Joel Goldenberg

CSL council rejects location for Public Safety station

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Côte St. Luc council, in a recent caucus meeting, affirmed that a potential new Public Safety station will not be on a greenspace on The Avenue between Cavendish Blvd. and Park Place, as originally proposed in the city’s master plan.

That original location was a factor that prompted Councillor Mike Cohen to vote against bylaws related to the master plan.

“The late [councillor] Ruth Kovac had designated a park for that spot, she even named it [Volunteers Park],” Cohen said last November. “Residents have been asking me for a park there for 10 years.”

Instead, the location will potentially be elsewhere in the area around Cavendish. The current location is at the site of the old city hall at 8100 Côte St. Luc Road.

During a public consultation meeting, residents supporting a move from 8100 CSL Road said Emergency Medical Services response times would be reduced for many residents in distress, while area residents did not want the location on the parkland.

After hearing from residents at the consultation, Mayor Mitchell Brownstein said he was adamantly opposed to the station being at Cavendish and The Avenue.

“I am not going to have it go there,” he emphasized. “It was designated parkland by the province. Presently, cities are being audited for converting parkland into something else. So it’s not something that is looked upon positively.”

Brownstein also said that the intersection is “our town centre, in front of city hall,” adding that they want a potential redevelopment of Quartier Cavendish to be beautiful.

“It’s our area. Why would we want to give that away?” Instead, a station could be built anywhere between Mackle and Cavendish and The Avenue, a potential town centre as envisioned in the master plan, or at the community garden in the area that could be relocated.

“My recommendation to council is to stop this uncertainty amongst certain residents — it’s just, remove that use from that location from the master plan.”

Cohen was pleased, telling The Suburban, “I’ve been against it from Day 1. I asked when it was being raised as a possibility that this should have been brought to the residents months ago and we could have asked what they thought. Instead, they just dropped it in the master plan, which was very undemocratic. I met with my residents, going door to door in the winter, and privately by Zoom, and they were adamantly against it. If it had been presented in a better way, maybe they would have be open to it.

“The Mayor heard their concerns. There’s plenty of other good spots for the station. It was an ill-conceived thought to begin with.”

The council as a whole rejected the parkland location a day after the public consultation.

CSL council rejects location for Public Safety station Read More »

Montreal Holocaust Museum staging online events on antisemitism

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Montreal Holocaust Museum is hosting a series of online events in the next two months focused on the current rise in antisemitism in Canada and around the world, especially after the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel.

A statement by the MHM points out that in Canada alone, antisemitic incidents have increased by 172 percent in recent years. The series will be looking at how to learn to recognize antisemitism, the impact on its victims and what can be done to counter it in its various forms.

The first online event takes place 7 p.m. Feb. 26 online, and involves a discussion about the book The 7 Deadly Myths: Antisemitism from the time of Christ to Kanye West.

Author Alex Ryvchin “will be in conversation with Anthony Housefather, Member of Parliament for Mount Royal and the Prime Minister’s Special Advisor on Jewish Community Issues and Antisemitism,” says the MHM statement. “The discussion will touch on the earliest origins of antisemitism and how this age-old hatred manifests today.” The discussion is being held in partnership with the Vancouver Holocaust Education Centre. Reserve a free ticket at museeholocauste.ca.

The next online event takes place from March 10 to 17, and is screenings of the film David Baddiel: Jews Don’t Count.

“Is there a hierarchy of prejudice placing Jews firmly at the bottom? Comedian David Baddiel outlines why he feels anti-Jewish sentiment seems less concerning to those who oppose all other forms of discrimination. David Schwimmer, Sarah Silverman, Stephen Fry, and Miriam Margolyes join David to explore why there appears to be silence from those who often shout loudest about bigotry.” A free ticket must be reserved as well at the MHM’s website.

The third online event takes place 11 a.m. March 20 and is a discussion in French between Delphine Horvilleur and the MHM co-president Honourable Jacques Saada on Horvilleur’s book How Isn’t It Going?: Conversations After October 7.

“Devastated by the massacre perpetrated by Hamas on October 7, 2023, Delphine Horvilleur sees her world shatter. As a rabbi dedicated to supporting and alleviating the suffering of others, she suddenly finds herself in a state of shock, feeling powerless and voiceless. In this fevered state, she pens this small yet powerful treatise on survival, a slice of self-analysis that reconnects her with her existential foundations.” Reserve a free ticket at the MHM website.

The MHM is also highlighting a teaching guide called A Brief History of Antisemitism in Canada, which “provides teachers with an opportunity to learn about historical antisemitism in order to understand its various manifestations in Canada during the Holocaust (1933-1945).

“Particular emphasis is placed on the Quebec context – including a brief history of the Quebec Jewish community – while examining how antisemitism influenced Canadian governmental policies, media, public discourse and action regarding the situation of Jews in Europe and in Canada.” The guide can be downloaded for free at the MHM’s website.

Also highlighted by the MHM in the “collection” category is the book Jews in Caricature by Eduard Fuchs.

“This book illustrates the stereotypes that have been associated with Jews for many centuries. It was published in 1921 in Munich and was written by Eduard Fuchs, author, art collector and political activist. The caricatures demonstrate the existence of antisemitism before the Nazis took power in Germany.”

More information about the book and about the spread of antisemitism through caricatures can be found at the MHM’s website. n

Montreal Holocaust Museum staging online events on antisemitism Read More »

Demerged cities oppose $20 million debt for Namur-Hippodrome

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Association of Suburban Municipalities is officially filing before the Quebec Municipal Commission its opposition to an island-wide agglomeration $20 million borrowing bylaw in relation to the proposed Namur-Hippodrome development, according to a resolution passed at a Feb. 10 Côte St. Luc council meeting.

Councillor Dida Berku, who introduced the resolution, explained that the mayors of demerged municipalities met Feb. 10 to mandate a law firm to file the opposition. The $20 million is to be used to acquire properties around the Namur-Hippodrome project, which the councillor said is actually the responsibility of the City of Montreal and not the entire agglomeration.

The next step for the ASM would be to proceed to Quebec Superior Court if necessary.

Last month, Berku quoted an agglomeration summary as saying that the $20 million was to be borrowed because “land acquisitions will be required to ensure mobillity and the opening up of the area bordered by the CN and CP rail lines, and the Décarie Expressway.”

The summary also noted that acquisitions could “enable the development of Cavendish Boulevard, the development of mass transit and the development of the projected bicycle network….This will make it easier to accommodate the new 20,000-unit real estate development.”

Berku told the January CSL meeting that “if any level of government, be it federal, provincial or agglomeration, is going to spend money on the Quartier Namur-Hippodrome, in our view, it should not be spent without Cavendish” for a link.

“It should be part of that overall spending program. We know the City of Montreal put aside close to $100 million for Cavendish and now it’s been redirected to Namur-Hippodrome-Cavendish-Jean Talon, basically redirecting it to Jean Talon.” n

Demerged cities oppose $20 million debt for Namur-Hippodrome Read More »

Federation CJA marking Jewish Disability Awareness Month

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

This month, for the seventh year, Federation CJA is marking Jewish Disability Awareness, Acceptance and Inclusion Month.The organization points out that it is a “unified effort among Jewish organizations worldwide … to raise awareness and foster acceptance of community members living with disabilities and mental health conditions.

“This year, Federation CJA provided grants of up to $1,200 to 23 local organizations, schools and synagogues, helping them to alleviate financial costs associated with running activities and programs during JDAIM,” the organization’s statement says.

Yair Szlak, President and CEO of Federation CJA, pointed out that the organization “remains deeply committed to creating a community where every individual feels valued and supported.

“From inclusive education and employment opportunities to recreational programs and community-wide initiatives, Federation CJA is proud to empower individuals living with disabilities and their families to thrive and fully participate in Jewish life.”

JDAIM also includes numerous local events as part of the awareness effort, such as an art vernissage and cooking and baking demonstrations. Events open to the public include:

• Feb. 12, 19, 25: Sensory Story Time at The Jewish Public Library.

• Feb. 13: Dorshei Emet Tu B’Shvat educational and advocacy initiative “Branches of Belonging: Cultivating an Inclusive Community”.

• The Friendship Circle presents two events including the DeLaMie Bakery “Babka Bake”, and their “Friend Blend” party bringing teen volunteers and families together.

• Feb. 16: The Adath Seniors Brunch: Where Community, Connection, and Inclusion Meet, featuring The Montreal Shira Choir.

• Feb. 18: Ometz and L ‘Annexe, the Ometz Centre for Young Adults, in partnership with Cummings Centre and Sylvan Adams YM-YWHA, present “From Strength to Strength”, their annual Art Exhibition.

• Feb. 20: “JDAIM Market” at Federation CJA featuring vendors from social enterprise partners and people that employ persons living with diverse abilities.

Federation CJA also points out that “several Shabbat initiatives will take place over the month at the Adath Israel with neurodivergent speakers. Catering will be from Zera Café, a not-for-profit social enterprise with a mission to meaningfully employ neurodivergent adults.

Szlak added that the spirit of JDAIM “reflects the essence of our Jewish values—compassion, inclusion, and unity. By removing barriers and fostering understanding, we are creating a stronger, more vibrant Jewish community that welcomes and celebrates the contributions of all its members.”

For a complete listing of Montreal’s JDAIM 2025 Community Calendar of events, visit: https://jlive.app/organizations/104. For more information on how to access services in the community, consult the community resources section at federationcja.org/inclusion or contact inclusion@federationcja.org.

Federation CJA marking Jewish Disability Awareness Month Read More »

B’nai Brith CEO Michael Mostyn passes

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Longtime B’nai Brith Canada CEO Michael Mostyn passed away last week after a year-long battle with cancer.

B’nai Brith Canada referred to Mostyn, who became CEO in 2014, as a “dynamic leader, a passionate advocate, and above all, a genuine mensch. Michael’s life was dedicated to tikkun olam—repairing the world—a mission he embraced with every position he held and with every life he touched.

“Michael’s vision and leadership revitalized the organization, transforming it into a formidable voice in combating antisemitism and defending the rights of the Jewish community across Canada. His passion for justice was deeply rooted in Torah values, and whatever he did in life, was undertaken with tremendous respect and unwavering integrity.”

Members of the Jewish community and Canadians in general mourned the loss of Mostyn.

Iddo Moed, Israel’s ambassador to Canada, said, “His legacy as an unrelenting advocate for the State of Israel, as a leading fighter against antisemitism in Canada and as a sharp critic of support to anti-Israel organizations and groups will undoubtedly continue through the strong voice of B’nai Brith Canada.”

“Michael was a steadfast advocate for the Jewish community and a dedicated leader in the fight against antisemitism. His unwavering commitment to justice and human rights has made a profound impact on our community and Canada as a whole,” wrote the Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Centre.

Senator Leo Housakos referred to Mostyn as “a steadfast advocate against antisemitism and a champion for human rights. His unwavering dedication to justice and equality has left an indelible mark.”

Official Languages Minister and Outremont MP Rachel Bendayan said Mostyn was a “a true giant in the Jewish community. His legacy at B’nai Brith Canada will live on.”

Toronto Liberal MP Marco Mendicino said, “He dedicated his life to advocating for the Jewish community. He did so with strength and kindness. I am thinking of his family. May his memory be a blessing.” n

B’nai Brith CEO Michael Mostyn passes Read More »

No agreement yet between CSL and Quartier Cavendish

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The City of Côte St. Luc and Mandevco, the developer of Quartier Cavendish, are not yet agreed on the city’s position regarding a potential redevelopment of the mall site in what the CSL master plan says would be part of a town centre on and around Cavendish Blvd.

The city’s vision for the area says “it is essential that shops and local services be retained in a redevelopment project, in addition to interior and exterior public spaces. A dense residential component with high quality architecture, coupled with a mobility hub, is essential to create a complete neighbourhood.”

During last week’s public meeting on CSL’s master plan and the town centre, Councillor Mike Cohen asked about future discussions with Quartier Cavendish about such issues as the amount of storeys of buildings in the area — he mentioned six to eight storeys, and 20 storeys.

Associate City Manager Tanya Abramovitch said Quartier Cavendish has higher numbers in mind.

“Every project has to come to council,” she said. “If a building doesn’t fit or is out of scale or doesn’t fit in, it won’t be accepted at the Planning Advisory Committee level, let alone council. Council ultimately decides.”

Cohen said council has not met with Mandevco officials for several years.

“I do believe, at the appropriate time, council needs to meet with staff in a large group with the Quartier Cavendish people, and before we adopt any master plan, there needs to be a meeting with the owners of Quartier Cavendish like we did many years ago when they talked [in a public meeting] about demolishing half the mall.”

The Suburban sought more details about the differences between the city and the owner of Quartier Cavendish. Councillor Dida Berku said the city has not yet fixed a time to meet with the owners.

Berku said the city wants to find out what the differences are.

