules Feds not obliged to take part in anti-96 case

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Quebec Superior Court Judge Marc St-Pierre ruled last week that the federal government does not have to be a respondent in the Task Force on Linguistic Policy’s case against Quebec’s language law Bill 96.

The court ruling noted that it “cannot or should not force” the federal government to be a part of the case against the language law, and that the Task Force and the other complainants in the case are able to make their case on their own against Bill 96 and Quebec’s Attorney-General.

Task Force President Andrew Caddell told The Suburban that it is “disappointing the judge sided with the federal Attorney-General.

‘We now have a new Attorney-General in Gary Anandasangaree, but I am skeptical as to whether he will be knowledgeable enough to respond to any of the details of cases like ours. We believe the Trudeau PMO just wants this to go away, as they did with so many things concerning the Anglophone community in Quebec.”

Caddell added that last week’s decision “does not mean we cannot proceed with our case — just that we will be fighting the AG of Quebec.

“We have 30 days to appeal the decision to the Quebec Court of Appeal. I have asked the Board of the Task Force to decide. Our next meeting will be in a week or so, and we will let our members know once the Board has made its decision.”

As reported by The Suburban, the Task Force said last September that it included the federal government as a respondent for “refusing to defend the Constitution of Canada… against the unilateral declaration of Quebec as an exclusive French-speaking nation in the Constitution. It is also due to the incorporation of the Charter of the French Language, as amended by Bill 96, in Bill C-13, the new federal Official Languages Act.”

Michael Bergman, lawyer for the Task Force, told a town hall recently that a victory would have set an important precedent.

“It will be the first case of its kind on the notion that Canada must defend the integrity of the supreme law, the Canadian constitution,” Bergman told the virtual meeting, which was attended by nearly 100 people. “If Canada won’t defend it — that every province can start making unilateral amendments — the Canadian constitution will no longer be a unifying document. It will be like a jigsaw puzzle where the pieces don’t quite fit together, it will break into different pieces with different rules.”

The plaintiffs in the ongoing case against Bill 96 include Caddell, “general plaintiffs acting as public interest litigants, as a constitutional question; a teacher concerned about his status due to education provisions in Bill 96, a businessperson whose commercial affairs are affected by Bill 96, a permanent resident with an autoimmune disease who cannot receive communications in English and a mother whose autistic child has not been able to receive proper specialized care because his first language is English.” n

Court rules Feds not obliged to take part in anti-96 case Read More »

Green group opposes ADM plan for Sources nature park

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The environmental group Technoparc Oiseaux is strongly objecting to development plans in a brief presented last Dec. 16 by Aéroports de Montréal to a Montreal Metropolitan Community public consultation.

Part of the ADM brief details plans to exclude 155 hectares, equivalent to four lots, from the Sources Nature Park, which is near Trudeau Airport, and to “develop an area of over 100 hectares that would include Monarch Fields, a habitat for the endangered monarch butterfly.”

The group says the development of Lot 5 “would also severely impact the Des Sources Forest and Des Sources marsh complex.

“The document glosses over the devastating impacts of ADM’s proposed development on the area’s last remaining wetlands and greenspace, a vital ecosystem home to dozens of at-risk species and remarkable biodiversity.”

Technoparc Oiseaux’s statement added that this past Jan. 31, the ADM presented the environmental group with a plan submitted to Transport Canada, which they say confirmed ADM’s intention to “develop these ecologically valuable lands.

“The CMM, City of Montreal, City of Dorval, and federal government support protection of the site, alongside civic organizations and 25 cities and boroughs.”

“Technoparc Oiseaux is calling on the ADM to adopt a responsible approach, based on biodiversity protection and the public and political will. Silence in the face of such proposed ecological destruction would be inexcusable.”

Katherine Collin, president of Technoparc Oiseaux, stated “protecting these unique habitats is a collective responsibility. ADM can set an example by becoming a leading player in sustainable development and supporting, rather than hindering, protection of the site. If it truly wants to be known as a green company, ADM must withdraw its development plans while there is still time.”

The ADM is countering that it is preserving 25 hectares of land, and that having part of a nature park and its wildlife located so close to the airport and its runways would create a danger, such as birds flying close to or into planes. The airport agency cited a recent plane crash in South Korea caused by bird strikes, which killed 179 people.

