McGill University

McGill obtains injunction against SPHR

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill University has announced that Quebec Superior Court granted its request for a provisional injunction against Students for Palestinian Honour and Resistance (SPHR).

The injunction had been sought just after a three-day student strike at McGill during which classes were interrupted, Jewish students intimidated and much vandalism committed. The university pointed out that the injunction was needed at this time as exams are underway.

McGill president Deep Saini pointed out that the ruling states “McGill has a clear right to an order that allows it to carry out its academic activities without obstruction” and that “McGill is entitled to the protection of its property.”

More specifically, the court ruled that SPHR and any person aware of the judgment, “must not block or obstruct the entrance to any building where McGill is operating; must not engage in protests within five metres of any building where McGill is operating; and must not obstruct the delivery or performance of academic activities such as courses or exams.”

The provisional judgment was put in force for a 10-day period.

“The university applied for the injunction following SPHR’s involvement in classroom obstructions and vandalism during a three-day student strike April 2-4, 2025,” Saini explained. “In his decision, the judge recognized the harm done to the McGill community by protest activities that resulted in vandalism, violence, and intimidation tactics.”

The ruling also stated that “violence, intimidation and the destruction of property cannot be tolerated in this country, least of all at our universities, whose very mission is to foster learning and the expression of opinion through peaceful, respectful dialogue.”

Saini reiterated, as he did in his previous message to the community on this issue, that he will “vigorously defend everyone’s right to free expression and peaceful assembly, while also protecting our campus from abuses of these freedoms, especially when they hurt our academic mission or cause injury to others.

“Many of you are working steadfastly to maintain stability in our community despite differing viewpoints on a range of very challenging and sensitive topics. Thank you so much for this work, which supports the teaching, learning and research that we so cherish.” n

McGill obtains injunction against SPHR Read More »

McGill seeks injunction against anti-Israel group

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill University has filed a request with Quebec Superior Court for a provisional injunction against the anti-Israel group Students for Palestinian Honour and Resistance (SPHR), university president Deep Saini announced.

In a message to the McGill community, Saini wrote that the legal step was taken “to protect the rights of students and staff to pursue their studies and work free from threats, obstructions and harassment. The judge heard our request and we are awaiting his ruling.”

The injunction was sought just after a three-day student strike at McGill during which classes were interrupted, Jewish students intimidated and much vandalism committed.

Saini added that with student exams underway, “McGill is asking the Court to prohibit protesters from intimidating or harassing people trying to enter McGill buildings or classrooms, from obstructing academic activities, or from obstructing access to buildings. The university also requested that protesters remain five metres away from buildings used for its operations, whether on or off campus.”

Saini further explained that the injunction request “clearly states that the university considers protest by McGill students and staff, within reasonable limits, to be not only permissible but also important. McGill seeks to uphold freedom of expression and peaceful assembly while protecting the rights of students to continue their academic journey without obstruction.

“The goal of the injunction is to ensure that the integrity and stability of our academic activities are preserved during this critical period of the school year. We are first and foremost a university, and we must focus on our mission and the rights of our students to undertake their academic pursuits in a peaceful environment that supports their well-being and success.” n

McGill seeks injunction against anti-Israel group Read More »

Superior Court halts SSMU antisemitism resolution

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Superior Court Judge Bernard Larocque granted McGill University student Samuel Levkovsky and many other complainants permission to proceed with its case against the Students’ Society of McGill University regarding what they consider to be its biased policy on what constitutes antisemitism.

The judge also issued a six-month restraining order against the SSMU, halting the ratification of the policy. The students are represented by Spiegel Ryan lawyer Neil Oberman, and Choueke Hollander’s Michael Hollander. As reported by The Suburban last December, Superior Court Judge Daniel Urbas granted a 10-day injunction halting the ratification of the policy.

The SSMU policy against antisemitism, which on the surface appeared to be a straightforward denouncing of the portrayal of all Jews as evil and blaming them for actions by Israel, did not include disproportionate criticism of Zionism and Israel. “This narrow framing effectively permitted an environment where hate could persist on campus, as it excluded any negative sentiments aimed at Israel and its inhabitants from being classified as antisemitic,” Oberman told The Suburban.

Generally, the lawyer explained that the case involved “the fundamental right of students to express their voices and concerns as stipulated by the bylaws and regulations of the SSMU.

“Unfortunately, despite having secured an injunction aimed at safeguarding their rights in December, the SSMU chose to disregard this legal protection. They proceeded with actions that were deemed unlawful, specifically seeking to ratify a controversial policy known as the null policy. This particular policy was poised to have detrimental effects on Jewish students on campus, raising serious concerns about discrimination and antisemitism.”