Haven’t they expressed it, we asked.

“No,” she said. “They’ve told us in writing that they have issues with the maximum and minimum heights, setbacks, ground floor commercial use and parking requirements. We don’t have their final brief and they’ve told us they will send us one ‘with our comments and opinions on the draft bylaw.’”

Berku said that until the city receives that final brief with their issues and comments, “I don’t think we’re ready to address their issues, because there are questions they raise where there may just be a misunderstanding, or a misinterpretation.”

The councillor said the city envisions heights of buildings of six to eight storeys, and the owners may want much higher buildings.

“That could be a major difference. We’re not there yet.”

The Suburban contacted Mandevoco and awaits a reply. n

No agreement yet between CSL and Quartier Cavendish Read More »

Concordia investigating Student Union over BDS vote intimidation

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Some 100 mostly masked anti-Israel activists held a protest last Thursday outside Concordia’s GM Building on de Maisonneuve West to press the Board of Governors to vote on a Boycott Divestment Sanction motion approved at a Jan. 29 Concordia Student Union meeting. There was a heavy police and Concordia security presence inside and outside the building.

Less than 2% of the Concordia student body participated in the BDS motion, which called for divesting from companies which the CSU says helped Israel in its war against the terrorist group Hamas. The Suburban has checked the minutes of the Feb. 6 Board of Governors meeting, and saw no reference to the BDS vote.

However, the Concordia administration has decided to investigate the Jan. 29 meeting, according to an email and a statement by university President Graham Carr. The email was sent Feb. 6, the same day as the Board of Governors meeting, to the CSU by Concordia provost Anne Whitelaw and Concordia VP of Services and Sustainability Michael Di Grappa.

Concordia is probing if the Hall building auditorium was filled beyond capacity for the vote and thus violated regulations, and also alleges that the mezzanine was used for additional voters without authorization. The university is also checking whether the CSU allowed the People’s Potato to serve food without permission.

The university also alleges that “there was discrimination against and intimidation of a group of students during the CSU event that took place in the auditorium. The information and reports that we receive suggest, among other things, that heavily masked individuals were present and created an intimidating climate, that chants glorifying terrorism and recognized terrorist groups were made and tolerated, and then opposing voices were silenced.”

As well, it is alleged that the CSU “permitted and facilitated conduct that compromise the values of civility, equity, respect and non-discrimination and created an intimidating and hostile climate for members of the Concordia community.”

As well, all CSU bookings for events on campus, including in the Hall building, have been suspended until the investigation is complete.

Also, in the immediate aftermath of the Jan. 29 CSU vote, Carr released a statement that the meeting included the “presence of heavily masked individuals, complaints of discriminatory behaviour and the use of intimidation tactics. This behaviour is unacceptable on campus and contravenes our policies.

“The university has no input on the motions presented by the CSU or on its deliberative and decision-making processes. But we will examine the behaviour around and at the special meeting, and urge those who have complaints to report them.”

The Feb. 6 anti-Israel pressure protest, which took place hours after buildings at McGill were vandalized, included chants of “from the river to the sea,” “long live the intifada”, “close the campus”, and “if we don’t get it, shut it down.” There were also references by speakers to the “criminal administration” and there was an effigy of Carr, with the names of companies the CSU voted that the university should divest from, attached to the figure.

One masked speaker representing the CSU said the McGill vandalism should not be conflated with the bigger concerns of pro-Palestinian activists. Another speaker accused the administration of ignoring “acts of violent anti-Palestinian racism on campus,” and condemned Carr’s statement about the Jan. 29 meeting. A masked speaker from Solidarity for Palestinian Human Rights Concordia made reference to the “Zionist entity” and the “shameless white supremacist administration” ignoring student demands.

The protest concluded with a march that had a police escort that proceeded to McGill University, which also had a Board of Governors meeting and where its buildings were again vandalized, this time with red paint. n

Concordia investigating Student Union over BDS vote intimidation Read More »

Union demands removal of Urgences Santé CSL video

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

A lawyer for the CSN union representing paramedics sent Côte St. Luc councillor Mike Cohen and resident Nancy Benabou letters of demand that they take down a now very widely seen video on Instagram of an Urgences Santé paramedic after she allegedly declined to speak English while in the process of treating a patient.

The paramedic was treating CSL resident Rachel Benabou, 91, and was speaking to her and her daughter Nancy in French. But when neighbour Lana Mastromonaco asked the paramedic to clarify something in English, the paramedic allegedly refused. It was at this point that Nancy Benabou began filming. They allege the female paramedic said, “Madame, nous sommes au Québec.” Cohen was alerted about the incident by the residents, who live in his District 2.

Urgences Santé has defended the paramedic, saying it was agreed that the exchange with the patient would be in French, and also cited patient confidentiality in the paramedic declining to translate.

Cohen told The Suburban Friday that the video of the dialogue with the paramedic received 1.6 million views. He and Benabou, after receiving the legal letter, took down the video. We are told the letter contended that the reputation of the paramedic was being harmed. Cohen made a new Instagram video explaining this latest development.

“With the video and the publicity we generated of this incident, I think we made our point,” Cohen told The Suburban. “We’ve spoken to Urgences Santé and they’ve been very attentive.”

Cohen, CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein and Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather also sent a letter in English and French Friday to Urgences Santé on behalf of Rachel Benabou and “all our constituents who would prefer to express themselves in English when interacting with your staff during a medical call.”

The three explained the paramedic’s alleged refusal to speak English, and added, “as you are aware, the current Quebec government has stated on several occasions that health care services are exempt from Law 96 and has revised the recent directive to make clear that anyone can ask to receive services in English.

They added that it is difficult to imagine “that any paramedic working in the western sector that includes CSL where the minority language population is approximately 70 percent, is not sensitive to the fact that they may need to address a patient, or anyone in their entourage in English.

“Indeed, the paramedic in question apparently had spoken in English earlier, so irrespective of whether it is the patient or someone in their entourage trying to help them, there is no legal impediment for your paramedic to comply, especially considering the pressure of the situation and desire for someone to help a 91-year-old.”

Cohen, Brownstein and Housefather are seeking “clear confirmation” from Urgences Santé that those who contact the ambulance service and ask to receive responses in English “will indeed receive responses in English”; that employee and contractors of Urgences Santé “will be trained on how to respond in this type of situation and that it will not reoccur. As this has received a considerable amount of publicity, we encourage you to respond to us as quickly as possible.

“As you know, we are available to meet with you and would like the signatories of this letter to be present, as our aim is to work together in a spirit of mutual respect to ensure that this type of interaction does not happen again.” n

Union demands removal of Urgences Santé CSL video Read More »

CSL meetings with CDN-NDG on traffic woes imminent

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Staff from the City of Côte St. Luc are set to meet with their officials from Côte des Neiges-NDG very soon regarding traffic issues affecting the two jurisdictions, and then CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein will meet with CDN-NDG Mayor Gracia Kasoki Katahwa, Brownstein told The Suburban Monday.

Councillor Dida Berku told The Suburban the technical teams from CSL and CDN-NDG meet regularly.

Tensions have been building lately between Côte St. Luc, Hampstead and Côte des Neiges-NDG regarding the road work on Van Horne west of Décarie, which has exacerbated longstanding traffic issues in the three areas.

At the Jan. 20 CSL council meeting, Brownstein said he was unhappy that he had not yet received a reply from Katahwa asking for a meeting to discuss immediate traffic solutions, particularly on Vézina between Macdonald and Décarie, a notorious area for traffic tie-ups.

“If the CDN-NDG borough wants to see our master plan include a bike path and passageways for pedestrians on Clanranald, and potentially the widening of Vézina, they need to give us something,” the Mayor told the Jan. 20 meeting. “If they’re not going to respond, they’re not going to get. We have to be tough and let them know — you have to meet with us, you have to talk to us. We need to play hardball.”

Brownstein said CSL has been asking for no parking on Vézina approaching Décarie eastward, and he pointed out that the Décarie Square developers are willing to allow parking on the current mall site during rush hour.

“They can park there right now.”

The Suburban contacted the CDN-NDG Mayor’s office regarding a possible meeting with CSL. We were told that CSL was sent a letter by the Mayor on Jan. 17.

“Our services have been in contact with Côte St. Luc teams since the start of the work,” the CDN-NDG Mayor’s office said. “In fact, we informed them several weeks ago that it was not possible to comply with their request to remove parking on Vézina/Décarie. It’s important to note that this request has been ongoing since well before this work began.”

Brownstein then confirmed to The Suburban on Jan. 22 that he did receive the letter after the CSL Jan. 20 council meeting, and that a meeting will indeed take place.

“I am very pleased [the Mayor] accepted our invitation to meet. There are many ways we can help each other to the benefit of all residents in the area.”

Still, we have heard there are underlying tensions between the two jurisdictions over the long-awaited Cavendish link, as well as Vézina.

As for Côte St. Luc and Hampstead, CSL councillor Mitch Kujavsky told The Suburban last week that he will propose to council possible retaliatory measures against Hampstead, regarding their not temporarily lifting the rush hour left-turn restrictions on eastbound Fleet Road during the work on Van Horne.

“Hampstead residents benefit a lot from being neighbours of CSL, for example, discounts on recreation services _ there are many ways we can consider or reconsider our partnerships with Hampstead,” Kujavsky told The Suburban, adding that he was speaking for himself.

Councillor Dida Berku recently said removing the left turn restrictions “would have been a perfect opportunity for Hampstead to show some good faith.”

Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi recently told The Suburban that lifting the left-turn restrictions temporarily “would be a disaster. The cars would be lined up bumper to bumper to Fleet. It would cripple our snow clearing operations on that side of Fleet. Garbage and recycling would not be able to be picked up either.”

Kujavsky countered that the Van Horne work will “hold up Côte St. Luc residents from leaving our city. People are going to go both ways, they’re not just going to go through Hampstead, they’ll go through NDG also.”

The CSL councillor added that being stuck in standstill traffic on Fleet and Van Horne is not acceptable, and will prompt more air pollution through idling.

Levi responded that what Kujavsky said was “nonsense” and that he did not really want to respond to a hypothetical.

“If he’s going to retaliate because we’re concerned about the safety and security of our streets, I think it would be a very silly thing on his part.” n

CSL meetings with CDN-NDG on traffic woes imminent Read More »

Collision caused 8,000 litre gas spill in St.Laurent railyard

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

An accident that had the potential for a major disaster took place in St. Laurent Friday morning at the CN railyard on Hickmore Street in the borough’s western industrial area, not far from Autoroutes 520 and 13.

The area has been in the news a great deal in recent years, primarily for criminal activity involving arson.

The latest incident involved a train hitting a fuel truck in the yard, resulting in the spilling of some 8,000 litres of gasoline and ethanol.

The train was travelling at a low speed. The collision took place at about 10:30 a.m. Jan. 31. Crews from CN responded, as did 20 members of Montreal fire department’s hazardous materials team a half-hour after the incident, but no fires took place, and the spill was quickly brought under control.

Officials from the provincial and federal environment departments were also on the scene to determine what impact the spill had.

CN released a statement during the day that “all measures [were] being taken to minimize the environmental impact” and apologized “for any inconvenience caused by this incident.” The cause of the accident was not immediately known. n

Collision caused 8,000 litre gas spill in St.Laurent railyard Read More »

QAHN announces grants for local Anglo heritage

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Quebec Anglophone Heritage Network has announced a call for proposals for Heritage Micro-grants, for which the deadline is Feb. 28.

The QAHN is a “non-profit, non-partisan, province-wide organization engaged with its members in the preservation and promotion of the history, heritage and culture of Quebec — and, in particular, of Quebec’s English-speaking communities.” The organization says it “strives to advance the knowledge of the history, heritage and culture of those communities by informing, inspiring and connecting people through its activities and services.”

The QAHN points out that “thanks to generous support from the Department of Canadian Heritage under the Dedicated Fund for the English-speaking communities of Quebec, QAHN is pleased to announce a first call for proposals for its new Supporting Heritage Awareness, Recognition and Engagement (SHARE) program.”

Non-profit member-organizations of QAHN “are eligible to apply for a micro-grant of up to a maximum of $25,000.”

The SHARE program will be funding projects that “raise the visibility of the English-speaking heritage of Quebec, build bridges and foster dialogue between English-speaking minority and French-speaking majority communities,” and “encourage collaborative endeavours between Anglophone and Francophone heritage organizations or groups.”

For more information about program objectives, conditions and eligibility, and/or to obtain the application form, contact the SHARE Project Coordinator, Julie Miller (julie@qahn.org). n

QAHN announces grants for local Anglo heritage Read More »

Montrealers commemorate 80 years since Auschwitz liberation

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Gelber Centre was packed Monday night for the Montreal Holocaust Museum’s commemoration of the 80th anniversary of the liberation of the Auschwitz concentration camp where more than a million Jews were slaughtered.