Collin, who has said that the ADM’s fear is overstated, says, “we understand that Transport Canada will have until March 21 to accept [the ADM’s master plan]. We encourage you to call your local, provincial, and federal representatives and urge them to act quickly to protect the site.”

Technoparc Oiseaux had rejoiced last October when it was announced that the Plante administration had decided to buy land from the technology firm Hypertec for over $30 million, as it was expected that wetlands and urban forests at the Technoparc in St. Laurent would be preserved and the boundaries of the Sources Nature Park would be expanded.

“Today marks a remarkable step towards the near future where the entirety of the Sources Nature Park, including all remaining federal and private lands, will be fully protected and restored, for the benefit of all,” Technoparc Oiseaux stated at the time. “We would like to emphasize that this collaborative work must continue to protect the rich biodiversity of this site.” n

Green group opposes ADM plan for Sources nature park Read More »

Probe finds no harassment against Hampstead employees

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A thorough independent investigation has found that no psychological harassment took place against any town employee, Mayor Jeremy Levi announced at last week’s council meeting.

As well, the Mayor said, “the investigation did not result in any recommendations, as the town already has strong procedures in place to ensure a professional, respectful and safe work environment.

“The well-being of our employees is of the utmost importance. The conclusions of this independent investigation reinforce our confidence in the strength of our existing policies and our unwavering commitment to fostering a workplace rooted in integrity, fairness and mutual respect….Employees are always encouraged to share their concerns through internal channels.”

The town had received internal complaints, and allegations emerged into the public sphere, when CSL resident and former Hampstead employee Jeremy Biskin told council late last year that “during my time in Hampstead, I witnessed multiple instances of discrimination, verbal harassment and verbal abuse.”

Biskin made The Suburban aware of communications from other employees, one addressed to a union and the town alleging workplace harm and abuse, negligence and psychological harassment; and another alleging a toxic and unhealthy work environment.

A town statement following the independent investigation pointed out that Hampstead could not address the allegations raised by Biskin at the time “due to the serious and confidential nature of the ongoing process.” The town also contends that “sensationalized media coverage” presented an “incomplete picture of the situation.”

Following the council meeting, The Suburban asked if the allegations of psychological harassment, those alleged in public and in communications viewed by us, were found by the investigation to be fabricated or mischaracterized.

Hampstead Director General Joe Nunez told The Suburban the investigation found, based on witnesses who were interviewed, that “there was no credible information to warrant a finding in the definition of what is psychological harassment.

“Sometimes we’ll get a report that says, based on this conclusion, we’ll recommend certain actions. At this point, there was not even any recommendation. We do have a very good policy in place, we acted quickly to launch this investigation. It was a very serious accusation and the findings are there.” n

Probe finds no harassment against Hampstead employees Read More »

More than 5,300 sign disabilities petition sponsored by Prass

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

D’Arcy McGee MNA Elisabeth Prass, the Official Opposition Critic for Social Services and for People Living with Disabilities or on the Autism Spectrum, recently sponsored a National Assembly petition to “ask the CAQ government to guarantee the accessibility of alternative living environments for people with autism or intellectual disabilities.”

The 5,372-signature petition, whose signing period is over, can be seen at www.assnat.qc.ca/en/exprimez-votre-opinion/petition/Petition-11151/index.html. The petition points out that individuals with intellectual disabilities or autism “face significant barriers to accessing safe, healthy, and stimulating alternative living environments, such as supervised apartments, intermediate resources, and family-type resources.”

The petition adds that while every individual has the right to live in an environment that guarantees them a high quality of life,” there have been “frequent reports of abuse within alternative living environments;

“Quebec must uphold the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The lack of residential options often leads to a mismatch between the available living environment and the life plan of these individuals. There are non-profit models of alternative living environments that better meet the needs of these individuals, developed by and for the intellectual disability and autism community.”

The Quebec government is being asked to “strengthen staff training and oversight of alternative living environments to ensure adequate living conditions; and ensure that intermediate and family-type resources are tailored to the evolving needs of individuals, fostering the preservation and development of their abilities.”

The provincial government is also being asked to “give priority to non-profit alternative living environments in the creation of new spaces and actively support their development across all regions; and enhance and secure stable funding for non-profit alternative living environments.”

Prass also recently denounced the CAQ’s “unjustified cuts to major assistance programs for people living with disabilities.” She held a press conference Feb. 19 at the National Assembly with representatives of the Regroupement des activistes pour l’inclusion au Québec (RAPLIQ), where they said the cuts are “a historic step backwards in terms of accessibility and social participation for people with disabilities.

