Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue

“We live and breathe our children!”

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Hundreds of Montrealers came together last Thursday at Côte St. Luc’s Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue to mourn the deaths of Shiri Bibas, her children Ariel and Kfir Bibas and Oded Lifshitz, 84, all kidnapped by Hamas Oct. 7, 2023 and then slain by the terrorist group.

Hamas staged a parade of the coffins of the children earlier in the day in what Rabbi Reuben Poupko of Beth Israel Beth Aaron called an “orgy of sickness.” Just before Thursday’s event began came the cruel news that what was supposed to be the returned body of Shiri Bibas, the youngsters’ mother, was instead that of an unknown individual. Bibas’s body was then released Saturday. Yarden Bibas, the father, was released alive Feb. 1.

Speakers, including Rabbi Poupko, CIJA Quebec vice-president Eta Yudin, Rabbi Zolly Claman of CSL’s Congregetion Tifereth Beth David Jerusalem and Aviva Drazin, an organizer of the weekly Sunday Montreal march for hostages, called for the release of the rest of the hostages and for strong action from the Canadian government. Cantor Adam Stotland of Shaare Zion Synagogue sang and led prayers. On hand were CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein and Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather.

Rabbi Poupko said Hamas knew their victims very well, and “how much we love our children.

“That’s why they took Kfir and Ariel,” he said. “They know how we live and breathe our children. Who does that? Oded Lifshitz, 84 years old, Ariel, four years old, Kfir, 10 months old [on Oct. 7, 2023]. Who does that? Old people, babies! Not a shred of humanity left in the hearts of these people! Who does that? And who decides to go to demonstrations downtown, screaming ‘long live Oct. 7! Glory to our martyrs! Long live the intifada!’ Explicit calls for violence against every Jew!”

Yudin said that Hamas’ return Thursday of an anonymous body instead of Shira Bibas “was another twisted attempt at psychological terror, another attack on the heart of the Jewish people, another attack on Israel!”

Rabbi Claman said the community was gathered “to try to find words to describe the indescribable, it’s a waste of time. We’ve all cried individually today, we all know there’s nothing to say.

“But there’s a value in coming together, to cry together.”

Drazin said the Jewish community worldwide, and the allies “who stood by our side, have been praying for, shouting for, marching for the return of all the hostages.

“Each one is a world, each one has a family, friends, dreams, hopes. But there’s something about Shiri, Ariel and Kfir that struck a chord for so many.” n

“We live and breathe our children!” Read More »

Noa Tishby attracts 1,800 in CSL

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Noa Tishby, the Israeli author, actress, activist and the country’s former Special Envoy for Combating Antisemitism and Delegitimization, attracted a huge audience estimated at some 1,800 last Thursday to Côte St. Luc’s Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue, where she spoke as part of the Frieda and Mike Dym Memorial Lecture series.

Lines formed at the synagogue more than 90 minutes before the start of the event. Many watched her speech on a screen from a large room used for gatherings. Also on hand were Israel Consul-General Paul Hirschson, Yair Szlak and Steven Sebag, CEO and board chair of Federation CJA respectively; Eta Yudin, Quebec vice-president of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather and CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein.

Tishby engaged with BIBA’s Rabbi Reuben Poupko in a question and answer format, and delighted the crowd by filming them for social media. She said that when the Oct. 7 terrorist attack began, she broadcast live on Instagram for hours and, heartrendingly, received texts from Israelis imploring for the police or soldiers to rescue them.

Tishby said Israel and Jews around the world have the truth on their side, prompting applause. She also noted that Rabbi Poupko said there are two wars now taking place — one against Hamas and the other against antisemitism.

“The third war is between western values and jihadism. This is something I make sure I communicate very clearly….It’s jihadi culture that is hiding itself and pretending to be something it isn’t. It’s very important to keep removing the veil and exposing it for what it actually is. It’s the most important war this world is facing and the Jewish community is, again, at the forefront of it.”

Tishby also noted that people compare Hamas to the Nazis. “Hamas is worse. The Nazis were very methodical, but here we have religious fervour. Imagine if the Nazis had religious ecstasy for killing Jews. They thought it was the best thing for the human race. The animals we’re dealing with now think they’re doing the most spiritual thing in the world. We have to make sure we communicate that to the world — that this is why it’s not just our war. It’s happening right now in Belgium, Denmark, the U.K., Australia, Canada, the U.S., on campuses, everywhere!”

Tishby was also asked how to deal with people who claim everything that took place Oct. 7 to Israelis is a lie. “Those are the same people that insisted that Jews use the blood of Christian children to make matzos. If somebody says he or she has an issue with an Israeli policy or politician, we can have the discussion. If somebody tells me they don’t believe the footage Hamas filmed themselves, it’s literally the same as the blood libellers.”

She said that historically, the denial is not new, but it seems like it is. “Oct. 7 was the most documented pogrom we ever had. Self-documented! A reality TV show they created. And still people don’t believe it. And I hate to say this, we need to be okay with that. Not not to fight it, but to understand that this is the reality historically. They always don’t believe us! We have to prove it!”