On hand were the Consul-General of Germany, the Deputy Consul of Italy, federal Liberal leadership candidate Chrystia Freeland; former federal Liberal Pablo Rodriguez, who plans to seek the Quebec Liberal leadership; Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather, Anna Gainey, Alexandra Mendès and Rachel Bendayan; and D’Arcy McGee MNA Elisabeth Prass. UFC star Georges St-Pierre was on hand earlier in the evening.

MHM president Jacques Saada thanked the large audience for attending, saying “it means so much — today, especially, as we are going through a revival of antisemitism around the world.”

Rodriguez asked the community to work together “for a future in which such atrocities like the Holocaust never, never happen again. Let us commit ourselves to transmitting this memory to future generations so that history does not repeat itself and human dignity is preserved for all.”

The main event at the commemoration was an interview of Holocaust survivor George Reinitz by longtime CBC journalist Peter Mansbridge. Born in Hungary and now in his 93rd year, Reinitz came to Canada in 1948, and became a world class wrestler and a successful businessman with Jaymar Furniture, founded by Reinitz in 1956.

Reinitz, who was deported to Auschwitz at the age of 12 in 1944 and was the only member of his immediate family to survive, told the harrowing story of his daily battles to find food to eat — this included risking his life to leave his barracks at night to find discarded potato skins, which he shared with others. One time, he was caught, but an intoxicated guard let him live.

Asked by Manbridge if he was worried that history could repeat itself, especially with the current level of antisemitism, Reinitz said that education is the way to counter this.

“There are always going to be people who want to kill you, whether it’s because you’re a Jew or a Christian” he said. “We came a long way from those days when I was a kid. Antisemitism is going to be here forever. We’re lucky we have an Israel where we can go and fight and try to survive.”

Mansbridge told Reinitz that one way to counter antisemitism is to “make sure people like you tell their story.

“Without you reminding us of what happened, people will forget….The answers are education and leaving behind a record, which you’ve done many times.”

Reinitz later received a surprise, a wrestling sweater from longtime Concordia wrestling coach Victor Zilberman and a letter of tribute from Wrestling Canada read by Zilberman’s son David, a Canadian Olympic freestyle wrestler. n

Montrealers commemorate 80 years since Auschwitz liberation Read More »

Supreme Court will hear EMSB Bill 21 challenge including on Notwithstanding

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Supreme Court of Canada decided last Thursday that it will hear the challenge against Bill 21 brought by the English Montreal School Board, Mubeenah Mughal and Pietro Mercuri against the Quebec government, including its pre-emptive use of the Notwithstanding clause.

Bill 21 prohibits the display of religious symbols in the legislature, courts, by police, by teachers in public schools and certain bureaucrats.

As reported by The Suburban, last March, the Quebec Court of Appeal ruled that Bill 21 is constitutional and dismissed requests for a judicial review and a declaratory judgment.

That three judge panel — composed of Manon Savard, Yves-Marie Morrissette and Marie-France Bich — agreed with a Superior Court judgment that Bill 21 is “valid with respect to division of powers and does not offend Canada’s constitutional architecture or the unwritten principles of the Constitution, nor does it offend any pre‑Confederation statute or principle having constitutional status.” The judgment also says that the use of the Notwithstanding clause was valid and in this case overrides the Quebec and Canadian Charters.

Commissioner of Official Languages of Canada Raymond Théberge stated that he was pleased with the Supreme Court’s decision to hear the case, and added that as Bill 21 “has undeniable effects on minority schools in Quebec, I will therefore be filing an application to intervene in this matter before the Supreme Court of Canada to address the interpretation of section 23 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, including with regard to the English speaking minority’s right to management and control over their facilities and instruction.”

Quebec Justice Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette and Secularism Minister Jean-François Roberge posted that “secularism is a fundamental value for living together and a vector of social progress. It constitutes an individual right and protects the freedom and equality of all. It is through secularism that all Quebecers, of all affiliations, can come together and form a strong, modern and united nation.”

They added that an intervention by the federal government “would not only be disrespectful, but could not be considered anything other than an attack on the autonomy of the [provinces].”

English Montreal School Board chair Joe Ortona said the board, which based its case primarily on Section 23, maintains “our original position that Bill 21 conflicts with our values and our mission and with those of all Quebecers as expressed in the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms. Its very adoption was contrary to our societal goal of promoting our peaceful co-existence in a pluralistic Quebec.

“[Bill 21 also] sends a message of intolerance and exclusion to our students and their families. We are pleased to go forward in front of the highest court in the country.”

The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has been granted leave to intervene in the case. “We look forward to arguing our case that Bill 21 is an unconstitutional law that harms people who are already marginalized and has no place in Canadian society,” the organization posted. n

Supreme Court will hear EMSB Bill 21 challenge including on Notwithstanding Read More »

NDG’s Isidor Mesner looks back on 105 years

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The first question The Suburban asked NDG resident Isidor “Izio” Mesner is how he would describe his 105 years. “First of all, it’s something that happens to very few — so many events, so many wars in my lifetime that I went through — it was mixed, sometimes happy when I was married, sometimes very terrible,” the NDG resident said.

Mesner, who celebrated his birthday Sunday with a tea party with some friends, was born in Przemsyl in the Galicia area of Poland Jan. 19, 1920. “My parents had a grocery store and we were a middle class family — we didn’t have so many problems like so many Jewish people,” he explained. “There was hardly any intermixing with the non-Jewish people. There were Poles, Ukrainians and Jews, and they lived their own lives. No one intermarried. Any hostility was mostly not openly shown, but there was some boycotting of Jewish stores.”

When the Germans invaded Poland, in 1939, Mesner was studying outside his city. “I couldn’t go back to my city. Someone told me I could go on a train to the Soviet Union, at night. I jumped on the train and then ended up in Dagestan [in the North Caucasus in Russia], near Georgia.”

Luck helped him survive the war. In Russia, “I was first given a job of supervising people working in a field with vegetables. People were stealing, and one time I stole some vegetables too because I was hungry. They caught me — the usual punishment was 20 years in jail, but for some strange reason — maybe they took pity on me — they didn’t sentence me.”

Mesner later left and found other work. “From time to time, I was getting sick — I would go to the hospital for a couple of days, that was relaxation. I had malaria and other illnesses. Then I went to a kindergarten — a woman there told me indirectly that her husband was killed by Stalin — and I worked there. I was then sent to an office for an examination for military service and when I came back home, I got sick — I had typhoid, and that saved me. The people who were supposed to join the army were instead taken to work in fields, and they were dying of hunger. Eighty percent of people who had typhoid died. I was young and able to survive.”

While Mesner survived, sadly, most of his family was killed, with the exception of his sister, who married a French professor and lived in France. After the war, Mesner himself received a military passport and lived in France. “There was no future for me there, so I went to a DP camp in Germany and spent time in Munich. My aunt, my mother’s sister who lived here, secured papers for me and I came to Montreal in 1950.”

Mesner lived on St. Urbain Street, in the famed Jewish area of Montreal, and other areas of the city until he moved to his CSL Road condo in 1980. In 1952, he met his future wife, Mila Sandberg-Mesner, and married her a year later. Sandberg-Mesner was a Holocaust survivor well known in the Montreal community for working for decades at the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts and internationally for speaking about her experiences during the war in Poland, and writing about her life in several books, including the acclaimed Light From the Shadows. They were both the subject of the partly animated film Second Chances, awarded Best Documentary Feature at the Queens World Film Festival in New York last year. They were married until her passing in November, 2023, just before her 100th birthday.

Mesner has lived a modest life in Montreal in the last 75 years, working several jobs including for the Fleetwood television manufacturing company, and thriving through success in stock investments. Later in life, he became a director-general of a company participating in the annual fireworks competition in Montreal. When they retired, he and Mila travelled extensively, including to where he and his wife grew up.

“It was always my desire to travel,” Mesner says. The Suburban, of course, had to ask the question asked of all those who have lived to be 100 or more — how did you do it? He is in generally good health, with the exception of high blood pressure. “I liked doing exercise, skiing and I was quite active.” We were also told that everything he eats is organic and natural.

Amy-Sue Silcoff of Compagnons-Dropin-Companions, which provides in-home care for Mesner, marvels at his longevity and continued energy. “When I started to work with Izio and his wife more than three years ago, you couldn’t keep up with him,” she told The Suburban. “He was fast on his feet, he would run down the hallway. I would take him to Beaver Lake, he was amazing at 100 years old. We’ve become like family. He still exercises in his building’s gym- he’s amazing! For us, it’s been a pleasure and a privilege to care for the Mesners — kind, loving, generous people.” n

NDG’s Isidor Mesner looks back on 105 years Read More »

Mackle-Jean-Talon link a ‘non-starter’: CSL councillor

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The City of Montreal late last year proposed a link between Mackle Road in Côte St. Luc east to Jean Talon in Côte des Neiges-NDG, it was revealed during a Jan. 13 CSL public consultation on the city’s master plan, held at CSL city hall.

During the meeting, attendees were assured that any redevelopments of CSL’s three malls and changes in other locales will not take place in the near future, and only after an extensive process. Some attendees said nothing should be redeveloped until the Cavendish link between CSL and St. Laurent takes place, and there was also concern about traffic on a completed Cavendish link.

CSL associate city manager Tanya Abramovitch told audience members that the Cavendish extension is not happening any time soon. “I wouldn’t fret about Cavendish Blvd. just yet,” she said. “There’s a huge setback with Montreal right now, where they’re reprioritizing and having cockamamie ideas about Mackle. They’re worried about hooking up [with] the Hippodrome, so as it stands right now, I don’t see Cavendish happening for quite a while. And whatever version it is, it’s so far away right now. [Montreal’s] number one priority is Jean Talon, and they’re struggling with that one. I wouldn’t worry about Cavendish just now, at all.”

CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein told The Suburban that, “In principle we are not opposed to Montreal looking at creating other links, but only after it has kept its decades-long commitment snd built the Cavendish Link. And Montreal should get no money from Ottawa or Quebec for the Hippodrome until Cavendish is done because the Link was a condition of Montreal getting the Hippodrome site from Quebec.

Councillor Dida Berku, who is deeply involved in the Cavendish dossier, publicly revealed late last year that current plans have Jean Talon not connecting with Cavendish Blvd., even with the planned Hippodrome housing development. Instead, westbound Jean Talon would end within the border of Côte des Neiges-NDG. As for Mackle, Berku told The Suburban, “when the City of Montreal pulled the plug on Cavendish and decided to divert funding towards a Jean Talon tramway bike path, they put forth another option, which is to drive the Jean Talon corridor all the way into CSL through Mackle. This has been proposed since October, November. They presented it to us as an option, which I consider to be a total non-starter because there’s wetlands, train tracks and it’s of absolute no utility nor any practicality to it.”

There will be meetings in the coming weeks involving the master plan — a virtual information session 7 p.m. Jan. 23 on the Westminster corridor, a virtual session on the area of Caldwell and Kildare 7 p.m. Jan. 29 and an in-person/virtual hybrid session at CSL city hall on the proposed town centre area on and around Cavendish at 7 p.m. Feb. 3. For more information on how to participate, go to cotesaintluc.org/en/engage/planning-program. n

Mackle-Jean-Talon link a ‘non-starter’: CSL councillor Read More »

Rotrand awarded King Charles III Coronation Medal

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Marvin Rotrand, the longtime Snowdon councillor, former head of B’nai Brith’s League For Human Rights and now director general of the group United Against Hate Canada, was awarded the King Charles III Coronation Medal last week.

Rotrand was nominated for the award by his municipal successor Sonny Moroz, and the medal was awarded virtually via Zoom by Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather. The award is given for outstanding achievement in public service to the community and to Canada. Numerous political and community leaders spoke and were on the Zoom call, amongst them Luzviminda Mazzone, President, Federation of Filipino Canadian Associations of Quebec and Cynthia Waithe, President of Barbados House. The MC was new EMSB commissioner Chelsea Craig.

Rotrand, speaking from Indonesia, told the Zoom call, “I believe in good government and that government can do good for people, gives opportunity, lifts people out of poverty, prevents hate and discrimination and fosters peace and cooperation.

“It was a privilege for me to be the city councillor for Snowdon for 39 years, and in all that time, those were the issues I championed. I continued doing that in my role at B’nai Brith Canada and it’s what I’m doing now with United Against Hate Canada. There are common themes in all these positions — building solidarity, harmony and cooperation, understanding and promoting diversity as an asset.”

Housefather said Rotrand is a “very special person,” with whom he has worked for 30 years — “30 years of trying to build a future for the English-speaking minority of Quebec at a time when the English-speaking community was greatly threatened by many actions of the provincial government.

“The diversity on this call is a tribute to the kind of person Marvin is because, whatever the community, Marvin has tried to be a beacon for inclusivity of all communities. We want to be judged as people and Marvin’s been an inspiration in making sure that everyone is treated as an equal individual.”