Prass also told the press conference that in recent months, “especially with the arrival of Santé Québec, the cuts continue and it is always at the cost of the most vulnerable people.

“Whether it is the suspension of the home adaptation program, the cuts in the employment service cheque program, the cuts in the government contribution to work integration contracts, the possible pricing of services for home support, all these programs were created precisely to give a certain autonomy to people living with disabilities or with an autism spectrum disorder or intellectual disability and to allow them to live with a certain dignity, to stay in their home as long as possible, because what this government does not consider is that it costs less to offer home services to a person rather than to integrate them into a CHSLD or other institution for which there are waiting lists of thousands of people.”

Prass also pointed out that that with an budget upcoming and an $11 billion provincial deficit, “we are all afraid that these cuts will just get worse.”

Steven Laperrière, director general of the Regroupement des activistes pour l’inclusion au Québec, said that “inclusion cannot be an empty slogan.

“The government and Santé Québec must stop cutting and act now to guarantee everyone full participation in society, autonomy and the dignity to which every individual is entitled.” n

More than 5,300 sign disabilities petition sponsored by Prass Read More »

Neo-Nazi sentenced to five years for threats against Jews

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Quebec Court Judge Sylvain Lépine has sentenced Pascal Tribout, 38, of Saint-Joseph-du-Lac, near Oka, to five years in jail for making online threats against the Jewish community and using a 3D printer to illegally produce firearms.

“These charges are serious,” Judge Lépine ruled last week. “His comments [about Jews] are unacceptable… the manufacture of these weapons is worrisome.”

As previously reported by The Suburban, Tribout, who pleaded guilty to charges relating to the illegal manufacture of firearms and antisemitic hate speech, had made hateful comments against the Jewish community in a public forum on the social network Telegram.

The RCMP, which arrested Tribout last year, stated at the time that “violent statements will not be tolerated, whether made on social media or through any other means of communication. Perpetrators may face criminal charges involving significant sentences. Such incidents must be reported if we are to combat this type of crime.”

Jewish community organizations welcomed the sentencing. B’nai Brith Canada officials said they expressed the concerns of the Canadian Jewish community to the court.

“This verdict is a welcome sign for all Canadians,” said Henry Topas, B’nai Brith Canada’s Regional Director for Quebec and Atlantic Canada, who represented the Jewish community at the Feb. 26 sentencing. “This case shows that antisemitism is not only a threat to Jews but also can be a matter of national security.”

Topas added that Tribout “failed to demonstrate remorse or issue an apology.”

B’nai Brith Canada’s statement adds that Tribout’s case is precedent-setting, “marking the first time Crown prosecutors have brought someone to justice under a statute relating to the spread of computer data used to manufacture 3D-printed weapons.

“These so-called ‘Ghost Guns’ are a significant concern because they do not have serial numbers and thus cannot easily be traced.”

Officials from the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs stated that “as we said last year, this case is a reminder that antisemitism exists in many forms, such as the far-right neo-Nazi and anti-vaccine conspiracy theories.

“We welcome this sentence. From arrest to conviction, the authorities acted with determination against the threat posed by Mr. Tribout. It is up to them to act in this way at all times in the fight against antisemitism.” n

Neo-Nazi sentenced to five years for threats against Jews Read More »

St. Laurent energy loop a North American first

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Excellence Industrielle Saint-Laurent, which encourages innovation and promotes sustainable solutions, announced recently a collective energy loop project in the borough’s industrial sector, a North American first.

An energy loop is a system where energy is captured, used, and recycled back into the system for reuse, between one or several buildings.

The overall goal of the project, announced at YKK Canada Inc. on Thimens Blvd., is to optimize energy efficiency and reduce greenhouse gas emissions and, more specifically, to “capture industrial thermal waste and redistribute it via an underground network of tempered liquid.

“This approach reduces dependence on fossil fuels, stabilizes companies’ energy costs and improves their environmental performance.”

Excellence Industrielle Saint-Laurent’s announcement says the project goes beyond technical innovation, “it is a lever of competitiveness for local businesses and a new way of thinking about energy.” The initiative came about after the organization grouped together an advisory committee of 15 experts from the industrial, energy and territorial sectors.

As well, “the energy mapping of the industrial park made it possible to identify 23 potential synergies and three poles for the implementation of a pilot project: the Thimens sector, the Technoparc and the Lebeau sector.”