Oberman added that the complainants had no choice but to stop the ratification process. “We sought justice for those affected and aimed to ensure that all student voices were heard in matters directly impacting their community.”

In light of the March 5 judgment, Oberman said the SSMU policy on antisemitism cannot be legitimized or upheld moving forward. “The need for a more inclusive and accurate definition is crucial in order to combat all forms of hatred effectively and ensure that all individuals feel safe and respected within the community.”

Superior Court halts SSMU antisemitism resolution Read More »

McGill calls on police to investigate antisemitic incidents

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill University has called on the SPVM to investigate incidents of antisemitic graffiti and intimidation — graffiti was discovered on the Redpath Library building saying “Hail Satan LOL” and included a Nazi swastika.

When the encampment of anti-Israel protesters was dismantled in July, they vowed to return in one way or another. Some protesters recently tore up parts of the McGill campus lawns. The perpetrators fled and no arrests were made, The Suburban was told at the time.

In the current case, McGill has not specified what the incidents were.

In an email to the McGill community from Christopher Manfredi, McGill Provost and Executive Vice-President and Fabrice Labeau, Vice President Administration and Finance, they wrote, “in recent days, our campus has seen hate incidents, ranging from graffiti to intimidation of our campus community, acts which any reasonable person would consider antisemitic.

“Incidents were reported to the Montreal police and McGill’s security professionals are working with them to provide video or other evidence needed to identify suspects. Once the police’s investigation is completed, the attorney general will determine if charges will be laid. We will also immediately start disciplinary processes against any person identified as a member of the McGill community who was involved in these appalling events.”

They added, “as president Deep Saini has stated many times, antisemitism, like any form of hate, has no place on campus. We know that the McGill community unites behind us in unequivocally condemning these acts and in reaffirming our commitment to a campus free of discrimination, violence and hate.”

Eta Yudin, vice-president of the Centre For Israel and Jewish Affairs, Quebec, posted, “For too long, antisemitism has taken over our campuses and has plagued academic life. Together with our partners at Federation CJA, we have consistently and directly advocated for concrete action. We are encouraged that McGill appears to be taking the crisis seriously and expect further action to be taken, particularly as agitators continue to disrupt classes. The administration must remain vigilant and responsive.” n

McGill calls on police to investigate antisemitic incidents Read More »

McGill-led team may have identified anorexia cure

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , ,

By Joel Ceausu
The Suburban

McGill University announced that a McGill-led research team working with a French Sorbonne-led team (CNRS, INSERM and Sorbonne university) “believes it has identified the neurological mechanism underlying anorexia nervosa as well as a possible cure.”

The team’s findings, published in Nature Communications, “have the potential to improve the lives of millions of people around the world, mostly women, who suffer from the common eating disorder, which has the highest mortality rate of any psychiatric disease.

“Working with mice, researchers discovered that a deficit in a neurotransmitter in an area of the brain associated with the reward system, can lead to excessive habit formation and precipitate the compulsive self-starvation seen in people who suffer from anorexia nervosa.”

McGill Psychiatry professor Dr. Salah El Mestikawy, the senior author on the paper and researcher at the Douglas Research Centre, “looked at whether using a medication known to increase the presence of the neurotransmitter in the brain could have an effect on these compulsive self-destructive behaviours.”

“We found that it fully reversed the anorexia-like behaviour in mice, and we believe that it could potentially offer the first mechanism-based treatment of anorexia nervosa. In fact, we are already seeing its effects on some patients with the disease.”

As well, “ongoing independent studies in Toronto and Montreal led by an independent psychiatrist Dr. Leora Pinhas are showing positive results for 10 patients with severe anorexia nervosa who are being treated with low doses of the drug, donepezil. Three patients are in full remission and the other seven show a marked improvement. Further double-blind clinical trials, comparing results of those taking a placebo with those taking the medication, are due to take place this year at Columbia University, Denver University, and the Hôpital Sainte-Anne in Paris.

Mestikawy says, however, that “between clinical trials and government approval, it may take several years before a new drug can be used to treat anorexic patients, and there may be possible effects on other diseases involving compulsive behaviours. The McGill researchers are working with the French team to develop a novel compound with fewer problems. “We also suspect that other compulsive pathologies such as obsessive-compulsive disorders (OCD) and addictions can also be improved by donepezil, so we are actively looking for collaboration with other psychiatrist around the world to explore the possibilities.”

McGill-led team may have identified anorexia cure Read More »

Community rallies at McGill against anti-Israel hate

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Large numbers of Montrealers turned up last Thursday, May 2 at the Roddick Gates of McGill University to rally against anti-Israel hate emanating from the encampment inside the campus that was established on April 27. The crowd was so large Sherbrooke St. was closed for three hours. While the pro-Israel crowd chanted “Bring them home” about the hostages still held by Hamas since its terrorist attack on Israel Oct. 7, and “Am Yisrael Chai,” the anti-Israel demonstrators chanted slogans such as “all Zionists are racists.” Some 50 of the latter group formed a chain and faced off against the SPVM, some of whom were on horseback.