Rotrand’s son, Graeme, speaking for the family, said his father’s most important work “has been his career-long fight for a more just and a more equitable Canada and Montreal. That’s a fight he continues today.”

Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein said Rotrand “is an example of a grassroots politician who, more than any other that I know, has been appreciated by people of all backgrounds, and he’s done so much.”

Moroz told Rotrand he is someone “who goes above and beyond, in terms of the hours of commitment, but also to the detail that you put into your work. It’s unbelievable and more than what a medal can properly signify because you’ve had an impact with your actions over time.”

English Montreal School Board chairman Joe Ortona thanked Rotrand for his support of the board, particularly as regards Bill 40, the provincial law seeking to abolish school boards.

“There were very few elected officials who understood what Bill 40 was all about, and he always wanted to know where we were at with the court cases. He still asks me to this day.”

Lac St. Louis MP Francis Scarpaleggia told the meeting there was a reason Rotrand was Montreal’s longest serving municipal councillor.

“To experience the success and longevity Marvin did in the lion’s den of politics, you need to be true to your constituents and be true to yourself. Short-term success may be possible without these, but not long-term success….You have and continue to inspire me and others in political life, as well as those contemplating how they can make a difference in their community and by making their communities stronger, they make the country better.” n

Rotrand awarded King Charles III Coronation Medal Read More »

Van Horne roadwork will impact traffic for months

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The City of Montreal started major roadwork Monday on Van Horne west of Décarie that will impact traffic for drivers in CDN-NDG and the neighbouring cities of Côte St. Luc and Hampstead for several months.

The work is being done to modify and make additions to the underground electrical conduits of the Van Horne sector between Décarie and Macdonald.

The work will take place between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m. daily and last until May 21. During Phase 1, the Van Horne westbound lanes are blocked between Coolbrook and Macdonald. Detours will be through Coolbrook, Plamondon and Macdonald. During Phase 2, Van Horne eastbound lanes will be blocked between Macdonald and Coolbrook. Detours are through Macdonald, Plamondon, and Coolbrook.

In general, major work has been done on many streets in the CDN-NDG borough in recent years— sometimes lasting about a month on smaller streets and having an impact on parking for area residents.

Traffic expert Rick Leckner sent an email Sunday to CSL Mayor Mitchell Brownstein, Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi, CSL councillor Dida Berku and CDN-NDG councillor Sonny Moroz expressing his concerns and making suggestions.

“The year is not starting off well for area residents,” he wrote. “What mitigation measures, if any, will be in place to deal with this almost five-month serious traffic issue? Parking must be removed from Plamondon and Vezina for the duration. Has this request been made to the borough or centre city? I assume the SPVM is aware, but they are not always helpful. Public Security in Hampstead has hopefully been alerted.”

Leckner added that “we have seen the highly negative effects of recent work. Here we go again.

“Let us please be proactive.” n

Van Horne roadwork will impact traffic for months Read More »

Car fires continue in St. Laurent

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

What some may consider to be an epidemic of car fires in the borough of St. Laurent continued with two vehicles damaged early on Dec. 31.

Police and the fire department were called at around 2:45 a.m. to the parking lot of a home at Côte Vertu and Lebeau, near the eastern tip of the borough. Police say one car is a total loss and the other suffered minor damage. The SPVM says the cause of the fire is unknown and no incendiary device was found, but that the incident is being investigated by the arson squad.

The Suburban asked SPVM spokesperson Jean-Pierre Brabant why there are numerous incidents of car fires in St. Laurent — some in residential and some in industrial areas.

“We’re looking at it, but there are no answers at this point,” he said. “We’re trying to look into who did this, if the people are connected, but there’s no information indicating a link. But we’re still trying to get those people who are setting the fires.”

Most recently, two vehicle fires took place within the space of a week in St. Laurent, one occurring 9:30 p.m. Dec. 19 in the rear of an industrial building in the area of St. Charles, in the western part of the borough. The other took place early in the morning of Dec. 17 in the area of Jean Bouillet Avenue and Keller Boulevard, this time a residential area, in the north western part of St. Laurent.

A vehicle fire also took place in early November, at Cypihot Street, near Douglas-B.-Floreani Street in the western part of the borough. Three semi-trailers were damaged in that incident.

As reported by The Suburban, numerous other fires have been set in recent years in St. Laurent in the industrial areas of the borough, in the driveways of private homes, destroying and damaging vehicles; and at local businesses allegedly as part of extortion schemes against Arab-owned restaurants. Businesses and restaurants have also been fired upon.

Recently, vehicles in two St. Laurent driveways — both in close proximity to the Beth Ora Synagogue — were set on fire, less than a month apart. And last February, two fires in a space of 90 minutes took place at a home on Alexis-Nihon, damaging several vehicles, and at the Challenger Conference and Reception Hall.

Incidents have stretched even as far back as the 1980s, when an explosion took place at a home near St. Louis — I heard part of the blast in the form of a bang in my home on nearby Brunet Street. n

Car fires continue in St. Laurent Read More »

Two more suspects arrested in murder of west end spa owner

By Joel Goldenberg and Chelsey St-Pierre
The Suburban

The SPVM announced Friday that two more suspects have been arrested in the May 26, 2023 murder of Claudia Iacono, 39, the owner of a west end spa on Jean Talon in Côte des Neiges-NDG. The shooting occurred at approximately 12:45 p.m. on May 16, 2023 when Iacono pulled into the parking lot of her salon. A shooter emerged and fired at least six shots at her vehicle. First responders pronounced Iacono’s death at the scene. Investigators located multiple shell casings in the parking lot. Several employees of the salon along with Iacono’s sister witnessed the shooting.

The murder took place outside the spa as the victim was driving. As previously reported by The Suburban, Iacono was married to Anthony Gallo, son of Moreno Gallo, a prominent Montreal organized crime figure who was killed in Mexico in 2013.Gallo started in the Calabrian mafia before becoming an influential member of the Rizzuto family in the early 1980s. He was shot to death at age 68 in an Acapulco restaurant in 2013.

The two new suspects, Kalial Nesfield, 28, and Shaniqwa Parris, 31, were arrested Friday morning. Both suspects appeared at the Montreal courthouse where Nesfield was charged with first-degree murder while Parris faces manslaughter charges.Both remain in custody as the legal process proceeds.The two are known to police as they have a criminal history. Nesfield pleaded guilty in 2021 to drug trafficking and weapons charges, including possession of a firearm with an altered serial number. Parris faced drug possession charges in the same case, which were later withdrawn.

The police pointed out that the latest arrests are the third and fourth in the course of the investigation. The first suspect, Joel Richard Clarke, 28, was arrested in Toronto with the assistance of the Ontario Provincial Police and was charged with first-degree murder. A second suspect, Tyranne Andre Greenidge, 30, was arrested Aug. 14 in Ontario and faced charges of premeditated murder.

More than a year after the murder, gunshots were heard again at the spa. The police said the murder investigation, “was led by the Major Crimes Section, benefited from the support of several SPVM units.”

The SPVM reiterated “the importance of public collaboration in the fight against gun violence. Anyone with information on this subject can contact 911 or their neighbourhood police station. It is also possible to communicate anonymously and confidentially with Info-Crime Montréal at 514 393-1133 or via the reporting form available on the infocrimemontreal.ca website. Rewards of up to $3,000 may be awarded by Info-Crime Montréal for information leading to the arrest of suspects. Certain conditions apply.” n

Two more suspects arrested in murder of west end spa owner Read More »

Not enough lighting in St. Laurent say residents

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Parts of St. Laurent are too dark because of inadequate lighting, some residents told a recent borough council meeting.

One longtime resident said she and others are concerned about safety.

“We all got alarm systems, we all got cameras, because clearly, there’s something going on. We all see people going in our cars, we see everything, but there’s no lights. So we can’t see the people. There’s just no lights. My mother is 84 years old, she leaves my house and there’s no lights. Why are there no lights? It’s like there is a power failure and every city I go to, I don’t see the same problem.”

Mayor Alan DeSousa asked the resident to identify specific areas. The resident responded, “everywhere I walk, St. Louis, Valade, Fraser, Marlatt, White. My mother leaves my house, each time she says, ‘I’m going to fall, I’m going to fall!'”

DeSousa said no lighting has been removed by the borough, but that the lights “have changed across the entire community.”

“But there’s no lights!” the resident said. “We need lights! We have people robbing houses! St. Laurent is not the way it used to be!”

DeSousa said the street lights are there, “so if there’s a street light missing…”

“We don’t even have the poles!” the resident said. “Fifty people are complaining about the same thing. The lights used to be very bright.”

DeSousa said the identified streets have been around for decades.

“The streets were built in the 1950s and 1960s, the lights are there. The type of lighting has changed, they became more efficient. Our lighting system was fragile, we worked with Hydro-Québec and we followed them, not just on the lighting but on the fragility of the wiring. They replaced them, over three years, all the wiring was changed. If you do have specific areas or streets where the lighting is not there, we’ll check it out and validate what the lighting requirements are.”

Not enough lighting in St. Laurent say residents Read More »

Major CSL master plan consult takes place Jan. 13

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

An important step in Côte St. Luc’s master plan for the future of the city will take place at CSL city hall 7 p.m. Monday Jan. 13 when a legal public consultation takes place, part of the process leading up to the passage of final bylaws.

There has been tension regarding the master plan in recent weeks, with councillors Mike Cohen and Oren Sebag voting against draft bylaws because of objections regarding the process. Residents living around Décarie Square are also concerned a possible mixed development — including residential — could bring extra traffic. The owners of Décarie Square, as reported by The Suburban, have told the city that after five years of waiting if the redevelopment of the mall is not approved by the end of March, the mall administration will renew the lease of the popular store Winners and bring in the massive T&T Asian supermarket for a long-term lease. The Suburban has seen that the nearby St. Laurent T&T is very popular, with parking spaces sometimes difficult to find.

In the meantime, the city has released a plethora of information regarding the master plan at its cotesaintluc.org/engage website. Some of the most pertinent information:

• “In a context where there is a limited availability of land, the city must promote redevelopment with a focus on optimizing land value and transforming underused urban spaces to create sustainable, harmonious, and dynamic areas.”

• Urban redevelopment must involve “a renewal of residential neighbourhoods, adapting to the context and needs of the population and through judicious adjustment of densities when necessary” and “the transformation and consolidation of specific sites with considerable potential.”

The potential redevelopment of Quartier Cavendish, the CSL Shopping Centre and Décarie Square “would take the form of dense, mixed-use development projects. With their large expanses of underused surface parking, there is a considerable opportunity to optimize the properties and create high quality residential and commercial spaces.”

• Regarding Quartier Cavendish, “this redevelopment represents a unique opportunity for the City to create a true town centre and civic hub. It is essential that shops and local services be retained in a redevelopment project, in addition to interior and exterior public spaces.”

• Regarding the CSL Shopping Centre, it “currently provides all the proximity services for nearby residents, and these must be maintained. As it currently has a vast surface parking lot, there is high potential for high density, mixed-use infill development with large public spaces, which would optimize the land and fill in a gap in the urban tissue.” However, “the existence of a fast-food chain with a drive-through located on the property (McDonald’s) is incongruent with the notion of a pedestrian and transit-oriented neighbourhood, and it increases potential pedestrian-vehicle conflict.”

Regarding Décarie Square, “with high-density residential towers nearby, this site has strong potential for a high-density mixed-use development, which would become a complete satellite town centre in CSL. Given that Decarie Square is considered part of the Namur-De la Savane strategic planning sector, any redevelopment project must compliment other large-scale projects in the area, such as the Westbury, the Éco-quartier Namur-Hippodrome, and the Triangle.”

CSL’s document also deals with Westminster Avenue, the area at Caldwell and Kildare, and the Canadian Pacific Kansas City Railway Yard — CSL wants the latter to become, in the long term, a “habitable, mixed-use environment. The development of this site must integrate harmoniously with the city’s current and planned urban fabric and transportation networks along the Cavendish Corridor.” n

Major CSL master plan consult takes place Jan. 13 Read More »

A third of Quebec anglos feel discriminated against

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

About a third of anglophones in Quebec feel discriminated against by the province and feel inhibited in terms of speaking English outside the home, says Statistics Canada’s 2022 Survey on the Official Language Minority Population.

StatsCan says the survey was conducted to “shed light on different aspects of the situation of English-speaking populations in Quebec and French-speaking populations in Canada’s other provinces and territory capitals…. These results will be used to develop official languages policies, programs and services in Canada.”

The survey says that “in 2022, 31 percent of English-speaking adults in Quebec had experienced a situation of linguistic insecurity in the five years preceding the survey—in other words, a situation in which they hesitated to use the minority language….In 2022, 80% of English-speaking adults in Quebec used English daily or a few times a week in the public sphere, outside work with people other than family or friends. This percentage was higher in the Montreal area (83%) than in the rest of the province (69%).”