Pierre Audet, president of Excellence industrielle Saint-Laurent, said that “today, 40 percent of the energy consumed in industry is lost. While some pay for heating, others reject unused heat. By pooling this resource, we are creating a local, sustainable and resilient solution that benefits the entire territory.”

A feasibility study was also launched to validate the business model and the results are expected early this fall.

St. Laurent Mayor Alan DeSousa pointed out that two-thirds of energy in Quebec is used by industries, “and the current energy supply can no longer meet demand.

“Given that St. Laurent has one of the largest industrial parks in Quebec and that 70 percent of this territory is dedicated to economic activities, it has the best assets to launch this bold energy loop, a first in an industrial environment in North America.

DeSousa added that adapting to climate change and reducing greenhouse gas emissions are two goals of the borough’s 2021 climate emergency plan.

“I am proud to see that, under the leadership of Excellence Industrielle Saint-Laurent, the St. Laurent business community is mobilizing and transforming current challenges into a collective opportunity that corresponds to our strategic objective of building a responsible economy.” n

St. Laurent energy loop a North American first Read More »

Ethics complaints brought against Senator Woo

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg and
Beryl Wajsman
The Suburban

Yves Engler, a longtime anti-Israel agitator best known for interrupting events and attempting to video and ask anti-Israel questions of prominent members of the Jewish community and others he protests against, has been arrested for harassment and obstruction of justice.

Court documents say the current accusations include repeated communications with two individuals, with intent to harass, one being a police officer and the other being media personality Dahlia Kurtz, a pro-Israel activist prominent on X (formerly Twitter); and obstructing a police officer in his duties.

Engler had written about Kurtz in late June 2024, “Racist Dahlia supports killing Palestinian children. 20,000 is not enough she wants even more Palestinian blood spilled.” Kurtz responded in early July, “I’m advising you in this one message only that you are harassing me. You’re threatening and you’re making me afraid for my safety.”

She then contacted lawyer Neil Oberman, who has successfully obtained injunctions keeping anti-israel activists well away from Jewish institutions; and helping Jewish university students against anti-Jewish harassment on campus.

Knowing in advance of his arrest, Engler wrote that a police officer named Crivello “said I had described Kurtz as a ‘genocide’” supporter and ‘fascist’ on Twitter. Guilty as charged.”

Engler made bail following a court appearance. His conditions include not being in close proximity to the complainants and not to make any reference about the police officer who was the alleged subject of harassment, to appear in court at required times, live at his listed address and alert the court in writing of any change in residence.

In a further twist in this story, Kurtz has filed a formal complaint with the Senate ethics commissioner against British Columbia Sen. Yuen Pau Woo appointed by Prime Minister Trudeau in 2016. Kurtz alleges that Woo “incited hate, aggression, and violence against me online in a public forum on X (Twitter) in a series of posts. This is in regards to a case before the courts in which I am the victim. He doesn’t even have the correct information and is commenting and siding with the accused. Senator Woo has now put me in the crosshairs of more people — and has further endangered my safety and my reputation.”

In what appears to be an attempt at intervening in the judicial process after Engler was charged, Woo challenged police by posting on X that,” I support the right of @EnglerYves to voice outrage over genocide in Gaza and to call out those who aid and abet crimes against humanity. The @rcmpgrepolice must explain fully the grounds on which charges are being laid and how these actions do not violate freedom of expression.” n

Ethics complaints brought against Senator Woo Read More »

St. Laurent’s CAE launches ATS Training Centre

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The St. Laurent-based global aviation company CAE inaugurated its Air Traffic Services (ATS) Training Centre recently.

Officials of CAE, which trains pilots, aircraft maintenance technicians, and cabin crews, pointed out that last October, the company “started partnering in the training of air traffic controllers (ATC) and flight service specialists (FSS) with NAV CANADA,” a civil air navigation service company.

CAE President and CEO Marc Parent stated that “as an innovator in aviation learning sciences, CAE is perfectly positioned to partner with NAV CANADA and other Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSP) to meet the increasing global demand for air traffic services personnel and train the highly skilled professionals they need to manage air traffic safely.

“This is an extension of CAE’s core mission to make the world safer, and as a pilot, I can attest to the critical importance of the communication between flight crew and the air traffic personnel who play an essential role in the safety of every flight.”