Tishby said one media personality demanded to see proof that a baby was burned by Hamas Oct. 7.”Do you really? We have to acknowledge that is what’s happening. That is the reality we’re dealing with right now and what our ancestors have dealt with for generations! It’s not going to change!” n

Noa Tishby attracts 1,800 in CSL Read More »

Poilievre receives thunderous welcome in Mount Royal

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Federal Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre received a thunderous welcome during his standing-room only speech at Côte St. Luc’s Beth Israel Beth Aaron Synagogue March 26, which attracted some 1,400 people who gave Poilievre numerous standing ovations and waited in line for hours to take a picture with him.

It was so large, that it prompted prominent Conservative supporter Anthony Koch to tweet Liberal MP Anthony Housefather, currently reflecting on his future with the Liberals, about it. Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi replied, “I have no doubt our riding (Mount Royal) is going blue in a very big way!” And when Housefather earlier posted about “hopping from one party to the other” during Purim, Levi replied, “hopping from one party to the other is fun indeed (even when it’s not Purim!)” Previously, Levi posted that he was endorsing the Mount Royal Conservative candidate, and he was hoping it would be Housefather.

The federal Conservative leader, currently riding high in the polls, was joined at the synagogue by Conservatives Senator Leo Housakos and Quebec City-area MP Pierre Paul-Hus, and many other notables.

Before Poilievre spoke, Federation CJA board chair Steve Sebag condemned the passage of the recent “disgraceful” Liberal-NDP motion on the Israel-Hamas conflict, and lauded the Conservatives for their unanimous No vote. “Your moral clarity and steadfast support of the Jewish people in Israel is deeply needed and appreciated in these dark hours,” Sebag added. “Thank you for your friendship.”

The Conservative leader, who has visited Israel, said “the Jewish people are the only people I know of who, in the same language, worship the same faith, on the same land, in the same country as they did 3,000 years ago. That is a true indigenous people!” Thunderous applause followed.

Turning to current events, Poilievre said that “We know, since the [Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel], it has been necessary for us to turn our attention to the defense of our shared values, our eternal values.” He pointed out that before the attack, Israel had achieved peace through the Abraham Accords with several Arab countries, and it looked like Saudi Arabia might be next.

“Could you imagine what a breakthrough for peace it would have been?! This would have charted in a new era of peace and friendship among all of the Abrahamic peoples! It was this hope that most terrified the terrorists who carried out their attack on Oct. 7 and, more importantly, the state sponsors who orchestrated it all out of Tehran. They worried that their mission to destroy the Jewish people and Israel would be mortally wounded, their mission would be impossible, if Muslims and Jews were able to unite together in peace. What scared them even more was the possibility that the Palestinians had a hopeful future, a vested interest in the days ahead of them.”

Poilievre also pointed out that Hamas had total independence to run Gaza, as Israel had pulled out all Jews from the area in 2005. “When they say, ‘end the occupation’, in Gaza, the only occupier was Iran. Iran was occupying Gaza through its intermediary, Hamas!…And so they orchestrated the attack. The Hamas leaders travelled to Tehran, they got weapons and funding, and ultimately coordination. I’m sorry, but I refuse to believe that ragtag terrorists in Gaza were able to accumulate all of those weapons and all of that intelligence and coordination on their own! This was an outside job!”

Poilievre said Iran’s involvement “forms our policy as a country towards Tehran, and its terror arm, the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. The IRGC murdered 55 Canadian citizens and 30 permanent residents by firing an unprovoked missile at a civilian commercial aircraft, PS 752, over three years ago. This group can recruit, coordinate, mobilize, fundraise legally on Canadian soil. What is our Prime Minister thinking?! It’s time to ban the IRGC!”

Poilievre said he would also pressure the Trudeau government to streamline funding for the security infrastructure program, “so that shuls and all places of worship can put up the security to protect their people. I think it is appalling synagogues and churches are buried in paperwork for what what should be a very simple rebate program!” Poilievre also promised, to very long and sustained applause, that his party will stand with Jewish students on campuses, “fighting antisemitism at universities. We will also go line by line through all the groups that get dollars from the federal government and defund every single one of those that promote antisemitism in our country!…. We will continue to stand up for the right of Israel to defend itself and reject any motions and resolutions before the UN that unfairly target the Jewish State!”

Poilievre says he conveys the same message in mosques. “I say ‘I’m a friend of the State of Israel,’ and I will be a friend of Israel everywhere I go.

“Conservatives will stand with you! You are not alone in these struggles, you have friends!….I want you to look at the echo of the unmatched history of the eternal Jewish people!…The trashcan of history is filled with those who have tried and failed to destroy the Jewish people! I don’t know what will happen next year, or in a hundred years but I know that in a thousand years whatever is going on, on Fridays as the sun goes down, there will be Shabbat in Israel! The Jewish people will still go on, and they will say “am Yisrael Chai!” n

Poilievre receives thunderous welcome in Mount Royal Read More »

Scroll to Top