There has been a tendency over the years, witnessed by The Suburban and others, of two anglophones speaking to each other in French or English questions being answered in French by both francophone and anglophone officials.

Regarding language-based discrimination, 36 percent of Quebec anglophones -compared to 13 percent outside Quebec in the case of francophones — felt “discrimination or unfair treatment based on their use of the minority language in the five years preceding the survey.” The survey does not mention Quebec’s Bill 96 per se, which is perceived to have intensified instances of discrimination against Quebec’s English-speaking population and sparked numerous protests.

Other findings relating to Quebec anglophones include:

-”In 2022, the vast majority (90%) of English-speaking adults in Quebec felt it was important to receive health care or services in English. Among those who felt it was important to receive such services, approximately half (52%) of English-speaking adults in Quebec always or often received health care or services in English.”

-In terms of education, in Quebec in 2022, “66 percent of parents of preschool-aged children in a minority situation intended to enroll their children in an English-language elementary school. An identical proportion (66%) of parents of children who attended elementary school intended to enroll them in an English-language high school.”

The Quebec Community Groups Network posted last week that the StasCan survey “will guide our efforts to advocate for equity and cultural vitality in Quebec.” n

A third of Quebec anglos feel discriminated against Read More »

Two vehicle fires in one week in St. Laurent

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Two vehicle fires have taken place in one week in the borough of St. Laurent.

The latest took place around 9:30 p.m. Dec. 19 in the rear of an industrial building in the area of St. Charles, in the western part of the borough. The vehicle is considered to be a total loss, police say. The nearby building was not damaged. An incendiary device was found.

The other fire in St. Laurent last week took place early in the morning of Dec. 17 in the area of Jean Bouillet Avenue and Keller Boulevard.

That incident took place in the northwestern part of the borough, west of Laurentian Blvd and near Marlborough Park, a residential area. A 911 call to police had been made at 2:45.

Police say the fire department brought the fire under control and that a person of interest had been seen leaving the area.

The vehicle is said to be a total loss. The file was transferred to the SPVM’s arson squad. No one was injured and the fire did not spread.

These fires are the latest of many that have taken place not only in St. Laurent, but in many locations across the island of Montreal in recent weeks and months.

A vehicle fire took place in early November, at Cypihot Street, near Douglas-B.-Floreani Street in the western part of the borough. Three semi-trailers were damaged in that incident.

As reported by The Suburban, numerous other fires have been set in recent years in St. Laurent in the industrial areas of the borough, in the driveways of private homes, destroying and damaging vehicles; and at local businesses allegedly as part of extortion schemes against Arab-owned restaurants. Businesses and restaurants have also been fired upon.

Recently, vehicles in two St. Laurent driveways — both in close proximity to the Beth Ora Synagogue — were set on fire, less than a month apart. And last February, two fires in a space of 90 minutes took place at a home on Alexis-Nihon, damaging several vehicles, and at the Challenger Conference and Reception Hall. n

Two vehicle fires in one week in St. Laurent Read More »

Shield of Athena expanding its shelter

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Shield of Athena, which has been helping victims of conjugal violence for 33 years in numerous languages, recently held its Lilac Benefit Gala to expand its shelter.

The event was held at the Embassy Plaza at 1003 Labelle Blvd. in Laval.

The funds raised are dedicated to the expansion of the Shield’s emergency shelter, which had to double its capacity because of an increase in need for the organization’s services.

“Ever since the pandemic, we have gotten non-stop referrals from S.O.S Violence conjugale, the police and the Director of Youth Protection (D.Y.P.) — so there is a huge need to expand,” says Maria Kokkoris, the coordinator of Athena’s House, adding that the capacity at the emergency shelter has increased from nine to 17 people, “and housing up to 24 at times.”

The evening was hosted by CJAD’s Joanne Vrakas, and featured live music and dining, as well as an exclusive performance by musicians from the Montreal Classical Orchestra. There was also a “silent auction of artworks by renowned artists and a raffle of luxurious prizes.”

The organization also pointed out that it is in the midst of a major capital cost campaign to raise $5 million “to expand its network in Montreal and Laval.

“We need the public’s help to respond to this urgent demand,” says Shield president Chris-Ann Nakis.

The Shield is also adding a fourth point of service, a 17-apartment Second Step shelter that is still under construction.

“We need to respond to these increased needs for shelter by expanding both our capacity and services as well as meeting the rising costs of operations,” says Shield of Athena Executive Director Melpa Kamateros.

The sponsors included the Azrieli Foundation, Schwartz’s, the Papadimitriou Family, Scotia Bank, the Fairmount Queen Elizabeth, the Orchestre Classique de Montréal and many local media. n

Shield of Athena expanding its shelter Read More »

Poilievre holding West Island rally Dec. 13

By: Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Federal Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre is returning to the Montreal area for a “Common Sense” rally being held at noon Friday Dec. 13. The rally is being held at the Sources Mega Centre at 2325 Trans Canada Highway, at the Sources exit off Autoroute 40. Poilievre has made numerous appearances in the Montreal, including the West Island, the Mount Royal riding and other locales.

The event is being held at a time when, according to recent polls, the Conservatives are far ahead of the Trudeau Liberals nationally, and according to recent numbers on 338Canada, the Conservatives and Liberals were tied at 39 percent in the usual Liberal stronghold of Mount Royal — the riding has been declared a toss-up between the two parties. The Liberals recently lost two strongholds, LaSalle—Émard—Verdun in Montreal to the Bloc Québécois and Toronto—St. Paul’s to the Conservatives.

In the West Island, in Pierrefonds-Dollard, the Liberals are ahead 36 percent to 35 percent for the Conservatives, and the riding has been declared a toss-up. in Dorval-Lachine-LaSalle, the Liberals were ahead 31 to 22 percent, and this riding has been declared Liberal likely. In Lac St. Louis, the Liberals are ahead 36 to 31 percent, and the riding has been declared Liberal leaning. Further to the west, in Vaudreuil, the Liberals are ahead 31 percent to 28 percent for the Bloc Québécois and has been declared Liberal leaning.

For more information and to register, go to https://www.conservative.ca/common-sense-rally-with-pierre-poilievre-in-pointe-claire/. n

Poilievre holding West Island rally Dec. 13 Read More »

CSL Mayor blames Plante for SPVM inaction on anti-Israel mobs

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein recorded a video message last week in the aftermath of numerous verbally and physically violent anti-Israel protests, calling on Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante to support the police in restoring order.

The SPVM has been criticized for the fact the McGill encampment remained up for months, and for not intervening when mobs rampaged at Concordia University during an anti-Israel student strike.

“We are at an inflection point in the history of Montreal,” he said. “The world is watching the streets of Montreal and is horrified by what they see. Is violence and intimidation the new normal, or can Mayor Valérie Plante turn this around and give the police her full support so that they restore order?”

The situation of antisemitism in Montreal has become so bad, writes professor Gad Saad in a recent New York Post opinion article, that he took an unpaid leave from Concordia University to teach at Northwood in Michigan. His article, “How Montreal became the antisemitism capital of North America,” shone a spotlight for the world on what is taking place in the city.

In his video, which includes footage of verbally and physically violent incidents, Brownstein said the protests are a test for the police.

“When the Jacques-Cartier Bridge was shut down, the SQ came in to clear the bridge. When Via Rail trains were delayed by pro-Palestinian protesters, the Longueuil police used their emergency intervention unit to clear the tracks. In Montreal, the tone at the top is wrong! Mayor Plante must start sending a message to change the policing strategy of enforcement.”

Brownstein said the police strategy is to avoid conflict “in the face of demonstrations.This police strategy is a choice — it has failed and it must change. The strategy tolerates certain illegal behaviours such as blocking the street or graffiti on cars and buildings, or occupying university areas. It even tolerates protesters who violate a court injunction requiring them to keep a distance away from Jewish institutions. The Montreal police are allowing for the normalization of antisemitism.” n

CSL Mayor blames Plante for SPVM inaction on anti-Israel mobs Read More »

Déry orders probe into anti-Israel intimidation at CEGEPs

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Higher Education Minister Pascale Déry announced Tuesday morning an investigation into whether Vanier and Dawson CEGEPs are taking all available measures to protect students from anti-Israel-related intimidation.

“The climate on some campuses seems to have deteriorated in recent months,” Déry posted on social media.”Several reports have been received by the Ministry of Higher Education to the effect that students are feeling uneasy and even insecure.”

The Minister added that while she knows the Israel-Hamas war “generates its share of emotions, institutions have an obligation to take all necessary measures to ensure a healthy and safe environment for all students.

“Considering the accumulation of denunciations, I officially mandated the ministry to investigate the governance mechanisms in place in the Dawson and Vanier CEGEPs to see if they have taken all the measures at their disposal to guarantee the physical and psychological safety of students.”

Déry emphasized that “the right of students to develop in a healthy and safe environment is non-negotiable.”

Dawson had closed its doors on the day of a recent student strike, during which violence broke out at Concordia University and pro-Israel counter-protesters were given the Nazi salute and told a “final solution is coming.” The CEGEP cited safety considerations for its decision.

Federation CJA and the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, in a joint statement, said they were pleased with the announcement.

“CIJA and Federation CJA have been clear that strong measures are needed to protect Jewish and non-Jewish students from extremists who seek to impose their hateful ideologies through intimidation, harassment and violence. We are pleased with this decision and will continue to engage directly with the Ministry and institutions throughout the process.” n

Déry orders probe into anti-Israel intimidation at CEGEPs Read More »

Hindu community holds CDN march against Bengali persecution

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Members of the Montreal Bangladeshi-Canadian Hindu community held an ecumenical march in Côte des Neiges Saturday to protest the persecution of and increasing violence against Hindus in Bangladesh, part of a larger humanitarian crisis. The march included Christians, Buddhists and Jews.

The march took place from Van Horne Park, then along Victoria to the Plamondon Métro station. The protesters say that religious minorities are being persecuted after political upheaval took place in the country Aug. 5, “when former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina was forced to leave the country amid strong student protests. The newly formed interim government, supported by radical groups, has unleashed violence on religious minorities, particularly targeting the Hindu community.”

Protest organizers added that “Hindus have faced killings, as well as the looting, burning, and vandalizing of businesses, homes, and temples. Amid the unrest, prominent Hindu leader Chinmoy Krishna Das was jailed on alleged false sedition charges after protesting these injustices.”

Anup Chowdhury, Secretary of Sanatan Dharma Temple and one of the organizers of the rally, said “this is not just about the persecution of Hindus, it is a humanitarian crisis that requires immediate international attention.

“Our community is coming together to raise awareness and demand justice for those who have been silenced. The world cannot stand by as innocent people suffer.”

Marc Perez, a supporter of the event, added, “This is a critical moment to unite for justice and human rights.” n

Hindu community holds CDN march against Bengali persecution Read More »

CSL Mayor not invited to master plan meeting

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Last week at a District 1 information meeting hosted by Councillor Oren Sebag at the Le Vicomte residential complex, regarding what a potential redevelopment of Décarie Square could entail, it was revealed that Mayor Mitchell Brownstein was not invited to attend. Brownstein, who viewed the meeting on Zoom, revealed this as part of a long letter that he asked to be read to the meeting in lieu of attending — the letter was in response to a petition of Le Vicomte residents, put together by Sebag and residents, calling for a halt in the tabling of the master plan.

“I was disappointed that I was not allowed to attend, but I will maintain positive relations and open communications with Councillor Sebag, who I consider a friend, as with all my councillors,” Brownstein told The Suburban after the meeting’s conclusion. “We all want what’s best for the city.”

Tensions in Côte St. Luc over the master plan for the future of the city — including the potential redevelopment of its three malls — manifested themselves Nov. 20 when at a special meeting, council voted 6-2 for draft bylaws related to the plan. Sebag and District 2 councillor Mike Cohen voted against most of the draft bylaws, saying the more than two-year-old master plan process is flawed in terms of consultation and timings of meetings. Tense debates took place.

There will be a 7 p.m. Dec. 11 area meeting at Décarie Square, with doors open at 6:30 p.m., which will include attendance by the mayor, councillors and a presentation by city staff. During the Nov. 26 meeting, questions were raised about potential traffic issues, what the redevelopment of Décarie Square could entail and many other issues.

Councillor Dida Berku held her own master plan district meeting Nov. 5, to which she invited Brownstein and Councillor Steven Erdelyi, as well as CSL Shopping Centre representatives.

Asked about the non-invite of the Mayor, Sebag told The Suburban that the Nov. 26 meeting “was organized by the Vicomte, they sent the invitation…there was no reach out to other councillors because we, and I, wanted to present the facts as [related to the master plan].

“There is a clear exercise where they pitch the master plan…. This wasn’t a pitch. This was me presenting the facts and I do believe the way I presented it was different than the way [associate city manager Tanya Abramovitch] or Dida Berku would have done it, because they are pushing this master plan in a way that they might not be sensitive enough to the way the [area] residents feel.”