Mark Cooper, President and CEO of NAV CANADA, said that “air travel is a cornerstone of Canada’s social and economic vitality, with NAV CANADA positioned at the crossroads of international traffic, connecting communities and businesses globally.

“This partnership with CAE exemplifies our dedication to operational excellence, ensuring safe and efficient air navigation while preparing for the future of aviation through innovative training and collaboration.”

St. Laurent’s CAE launches ATS Training Centre Read More »

CSL senior seeks accountability from Walmart after injury

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Walmart has apologized but offered no further comment following allegations that employees at the Jean Talon store did little or nothing to help a Côte St. Luc senior who was severely injured on the property in January.

CSL councillor Mike Cohen has recounted that his District 2 constituent Dorothy Baker, 89, who he described as dynamic and independent, slipped and fell in the Walmart Jean Talon parking lot on Jan. 11.

The resident’s grandson Jonathan Labow-Hart told Cohen that she was in the parking lot for an hour before help arrived, even though 911 was called immediately.

“Due to the area surrounding the fall, an individual went into the store to alert Walmart staff asking them to barricade the area to avoid her being hit by a car,” Cohen wrote. “Staff said they could not comply nor did they come out to assess the situation. A good Samaritan by the name of Milan retrieved a sleeping bag from inside the store to cover Dorothy. Milan then called her grandsons who quickly arrived at the scene. Her grandson Simon Fauteux held the sleeping bag over her head to shield her from the falling snow, however she was still laying on top of the snow covered ground as she could not be moved.”

Cohen added that the Montreal fire department arrived first and ensured she could be brought indoors. He wrote that Urgences Santé arrived nearly an hour after the initial 911 call was made.

The resident’s daughter-in-law said that motorists “opened their doors to create some kind of barrier to prevent further injuries.”

Cohen wrote that Baker’s hip was shattered and could not be replaced, and that two metal rods and multiple posts were inserted instead to ensure she could walk again. She was then in rehab, rushed to hospital with a pulmonary embolism, and then went back to rehab, where she contracted COVID.

The councillor was told that the store manager apologized to the family and allegedly told them that store personnel were not fully detailed on what took place, that they underestimated the urgency of the situation and that retraining should take place so that this does not happen again.

Cohen also revealed that an insurance company is reviewing the case.

“This ordeal has taken a toll on both Dorothy and her family,” the councillor wrote. “Her life will be greatly impacted as a result of this.

“We thought Walmart was all about community and customer appreciation,” says a family statement.

Steeve Azoulay, senior director of public affairs for Walmart, told The Suburban and Cohen, “We’re aware of the incident and are very sorry to hear a customer was injured in the parking lot. While we’ve been in touch with the family, given that this is an ongoing matter and out of respect for all parties involved, we cannot provide further comment.” n

CSL senior seeks accountability from Walmart after injury Read More »

Supreme Court rejects St. Laurent rapist’s appeal

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Supreme Court of Canada last week dismissed an appeal by former St. Laurent resident Erich Shimon Chemama, who has tried to have his convictions for rape and other offences dismissed for many years.

The Quebec Court of Appeals ruled against Chemama in April 2024, in a judgment by Justices Martin Vauclair, Robert Mainville and Marie-Josée Hogue. A psychiatric evaluation said he has a “personality disorder with significant narcissistic and antisocial psychopathic components,” and he was declared a dangerous offender, very likely to reoffend.

Chemama had been found guilty for crimes that occurred in his St. Laurent home against sex workers, including two counts of sexual assault, two counts of forcible confinement and two counts of uttering death threats. In terms of the third of three incidents, he was acquitted of one count each of sexual assault, forcible confinement and uttering death threats.

Chemama will now have to serve his sentence for an indeterminate amount of time.

Chemama, 28 years old at the time of the first, Oct. 7, 2009 incident, asked an agency for an escort. The victim was referred in court documents as O.M., 18 at the time.”Mr. Chemama grabbed [the victim] and pushed her on the bed,” the judgment states. “O.M. screamed, but Chemama turned up the volume of the TV set to cover her voice. Making a gesture as if to look for a concealed object, he threatened to kill her, saying, ‘I’ll make it like a Soprano (a reference to the HBO show about the Mafia), no one will find your body.’”