The pro-Israel rally was organized by the student group StartUp Nation, Chabad at McGill and Chabad at Concordia, Bring Them Home Now Montreal and many other organizations. On hand were Yair Szlak and Steven Sebag of Federation CJA, former CSL councillor Glenn Nashen and many others, including Cantors Adam Stotland, Gideon Zelermyer and Daniel Benlolo, who sang together.

Anastasia Zorchinsky, founder and president of the StartUp Nation group, said “we’re here to stand for peace, we’re here to stand for unity! We’re also here to call out the vile hate that has been infesting our universities!….We’re experiencing the worst cases of antisemitism our generation has ever seen because of universities like McGill and Concordia, which are not enforcing their policies when Jewish students are targeted!”

Just before the rally began, Premier Legault called on the SPVM to dismantle the “illegal” encampment.

Michael Eshayek, also of StartUp Nation, called on universities to “stand up against Jewish hatred and to be on the right side of history! Today, it’s the Jewish community, tomorrow it will be someone else!”

McGill law student Jamie Fabian said when the anti-Israel mobs call for intifada, “we don’t call for violence. We use the law, and as law students, as Jews, we stay peaceful. We use the law to defend what’s right, and what’s right is not antisemitism!”

McGill graduate Sydney Rouah, who was in Israel Oct. 7, said Jewish life is “bigger and stronger, and certainly more important, than ever! I woke up Oct. 7 thinking it was a regular Saturday morning, I soon realized how wrong I was. I saw many sights that still shocked me. I see people younger than me changing into uniform, running in to war to save their people with no regard what could happen to them.”

McGill alumni Dr. Samantha Balass said the university “has become the breeding ground for antisemitism and what is McGill’s response? Underwhelming! They shuffle their feet and dodge responsibility, leading to the rampant antisemitism festering within their walls! McGill, we demand better and we will settle for nothing less!”

Szlak, president and CEO of Federation CJA, said, “we are here in support of students who celebrate and sanctify life, and we stand in stark contrast to the pro-Hamas campers who celebrate the deaths of Jews and Israelis and are calling for a global Intifada.”

Rabbi Reuben Poupko, who thanked Premier François Legault for his support of Israel and calling for the dismantling of the encampment, said the anti-Israel activists “think they’re reliving the 1960s, singing John Lennon’s Give Peace A Chance.

“Peace rallies don’t have slogans like ‘long live Oct. 7’, “long live Hamas’, ‘glory to our martyrs’, ‘globalize the Intifada’! Those aren’t peace slogans! Those are battle cries! We know how this movie ends — with the Jewish people strong and secure! I wish everyone here the strength, the resilience, the courage and the wisdom to keep up the fight and to make sure your voices are heard every day!” n

Community rallies at McGill against anti-Israel hate Read More »

Concordia and McGill to sue Quebec over tuition hikes

Local Journalism Initiative / / / , , ,

Photo Alice Martin

Maria Cholakova
Local Journalism Initiative

On Feb. 23, Concordia President Graham Carr announced that the university is set to take legal action against the province after months of discussions with the government.

According to Carr’s statement, the decision to pursue legal action comes after months of unsuccessful talks with the government and Coalition Avenir Québec’s (CAQ) rejection of Concordia’s French language program proposal. 

The CAQ has reduced the increase for out-of-province students from $17,000 to $12,000. However, despite the change, Carr wrote that the provincial government “never worked with us in any substantive way to hear, let alone address, our wide-ranging concerns.”

Concordia is already feeling the effects of the hikes, with the university seeing a 27 per cent decrease in out-of-province student applications. In addition, the university is already in financial trouble, with a current deficit of $35 million, on top of the $362 million of total debt. 

Due to these challenges, Concordia is ready to take legal action, stating that they “have no choice but to pursue a just outcome.”

Concordia’s main reasons for the action are its financial troubles, the belief that “diversity is a critical driver of excellence,” the need for accessible education for all, and the importance of “equality among francophone and anglophone linguistic groups and the protection of Quebec’s minority English-language community.”

Concordia isn’t the only English university taking legal action. McGill has also pursued a similar lawsuit, although completely separate from Concordia’s. 

Apart from the Concordia administration’s efforts to put an end to the tuition hikes, student groups around campus have continued their mobilization efforts. Twelve student associations went on strike from Jan. 31 to Feb. 2, and many are set to strike again from March 11 to March 15. 

Concordia and McGill to sue Quebec over tuition hikes Read More »

Scroll to Top