Asked for a response, Berku told The Suburban, “it’s not about who was invited or not invited, it’s about the traffic — there is a traffic problem and I am the champion of the city to solve those problems. We are working on it. There’s more things that will happen, and it’s not just in reaction to the master plan, it’s been the city’s mission for the past four years. We have enough briefs and presentations to wallpaper a room, and on Dec. 11, we’ll bring them all so everyone can see what we’re doing and continue to do to open up Vézina and Cavendish.”

CSL Mayor not invited to master plan meeting Read More »

Tordjman running for CSL Mayor in 2025

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Former CSL councillor David Tordjman announced this week that he will be running for the city’s mayoralty in the November 2025 election.

Tordjman also ran with a team of candidates in the 2021 municipal election against incumbent Mitchell Brownstein, who was re-elected. One member of Tordjman’s team, Lior Azerad, was elected.

In a statement, Tordjman stated that his decision to run again is “driven by a deep commitment to the city’s future and concern about the current direction of the Master Plan, [I’m] stepping forward at this time to help ensure that voices of all residents are heard and respected.

“The Master Plan is a vital blueprint for the growth and development of our city. In its current form, it is a draft that needs consideration. We need to take into account the need for more housing, greater density in certain parts of the city while ensuring that we maintain safety and security as well as manage significant traffic issues. I firmly believe it is an essential tool to enhance the quality of life for everyone in CSL. It’s time to move forward responsibly and inclusively, ensuring that every resident feels engaged in shaping the path ahead.”

Tordjman added that “as a candidate and a professional Civil Engineer, I bring a wealth of municipal experience, having served as the city’s Director of Engineering, Urban Planning and Public Works from 2005 to 2010 and having previously held office as a city councillor from 2017 to 2021.

“[I am] committed to advancing the Master Plan in a way that reflects the city’s collective interests and priorities. We need to bring everyone to the table and create meaningful progress for CSL. Our community deserves a leader who can navigate complex challenges and find common ground. This is about building a future that works for all of us, and I have the experience and know-how to guide us through this.” n

Tordjman running for CSL Mayor in 2025 Read More »

St. Laurent MNA wants ban on injection sites near schools

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

St. Laurent Liberal MNA Marwah Rizqy has introduced Bill 892, to ban supervised injection sites for drug addicts near elementary and high schools and daycare centres. The law would ban such facilities within 150 metres of such educational institutions in Montreal, and within 250 metres of the institutions elsewhere in the province.

“The bill states that the government may, by regulation, determine the services that constitute supervised consumption services and provide other standards relating to the location of supervised consumption services,” she told the National Assembly. “The bill gives organizations that offer supervised consumption services at the time of its assent a period of two years from the date of its assent to comply with the prohibition it introduces.”

Rizqy posted on X that “many of you have written to us to ask for legislation to ensure that supervised drug consumption centres are not set up near schools and daycares. I stood up in the House to challenge the Legault government on this issue a year ago. Last September, Premier Legault finally admitted that we cannot ask children to live with intoxicated people. The parliamentary session is coming to an end, and the Liberal Party of Quebec is offering this bill to the government. You can even erase my name, the important thing is to legislate promptly. For a Quebec that has the good and safety of its children at heart.”

The QLP posted that “the ball is now in the CAQ’s camp.”

Lionel Carmant, the Social Services Minister, says he plans to introduce a similar bill next spring. “We’re already working on it with the legal affairs department,” he told reporters. “I’ve already said that, yes, we want to reduce distances, but we also want to facilitate access to care for drug addicts. We will study what [Rizqy] has presented to us, but we want something a little broader.” n

St. Laurent MNA wants ban on injection sites near schools Read More »

MoWest acts after two students hit by cars

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Montreal West is promising action after two teens were hit by cars on Westminster while crossing the street during morning and afternoon rush hours in a nine-day period. Councillor Lauren Small-Pennefather, who presided over the recent council meeting, addressed a nearly full house of concerned residents.

NDG resident Charlie Shein, 14, had been hit on his side at the crosswalk at Westminster and Ainslie on Oct. 28, in the morning on his way to Royal West Academy. That same week, Percival resident Nick Giannias warned council that the view of pedestrians is blocked when there is traffic on Westminster heading north, creating a danger. Mayor Beny Masella said at the time that the area is being studied, because of two accidents at the rail crossing, including a 70-year-old man who died days after being struck by a train.

Then, on Nov. 6, CSL resident Khayyam Cesar-Mohammed, 17, was crossing at the Westminster and Broughton crosswalk when a motorist ran over his foot at around 5 p.m. The meeting heard that first responders had a hard time getting to the scene because of traffic.

“I started crossing, the first car in the closest lane to the sidewalk stopped,” he told The Suburban. “I clicked the button that signals a pedestrian is crossing, and the car that was in the middle lane didn’t seem to stop. My foot got run over — I was in a bit of shock. A lot of people came, someone brought some ice. For the next couple of days, I had lots of difficulty walking. I’m better now.”

The student added that something has to be done to prevent more incidents.

“What’s important is this doesn’t happen to somebody else. There was no ticketing, no fine. There needs to be consequences. Also, the pedestrian needs to be visible, to be noticed. If I was one step ahead, I could have been completely taken out. It could have been much worse. A solution has to be found for everybody.”

Small-Pennefather said Westminster will have to be reconfigured and that accident and potential accident factors include sun glare, driver frustration because of heavy traffic and driver misbehaviour — she said one driver claimed to her that stopping at crosswalks in Quebec when people are crossing is an option. Small-Pennefather added that other needed actions include signage “and continuing to sensitize people in the area.

At the council meeting, in relation to changes in the Westminster area, there was a document with a proposed bylaw for a new left turn ban, from Sherbrooke heading west onto Westminster heading south. n

MoWest acts after two students hit by cars Read More »

CSL master plan process flawed say two councillors

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Intense debates ensued during a three-and-a-half hour special Côte St. Luc council meeting to pass draft bylaws regarding Côte St. Luc’s master plan for the future of the city, including the potential redevelopment of the city’s three malls.

A detailed explanation of the bylaws was given at the meeting, and details of the master plan, which Mayor Mitchell Brownstein says is currently a vision with no specific redevelopment proposals presented to the city yet, can be seen at cotesaintluc.org/engage. A public consultation will be taking place 7 p.m. Jan. 13 at a location yet to be determined. Questions included concerns about the potential redevelopment of Décarie Square, an area with a great deal of traffic already.

Councillor Oren Sebag, who represents the area that includes Décarie Square, voted against some of the bylaws. “As much as I believe in a strong vision for the city, I don’t think we’re ready to move forward with this plan,” he said. “We needed to have targeted district meetings before getting to tonight’s meeting. The plan has faced delay after delay. And instead of giving us time to properly review it or consult residents in a meaningful way, we’re rushing to the finish line.” Sebag also objected to the date of the consultation, saying many CSLers will be out of town.

Rebuttals included the fact some 10 percent of the CSL population was consulted in the last two years the master plan process has taken place.

Councillor Mike Cohen said two years ago was the last time the malls presented an idea of how they want to redevelop, and that he only received a briefing more than two weeks before the Nov. 20 meeting. “They’ve been the invisible malls since then,” he added. “My concern is the fact that we’re putting forward our ‘vision’ for the three malls, including Quartier Cavendish, and that vision will likely be 6-2 in favour of everything. The mall will have license to do whatever it wants, based on the parameters being put together in this plan. The plan is magnificent in terms of everything it entails, but I’m very big on consultation….I would have liked to consult on our vision for the mall going back to last summer.” He also objected to the Jan. 13 public consultation date, because of the snowbirds.

Councillor Lior Azerad said the plan isn’t being passed in its final form yet. “Yes, there were things that were rushed, but 1,600 pages weren’t rushed. There’s always little changes.” He added that the city needs revenue — earlier in the meeting, it was pointed out that the valuation of the malls has gone down, while the valuation of homes has shot up. As well, tens of millions of dollars are needed to fix the city’s infrastructure.

Near the end of the meeting, the debate got more intense between Councillor Dida Berku and Sebag. “From day one, Councillor Sebag, you’ve been telling us and me, in particular, ‘I’m voting no,’” Berku said. “You’ve been voting against this from the beginning! It’s not ‘we didn’t have consultations or ‘it’s being rushed.’ From Day 1, ‘I’m voting no!”

Sebag said he took offence to the comments. “I never said ‘from Day 1.’ I listened, I sat at every meeting. I contributed to this, and I told you specifically, in June, that there were delays after delays. I don’t want to get into personal issues here, because then we’ll stay all night. I haven’t been voting no for the sake of voting no. For you to say, in front of everybody here publicly, that I told you I’m voting No, you very well know what was happening, I told you the delays would cause issues.”

Sebag demanded an apology, and Berku retracted her comment. The Suburban then asked Berku if her retraction meant her comments were not true — she replied that she stands by them, and had retracted because Sebag was offended. n

CSL master plan process flawed say two councillors Read More »

French youth don’t care about language in stores: OQLF

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The use of French to greet consumers and provide services has declined, especially in the Montreal and Gatineau areas of the province, but not that many are exceptionally concerned about that, says a new Office Québécois de la Langue Francaise report.

The less negative feelings were especially prevalent amongst those between 18 and 34 years old.

The study was conducted in late 2023 with some 3,800 people responding.

Language Minister Jean-François Roberge reacted by urging Quebecers “to demand to be served in French in Quebec businesses, and to complain to the OQLF when this is not the case.”

In this reporter’s shopping experience, I am always greeted with a “Bonjour” or a “Bonjour-Hi” in local stores, and primarily “Bonjour” outside Montreal, never just a “Hi”.

The study, ‘Language of welcome and language of service in Quebec businesses in 2023’ says that “across Quebec, the lack of reaction among clients welcomed and served in a language other than French tends to increase.

“In fact, approximately one in three people feel indifference when they are not greeted in French (29%) or served in French (33%). A significant portion of the clientele has no preference regarding the language of welcome and the language of service (14% and 11% respectively). In addition, among all clients, including French-speaking clients, many rarely or never ask for service in French when it is not first offered in that language (56% of clients across Quebec and 40% of French-speaking clients).”

In the Montreal area specifically, from 2010 to 2023, “the proportion of customers experiencing negative feelings when they are greeted or served in a language other than French is decreasing,” with more than 52 percent saying they would not boycott the establishment, 11.5 saying they would not return, and the rest saying they would return if they needed the store’s product.

“Although the results show an upward trend in the proportion of people who have been greeted or served in a language other than French, fewer and fewer Montreal consumers experience negative feelings if they experience this situation (-26 percentage points for service and -15 points for greeting).”

As a result of these findings, the study’s authors wonder “is it now standard practice to be greeted and served in a language other than French, resulting in a feeling of indifference among some customers and a reduction in their negative feelings when they are not greeted or served in French? Is this experience, once less frequent and perceived more negatively, tending to become more commonplace?” n

French youth don’t care about language in stores: OQLF Read More »

Domestic terrorists take over Concordia building

By Joel Goldenberg and Beryl Wajsman, Editor
The Suburban

Anti-Israel protests at Concordia University last Thursday in which there were words and actions reminiscent of the Nazis has sparked an outcry in Montreal, across Canada and around the world. The protests took place as part of a two-day strike by hundreds of students from Concordia and McGill Universities, and Dawson College. Dawson and Concordia’s Hall Building closed for the day citing safety concerns.

At one point, the entire Hall Building at Concordia had been broken into and occupied by a mob and video clips showed the protesters breaking down doors, breaking lights and glass and spraying graffiti on walls and lockers. Concordia security tried to stop the protesters, but they flooded the main floor of the Hall building, where they overturned garbage cans and flooded in. Police are looking into an alleged assault on a security guard and alleged acts of mischief.

One protester, Mai Abdulhadi, a franchisee owner/operator of the Second Cup location at the Jewish General Hospital, was videoed saying “the final solution is coming your way,” to pro-Israel counter protesters, and giving the Nazi salute with several others. After the evidence of her actions came to light, Second Cup terminated her franchisee agreement. Second Cup stated that it “has zero tolerance for hate speech. In coordination with the hospital, we shut down the franchisee’s café and are terminating their franchise agreement. This franchisee’s actions are not only a breach of our franchise agreement, they also violate the values of inclusion and community we stand for at Second Cup.”

Quebec Higher Education Minister Pascale Déry stated, “..it is unacceptable that institutions feel forced to close their doors. Students should be able to access their classes safely; it is their right. Now, what we are asking is for the demonstrations to take place calmly and without excesses. Quebecers do not want us to import the conflict here.”

Federation CJA and CIJA issued a joint statement saying they are “horrified by the violence that unfolded today across university campuses. To be clear, today was not a ‘strike’, but an aggressive and unacceptable campaign of intimidation. While we recognize university administrators sought to protect students today, more must be done to ensure the shameful episode never reoccurs.