The victim, who knew her life was being threatened, “gave in to Mr. Chemama’s commands” and unprotected sex of various types took place. The escort was then told by Chemama not to go to the police, saying he was a lawyer. “To secure O.M.’s silence, he pulled her driver’s licence from her purse and photocopied it. He also dialed her phone number to make sure that the number obtained from her was correct.” The sexual assault left the victim with injuries in the areas where she was violated.

The next incident, on Nov. 25, 2010, involved another escort, also 18 and referred to in the court documents as A.O., who was offering her services for the first time. As with the first incident, A.O. declined to engage in sex without a condom and rejected a demand to engage in oral sex. “Mr. Chemama replied that she would have to do whatever he wanted. He then aggressively tried to perform oral sex on her, which she protested against. Mr. Chemama then became upset.” The incident then became physical and threatening.

Chemama “grabbed her by the neck and a rough fight followed. When A.O. screamed and bit his gloves, Mr. Chemama shouted, ‘If you don’t shut up, I’m gonna f—–g kill you. I’m gonna take your body, cut it up and put it in a bag. I did that to many girls before, you don’t know me – I’m a sick guy.’” He also said, ‘If you don’t shut up, I’m gonna tape your mouth and no one is going to hear you.’ When A.O. screamed and asked to be let go, Mr. Chemama tried to cover her mouth. Then a light came on and an older lady, whom Mr. Chemama identified as his mother, came into the room, exchanged a few words with him in a foreign language, then she left.”

A.O. then called “police, police, police!” and was rescued by her driver and the building’s janitor. Chemama was then arrested.

The Appeals Court document also pointed out that while he was incarcerated, Chemama “has been the object of numerous complaints and numerous incidents — 300 over five years according to the carceral authorities — involving both verbal and non-verbal violence, threats, refusal to cooperate and the like.”

“As an example of Mr. Chemama’s [activities] in detention, he once poured bleach in a coffee machine that was used by the prisoners. A petition by Mr. Chemama’s fellow inmates followed to ‘get rid’ of him [was] a first in the services director’s experience of 26 years in carceral institutions.” n

Supreme Court rejects St. Laurent rapist’s appeal Read More »

Second suspect arrested for firing on Jewish school

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A second suspect has been arrested for firing a gun at Yeshiva Gedola School in November 2023, a month after Hamas terrorists attacked Israel, killed 1,200 people and kidnapped 250.

The suspect is Feijhoo-Leito Joseph, 19, of Vaudreuil.

Numerous Jewish institutions in Montreal, throughout Canada and around the world, were attacked in the aftermath of the Oct. 7, 2023 massacre perpetrated by Hamas. Yeshiva Gedola, located on Deacon Road at the eastern tip of Côte des Neiges-NDG, was fired upon twice in late 2023, on Nov. 9 and 12.

Joseph was arrested the morning of Feb. 19 for the Nov. 12 shooting and has appeared at the Montreal courthouse. Last May, police arrested Mahdi Ahmed Abdirazak, 20, of Les Cedres, also for the Nov. 12 shooting. He was charged with discharging a firearm, theft and receiving stolen vehicles.

The SPVM investigation had continued after the first arrest “regarding the possible participation of one or more other individuals. Various elements collected by the team responsible for the investigation made it possible to identify a second suspect.”

A CIJA announcement welcoming the arrest provides more information, that the second suspect was arrested for discharging a firearm and theft of an Acura, as well as aggravating hate factors.

“While this is a welcome development, far more must be done to send a strong message that those who have sought to terrorize Montreal’s Jewish community since Hamas’s Oct. 7 attack will be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law,” the CIJA statement says.

The organization added that while it recognizes the efforts of the police that led to the arrest, “it is now up to prosecutors and the courts to ensure this case leads to meaningful and lasting change.

“A strong sentence will deter those intent on continuing this campaign of hate, which has resulted in violence, shootings, firebombings and vandalism. We will use every available tool to push this objective forward.”

Henry Topas, Quebec regional director of B’nai Brith Canada, praised the SPVM for the latest arrest.

“A strong message must be sent,” he added. “Those behind this cowardly act of intimidation against the Jewish community must be held responsible for their antisemitic acts.” n

Second suspect arrested for firing on Jewish school Read More »

Montreal punishes St. Laurent, LaSalle for early snow clearing

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Last Tuesday Feb. 18, 48 hours after the two mega snowstorms that left some 70 cm of snow on the ground , the streets in the City of Montreal were a hellscape of barriers created by snowbanks left on major and side streets during the initial snow removal process.