“Hate, intimidation and harassment of a targeted student population gone unchecked for 14 months resulted in today’s unacceptable so-called ‘strike’. We also reiterate our disappointment that Dawson College chose to preemptively cave into the mob and close its doors. We are in contact with administrators, law enforcement, and other security personnel and will use every tool at our disposal to ensure student safety. Jewish students, like all others, have the right to learn in a safe and secure academic environment and today they were not able to do so.”

B’nai Brith Canada stated, “the growing trend of student strikes raise serious concerns not just about safety at our schools and campuses, but also the broader impact on students trying to focus on their studies. The rise of ideological conformity amongst students has weaponized principles like diversity and inclusion to foster a mob mentality and silence dissent. This trend jeopardizes both community safety and the integrity of educational institutions.”

Deborah Lyons, Canada’s Special Envoy on Preserving Holocaust Remembrance and Combatting Antisemitism, said, “…Nazi-style salutes. Shouts of ‘stupid Zionist btch’ and ‘the final solution is coming your way’, attempts to break down doors. This is not peaceful. This is not free expression. The tools to deal with incitement and harassment exist — we expect administrations and municipalities to use them.”

Michal Cotler-Wunsh, Israel’s Special Envoy for Combatting Antisemitism, posted, “THIS is the product of YEARS of silence, false moral equivalence, impunity…for systematic weaponization of human rights to intimidate, bully, harass ANY voices identified with Israel, mainstreaming a modern, lethal strain of antisemitism, which also enables the targeting of a former Minister of Justice and human rights warrior in Montreal (her father Irwin Cotler), even as the Canadian PM aligns with the Orwellian International Criminal Court citing ‘the Canadian way’.”

U.S. pro-Israel activist Eyal Yakoby, who has appeared on American cable networks, posted, “..these are domestic terrorists. There is no other way to describe them.” n

Domestic terrorists take over Concordia building Read More »

CSL honours its volunteers

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The City of Côte St. Luc recently honoured its many volunteers at their annual recognition evening, held at the Quartier Cavendish Cineplex theatre.

Numerous awards were given out — among them:

• The Gerry Weinstein Ambassador of the Year award, “in recognition as the citizen best portraying charitable qualities and serving the community at large,” went to Marc Ezerzer.

“Marc plays and sponsors a team in the CSL Executive Softball League and he also sponsors the annual CSL Golf Classic,” Councillor Mike Cohen said. “He is a prominent real estate agent who lends his high profile to the good and welfare of CSL sports programs. I was proud to have nominated Marc.”

• Aquatics Volunteer of the Year Award: Michèle Castonguay for her great dedication to the City of Cote Saint-Luc and its competitive swimming program,” Cohen added

• The Community Special Events Award, presented to volunteers for their “exceptional contribution to the community special events programs,” went to Bryan Wolofsky for his involvement with the PeeWee National Outdoor Hockey Tournament; and CSL Men’s Club Chairmen of Programming Bernie Green, for his work organizing trips, the Hot Stove League and booking speakers.

• The Eco Award, “in recognition of leadership in the promotion of environmental advocacy and action within the community,” went to Kirwan Garden Coordinator Boyd Hamilton.

• The Edward J. Kirwan Award, “awarded annually to outstanding volunteers in the CSL programs for exceptional contribution,” went to Adriana Rico of the Figure Skating Club.

• The EMS (Emergency Medical Services) awards went to Scott Hunt for excellence in operations, Alizée Znaty for excellence in training and Kassandra Pinsonneault for Rookie of the Year.

•The Hazel Lipes Award, awarded “to the outstanding volunteer for exceptional contribution to the community service program,” went to Diane Liebling, chair of CSL’s Cats Committee.

“She has carried on these duties for the past six years, working virtually 24/7 physically trapping cats, giving up her family garage to feed strays, finding homes and foster homes for them, establishing a network of feeders of outdoor cats, organizing meetings and making repeated visits to the CSL Hospital for Animals,” Cohen said. “Quite simply, the committee would not function without her. I was proud to have nominated Diane.”

More details about the awards and recipients can be seen at Cohen’s website, mikecohen.ca

CSL honours its volunteers Read More »

SPVM investigating yet another St. Laurent fire

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The SPVM is investigating one of many suspected arson attacks in St. Laurent, this one at a business at Montée de Liesse near Côte de Liesse, in the western sector of the borough.

The SPVM and Montreal fire department responded to a 911 call 5:40 a.m. Saturday May 20.

Police say the window of the business was broken, but no incendiary devices were found. The fire, which caused minor damage, was quickly brought under control. There were no injuries and no arrests as of May 20.

The SPVM is checking surveillance footage as part of their ongoing investigation.

Many other suspected arsons have taken place in recent months at businesses in St. Laurent, including one May 9 at McCaffrey; six cars were destroyed by fire around 11:25 p.m. April 26 at Lebeau near the Metropolitan Expressway, in the southeastern section of the borough; the Bab Sharqi restaurant was targeted several times, another fire took place in mid-March at Bois Franc and Miniac, and two others took place Feb. 16 and March 7 at businesses near Montée de Liesse.

SPVM investigating yet another St. Laurent fire Read More »

Heroes remembered, Mayor honoured at Hampstead Remembrance Day

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

The Hampstead Remembrance Day ceremony, held at the Cenotaph at Hampstead Park, was attended by many dignitaries with a special participation by a detachment of Grenadier Guards and a moving exhibit including an original Grenadiers Vimy Ridge Memorial. The dignitaries included Mayor Jeremy Levi and council members, Israeli Consul-General Paul Hirschson, who laid a wreath representing those killed in the Holocaust; Senator Leo Housakos, Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather, Conservative Mount Royal candidate and lawyer Neil Oberman; Alex Copeman, D’Arcy McGee MNA Elisabeth Prass’ political attaché; Hampstead Director General Joe Nunez and other town employees; Rabbi Moishe New of the Montreal Torah Centre, and students from Solomon Schechter Academy, Hampstead Elementary School, Bialik High School and John Grant High School.

Also in attendance was the family of Montrealer and World War II Sgt. Samuel Moses “Moe” Hurwitz, the most decorated Canadian Jewish soldier in World War II who fought bravely as part of the Canadian Grenadier Guards. He died in 1944 of wounds suffered in combat.

“Sgt. Moe Hurwitz’s life and service exemplified the very essence of what it means to be a guardian of freedom and a beacon of hope to his comrades and fellow citizens,” Mayor Levi said. “His story is a testament to the enduring values of inclusivity, unity and the unshakable commitment to upholding the principles that bind us.”

Senator Housakos also paid tribute to Hurwitz, saying he turned down a tryout with the Boston Bruins and instead enlisted to fight in the war.

“He said ‘there’s no time to play hockey when millions of my brothers are getting killed in Europe.’ It was said at the time of his passing, ‘lost to the regiment was its most purposeful and persistent soldier, whose deeds of gallant leadership were an inspiration to those who succeeded him in the battles that were to follow.’ May Moe’s memory be a blessing and inspiration to all of us gathered here today and may it serve as a critical reminder of our collective responsibility to preserve the peace and freedoms Moe and every other soldier fought so hard to achieve.”

Wreaths were also laid representing Canada, Quebec, municipalities, veterans, Hurwitz; the Canadian Grenadier Guards, the Royal Montreal Regiment and the Royal Canadian Legion — members of each were on hand as part of the ceremony; and the SPVM and the SIM — the Montreal Fire Department.

Hampstead Mayor Jeremy Levi was presented with the King Charles III Coronation Medal by Conservative Senator Leo Housakos, following the ceremony. Honourees are recognized for outstanding achievement in public service and volunteerism. Levi is known for being very active and outspoken, in public and on social media, in support of Israel and against the anti-Israel and antisemitic protests that have taken place in Montreal since the Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist attack.

The medal presentation took place in the Adessky Community Centre, where the town also presented an elaborate exhibition of war artifacts from the Canadian Grenadier Guards, the Royal Montreal Regiment and individual collections — including an original 1917 Canadian Grenadier Guards Vimy Ridge memorial.

Senator Housakos said during the medal presentation, “Mayor, I want to thank you for being a strong voice for what is right in our country and our society and your community.

“I say to everybody, as a Senator, when I go to coast to coast to coast in this country, that the best Mayor in Canada is Mayor Levi, I mean it from the bottom of my heart. He never shies away from doing the right thing, from saying the right thing. The medal goes to people for significant contributions to community and country, and Mayor Levi, you have done that in spades. Hampstead is lucky to have you.”

Levi thanked Housakos, and humbly responded that the medal “belongs to the entire community. I’m just a voice for the community.”

The Mayor then presented Housakos with a Freedom of the City commemorative coin, one side representing Hampstead and the other side representing the Canadian Grenadier Guards. n

Heroes remembered, Mayor honoured at Hampstead Remembrance Day Read More »

Gurmans being honoured at Feast of the Nations

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Prominent Montreal community leaders and philanthropists Joanne and Jon Gurman are being honoured at the annual Feast of the Nations Gala, being held Thursday Nov. 21 at Congregation Shaar Hashomayim in Westmount. Internationally renowned singer Gad Elbaz will be performing at the event, held by the Chabad Chaya Mushka Seminary Ben Weider Educational Centre. Cocktails will be at 5 p.m., followed by the dinner and concert.

The event will raise funds for the Seminary’s Operation Miriam, a five-year mission which enables 25 young women between the ages of 17 and 20 from Ukraine and Israel to study at the Seminary and live at the Frieda Dym Residence Hall, as well as help underprivileged students.

The Gurmans will be presented with the prestigious Chai Lifetime Achievement Award for “their unwavering humanitarian support and dedication to helping those in need beyond our immediate community,” say event organizers. “[Their support] creates a ripple effect that reaches Israel and communities around the world. Joanne and Jon are truly exemplary figures, inspiring others with their actions.”

The organizers added that the Gurmans’ “generous hearts and philanthropy have left a lasting impact on the growth of Montreal schools, synagogue, healthcare centres, eldercare facilities, hospitals and more. They embody passion for the Jewish people, resilience and commitment to NEVER AGAIN and ‘Am Yisrael Chai.’”

The Gurmans were introduced to Chabad when the Montreal Torah Centre was at Décarie Square, and they were taken with Chabad’s concepts and values.

“With Chabad, anywhere in the world, you have a home — if anyone is going to preserve the Jewish culture and our connection to Israel, it’s the Lubavitch,” says Jon Gurman. “I’ve been to the Chabad Lubavitch World Headquarters and I’ve met rabbis from all around the world. When we help them, we are helping all Jews.” The couple also spearheaded the construction of the Montreal Torah Centre’s current building on Cleve Road in Hampstead, which has a bustling congregation, a daycare and is known as a hub of community activity.

“Our whole family understands and appreciates the good that Chabad does in the world,” Joanne Gurman says. “When our daughter was studying at the University of Leeds in England, she had Chabad. Wherever you go, there is always a home for you with Chabad.”

Jon Gurman also helped The Seminary with their auction and Scotch & Cigar event, and the couple’s involvement increased with the launch of Operation Miriam. The Gurmans sponsored a young girl from Ukraine to come study in Montreal.

“The Seminary is providing both education and a home to young girls from both Ukraine and Israel,” says Joanne. “It’s so important that we support them and these girls. The Chabad Seminary of Canada and the Chaya Mushka Seminary prioritizes not just any education, but the education of displaced young women whose education has been interrupted. When the war broke out in Ukraine, they stepped up when few would and since the Oct. 7 [Hamas terrorist attack], they have only increased their efforts to help girls in both Ukraine and Israel. They’ve not only changed lives, but saved lives.”

The couple also considers Israel to be “the most important cause in our lives.”

“Our passion is for Israel, the Israeli people and the brave men and women who defend Israel and in turn, the Jewish people,” says Jon.

In general, “Rabbi Abraham Cohen has done incredible work at the Chabad Seminary of Canada and we are proud to support him and his entire team of educators year after year,” he added. “We are honoured to have been chosen as the recipients of the Chai Lifetime Achievement Award.”

Rabbi Cohen stated, “More than one year since the terrorist attack of Oct. 7, our gala will celebrate our unbreakable spirit. The mission of our Seminary has not changed; with the war ongoing, young women need our help more than ever and we will continue to be there for them.”

For more information about the event, go to seminarygala.com or call 514-543-5446. 

Gurmans being honoured at Feast of the Nations Read More »

“Where is the outrage?”

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Iris Weinstein Haggai, the daughter of Canadian Judi Weinstein Haggai and Gadi Haggai who were killed by the terrorist group Hamas October 7 and whose bodies are still being held in Gaza, spoke to the Montreal community last week.