The corners of westbound Van Horne and northbound Décarie and Victoria were down to one lane because of a massive snowbank. Drivers stuck in traffic on northbound Décarie headed to Paré were forced onto side streets that were packed with cars as snowbanks caused the two-way streets to be narrower. Cars headed in either direction came close to scraping each other.

Such was the state of streets under the responsibility of the City of Montreal.

And yet, two boroughs, St. Laurent and LaSalle, which took the initiative to clear snow ahead of a City of Montreal-dictated schedule after a 20 cm snowfall earlier this month, are being told they used up their one instance of misbehaviour, and that the next time this happens, they will have to pay for the snow removal themselves — not the centre city.

LaSalle borough mayor Nancy Blanchet told the Feb. 17 Montreal city council meeting that her borough, St. Léonard, St. Laurent and Anjou asked Montreal for permission to at least partially clear the snow ahead of Montreal’s designated date. When this was denied, LaSalle and St. Laurent went ahead anyway, the latter doing so from Feb. 4 to 7, Mayor Alan DeSousa told the media.

DeSousa further said last week that, in relation to the latest snowstorm and overall city policy, “although this is exceptional precipitation, snow loading operations are further hampered by the reform of the snow removal policy imposed by Projet Montréal last spring. The result —Montrealers must wait even longer before the snow is removed from the public domain.”

Blanchet told the Feb. 17 council meeting that her borough went ahead with its early February snow clearing for security reasons.

The Plante administration has responded that the Services de concertation des arrondissements (SCA) committee decides when snow clearing in boroughs take place, and to what extent — partial or complete.

LaSalle city councillor Richard Deschamps told the Montreal meeting that borough councils should make snow clearing decisions, not centre city officials.

Plante told Deschamps that the centre city’s decision process for snow clearing enables a better sharing of resources, but that she would consider a change if deemed necessary. n

Montreal punishes St. Laurent, LaSalle for early snow clearing Read More »

“We live and breathe our children!”

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Hundreds of Montrealers came together last Thursday at Côte St. Luc’s Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue to mourn the deaths of Shiri Bibas, her children Ariel and Kfir Bibas and Oded Lifshitz, 84, all kidnapped by Hamas Oct. 7, 2023 and then slain by the terrorist group.

Hamas staged a parade of the coffins of the children earlier in the day in what Rabbi Reuben Poupko of Beth Israel Beth Aaron called an “orgy of sickness.” Just before Thursday’s event began came the cruel news that what was supposed to be the returned body of Shiri Bibas, the youngsters’ mother, was instead that of an unknown individual. Bibas’s body was then released Saturday. Yarden Bibas, the father, was released alive Feb. 1.

Speakers, including Rabbi Poupko, CIJA Quebec vice-president Eta Yudin, Rabbi Zolly Claman of CSL’s Congregetion Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem and Aviva Drazin, an organizer of the weekly Sunday Montreal march for hostages, called for the release of the rest of the hostages and for strong action from the Canadian government. Cantor Adam Stotland of Shaare Zion Synagogue sang and led prayers. On hand were CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein and Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather.

Rabbi Poupko said Hamas knew their victims very well, and “how much we love our children.

“That’s why they took Kfir and Ariel,” he said. “They know how we live and breathe our children. Who does that? Oded Lifshitz, 84 years old, Ariel, four years old, Kfir, 10 months old [on Oct. 7, 2023]. Who does that? Old people, babies! Not a shred of humanity left in the hearts of these people! Who does that? And who decides to go to demonstrations downtown, screaming ‘long live Oct. 7! Glory to our martyrs! Long live the intifada!’ Explicit calls for violence against every Jew!”

Yudin said that Hamas’ return Thursday of an anonymous body instead of Shira Bibas “was another twisted attempt at psychological terror, another attack on the heart of the Jewish people, another attack on Israel!”

Rabbi Claman said the community was gathered “to try to find words to describe the indescribable, it’s a waste of time. We’ve all cried individually today, we all know there’s nothing to say.

“But there’s a value in coming together, to cry together.”

Drazin said the Jewish community worldwide, and the allies “who stood by our side, have been praying for, shouting for, marching for the return of all the hostages.

“Each one is a world, each one has a family, friends, dreams, hopes. But there’s something about Shiri, Ariel and Kfir that struck a chord for so many.” n

“We live and breathe our children!” Read More »

Scroll to Top