Haggai spoke on several occasions, including at the Sylvan Adams YM-YWHA following the weekly Bring Them Home Montreal walk for hostages. She was joined at the Y by former Montreal Mayor Denis Coderre, known for being a strong supporter of the Jewish community and Israel, and Iranian human rights activist Tara Dachek.

Haggai has called on Canada to do everything it can to ensure the return of her mother’s body. Her parents’ fate was not known for 83 days.

“As a Canadian, as Judi Weinstein’s daughter, the Canada I know would not stand by as such horrors are inflicted on the innocent. This country, the one my mother raised me to love, would rally and demand that every hostage be freed, that those who commit atrocities against our own are held accountable. This is about who we are as a nation, about standing for justice, human rights and for those who cannot stand for themselves.”

Haggai also asked, “where is the outrage for innocent people held in inhumane conditions, in underground torture tunnels funded by Canadian tax dollars?

“Rape, killing, kidnapping and torturing innocent civilians is not resistance! Holding bodies of deceased hostages is a violation of every humanitarian law and a pure desecration of religious values!”

Coderre, who proclaimed “am Yisrael chai!,” pointed out that he fulfilled a 2017 promise to go on the March of the Living, which includes a tour of the Auschwitz concentration camp.

“I said ‘never again’. I decided to walk with you today because I believe we need to bring them home! What I’m scared of right now is the rise of fascism and antisemitism. It’s not just about the hostages, it’s about making sure that we have our country again. I don’t like to see what I’m seeing right now!”

Dachek, of the Iranian Justice Collective, said “we gather, not just as individuals, but as a united front showing the world that the Iranian and Jewish communities share a strong bond, a commitment to fighting against terrorism and advocating for the freedom of hostages.

“I want to deliver a message to you – the horrors and brutality we witnessed on Oct. 7 was unforgettable and unforgivable. The victims are not just statistics, they are lives lost and families shattered! The hostages are not just names we call out! Each one of them, young or old, is a person who is suffering at this very moment! Each one has a family that has been in agony for over a year! We Iranians understand your pain, because the people who financed and supported Oct. 7 are the same people who have oppressed us for decades!” n

“Where is the outrage?” Read More »

Albanese talks cancelled after Oberman serves McGill

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

McGill student groups, represented by Spiegel Sohmer senior partner Neil Oberman, served McGill University and UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese with a demand for security and safety on campus, seeking to bar Albanese from speaking at the university’s Moot Court Nov. 4. The university was given a deadline of 2 p.m. Nov. 1 to reply or face possible further legal action.

“Our clients plan to hold McGill University liable for the damages they suffer due to the failure to ensure a safe and secure environment,” the demand letter says.

The McGill talk was cancelled at the Moot Court, and instead took place at the student union building, which was not served and over which McGill has no authority. Albanese also ended up cancelling at another Montreal event Nov. 2 after the letters were served. Oberman referred to that event as a “Hate Conference” for including virulent anti-Israel and antisemitic speakers, such as Charlotte Kates of Samidoun, recently designated by Canada as a terrorist entity. Oberman refers to the McGill conference as the “Hate Lecture.”

Oberman, representing 21 students, Chabad McGill, Hillel McGill, the Jewish Law Students Association of McGill (“JLSA”), Israel on Campus McGill and other organizations, demanded that McGill “stop Ms. Albanese from promoting hatred on campus” and “restrict Ms. Albanese from using McGill premises to spread hate speech.” The demand also calls on Albanese herself to “refrain from coming to the university campus to spread any offensive, hateful, or discriminatory language or messages.”

McGill is accused in the letter of failing “to act in accordance with the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, the Civil Code of Quebec and the Consumer Protection Act.”

Oberman’s demand letter conveys to McGill President Saini that, “as the custodian of the university, it is your obligation to ensure that all students are always, while on campus or participating in university activities, safe, secure, and protected regardless of their race, religion, and/or ethnicity. These obligations extend to our clients’ civil rights, particularly those guaranteeing them safety and the ability to be free from discrimination.”

Oberman pointed out that promoters of the McGill conference included Independent Jewish Voices Canada Inc., “an organization which is currently the subject of contempt of Court proceedings and was the subject of a provisional interlocutory injunction in another Court matter as recently as October 2nd, 2024, for its illicit campus activity at Concordia.

“They also include ‘LawStudents4Palestine’, an unincorporated, unregistered and purposefully anonymous entity which is not a registered student club with the LSA. These groups remain anonymous to evade accountability for spreading hatred and discrimination, including at times committing unlawful acts of physical aggression and property damage.”

“It is unacceptable that McGill University allows such activities on its campus,” Oberman’s demand letter says.

Native Montrealer Hillel Neuer of the organization UN Watch, speaking at Hampstead Park Sunday before the weekly Bring Them Home Montreal walk for hostages, slammed Albanese for saying the world “has to understand the context” of the Oct. 7 attack from the Palestinian perspective, and for accusing Israel of aggression on that day.

“Yet, despite this, she was invited to Montreal. I’m a proud graduate of McGill law school, where she was invited to speak. McGill [said] they’re not involved, it’s the students. Would McGill law school give its lecture hall to students hosting a speaker who was internationally condemned for racism against Black or Indigenous people? I don’t think so. If you’re going to host them, at least speak out.” n

Albanese talks cancelled after Oberman serves McGill Read More »

Ortona, team sweep EMSB election

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Joe Ortona was re-elected chairman of the English Montreal School Board by a wide margin and his entire team was elected, defeating challenger Katherine Korakakis and her team. The voter turnout was 22 percent and observers feel it would have been higher had registration rules not been changed in mid-campaign by the returning officer and Elections Quebec.

The election was contested vigorously, with some barbs at times as seen on social media. Volunteers called potential voters as late as this past Saturday night.

“Thank you to everyone who came out to vote today,” Ortona said Sunday night. “Your support means everything to us, and we’re proud to continue advocating for the needs of our English-speaking community. The journey to protect our schools never stops, and we’re honoured to have your trust. Here’s to a brighter future for the EMSB, our students and our community. Together, we’ll keep building something great.”

Ortona touted the board’s success rate of 95.9 percent graduation, and talked about the political battles the board is waging against the Quebec government over Bill 96, Bill 21, and Bill 40 – the contentious bid by the government to abolish school boards, as they did for the French sector (which some have blamed for the Ecole Bedford fiasco).

Ortona says the results send a strong message to the CAQ in terms of the community being in control of its own schools.

The results were:• For chair:Joe Ortona, Team Joe Ortona 13,289

Katherine Korakakis, Team Katherine Korakakis 4,674

• Ward 1 (Ahuntsic-Cartierville–Montréal-Nord)

Susan Perera , Team Joe Ortona 916

Franco Mazzariello, Team Katherine Korakakis 425

• Ward 2 (Côte-des-Neiges–Notre-Dame-de-Grâce)

Chelsea Craig, Team Joe Ortona 1,039

Howie Silbiger, Team Katherine Korakakis 631

• Ward 3 (Côte-Saint-Luc. Montreal West, Hampstead)

Paola Samuel, Team Joe Ortona 1,607

Samara Perez, Team Katherine Korakakis 1,110

• Ward 4 (Mercier–Hochelaga-Maisonneuve–Rosemont–La Petite-Patrie–Plateau-Mont-Royal–Anjou–Montreal-Est)

Maria Corsi, Team Joe Ortona 1,121

Viktoriya Grosko, Team Katherine Korakakis 333

• Ward 5 (Notre-Dame-de-Grâce)

Sharon Nelson, Team Joe Ortona 1,132

Joseph Lalla, Team Katherine Korakakis 853

• Ward 6 (Rivière-des-Prairies–Pointe-aux-Trembles)

Pietro Mercuri, Team Joe Ortona 2,248

Tony Aversano, Team Katherine Korakakis 340

• Ward 7 (Saint-Laurent)

James Kromida, Team Joe Ortona 974

Vicky Pololos, Team Katherine Korakakis 471

• Ward 8 (Saint-Léonard)

Mario Pietrangelo, Team Joe Ortona 1,681

Antonio Zaruso, Team Katherine Korakakis 521

• Ward 9 (Villeray–Saint-Michel–Parc-Extension–Mont-Royal–Outremont

Paula Kilian, Team Joe Ortona 938

Joanne Charron, Team Katherine Korakakis 310

• Ward 10 (Westmount–Sud-Ouest–Ville-Marie)

Julien Feldman, Team Joe Ortona 1,243

Shalani Bel, Team Katherine Korakakis 752 n

Ortona, team sweep EMSB election Read More »

Public storm over Montreal anti-racism report that omits antisemitism

By Joel Goldenberg and Dan Laxer
The Suburban

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs is condemning a report on accelerating changes for a Montreal free of racism and discrimination from 2023 to 2025, saying it omits any mention of antisemitism. Numerous anti-Israel and antisemitic incidents have taken place in Montreal — including antisemitic slurs, Jewish schools being fired upon and Molotov cocktails thrown into Jewish community centres — since the Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel.

The report on racism and discrimination was presented to the city last week by Bochra Manaï, Montreal’s Commissioner for the Fight against Racism and Systemic Discrimination. Manaï has been harshly criticized for attending 2023 anti-Israel rallies where antisemitic chants were heard.

A CIJA statement regarding the new anti-racism document says that “we are outraged—though unfortunately not surprised—to see that she did not even mention the Jewish community or antisemitism.

“This report represents a glaring erasure of one of Montreal’s ethnic minorities, by the City of Montreal itself, even though the Jewish community is one of the most frequently targeted by hate crimes and incidents in the city. This omission is concerning, particularly coming from an office responsible for addressing racism and discrimination, and it adds to some troubling stances the Commissioner has taken in the past.”

CIJA is calling on Mayor Valérie Plante to “ensure that the Office of the Commissioner for the Fight against Racism and Systemic Discrimination fulfills its mandate without ignoring one of the groups currently most targeted by hate. She must reconsider her decision in appointing a divisive Commissioner to a role that should never have been contentious.”

In seeking an answer directly from Manaï as to why antisemitism was left out of a report on racism, The Suburban discovered that the Mayor’s office had put all responsibility for responses on the report on the shoulders of CDN/NDG Mayor Gracia Kasoki Katahwa and City Director-General Benoit Dagenais. Katahwa is also the executive committee member responsible for the fight against racism.

Indeed even during the council meeting when the report was debated, and questions on the exclusion of antisemitism were asked, Manaï remained silent even when questions were directed at her and all questions were handled by Katahwa and Dagenais with Manaï nodding her head in agreement.

The Suburban attempted to reach Manaï by phone, email and at City Hall. Surprisingly, we found the whole office of “Commissioner” is Manaï and one assistant.

Finally, editor Beryl Wajsman obtained Manaï‘s personal cell number. He texted her one question: “Chère Mme Manai, nous aimerions avoir une brève explication claire des raisons pour lesquelles l’antisémitisme n’a pas été mentionné dans votre rapport sur le racisme.” She responded that, “Le service des relations média vous achemine une réponse.” The Suburban is still waiting.

Katahwa emphasized twice that the omission does not mean that the Plante administration doesn’t care about antisemitism. “For me, it’s important to say to Montrealers of Jewish origin that this does not mean that antisemitism is acceptable. It is absolutely unacceptable. We have taken action and we will continue to take action to ensure the members of the Jewish community are safe and will always be safe in Montreal.” She added, as mayor of the CDN-NDG borough, that the police are “present and mobilized to be sure to protect the Jewish community.”

For his part, Dagenais acknowledged the omission, adding that “antisemitism is a scourge,” and that the fight against it must be made a priority, especially “in the context of the conflict in the Middle East.” He said the goal is to fight antisemitism, “and all other forms of discrimination and racism. If there are any groups who lack confidence in the commissioner, specifically the Jewish community, she will work to restore that trust.”

Katahwa characterized the Manaï report as a progress update in response to a 2022 report tabled by the Office de consultation publique de Montréal (OCPM) that was highly critical of the city’s record on racial profiling.

With files from Editor Beryl Wajsman n

Public storm over Montreal anti-racism report that omits antisemitism Read More »

Caldwell tenant alleges critical problems since 2023 flood

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Many problems remain at 5789 Caldwell Avenue ever since a flood that took place in the building in February 2023, resident Bonnie Lewis told The Suburban and Côte St. Luc council at its October meeting.

“As of today, there hasn’t been any heat, they turn the water off and on and the electricity,”she told council. “We’re living in such a mess. There’s also a major renovation in the entire building. I understand that under Quebec law, we cannot reside in there, they have to move everybody out and pay for our move and the rent for the year, or however long it’s going to take.”

She later told The Suburban that the owners are just “moving people around, and because I’m speaking out, they want me out of the building. They took me to see another of their buildings, and it’s worse than this one.”

Lewis says she has hired a lawyer.

“I want to be put in a place of my choice because I do not want to be with any of their management.”

Lewis also alleged to council that the building is being neglected and that items have been stolen from her.

Mayor Mitchell Brownstein said the city has received many e-mails from Lewis.

“I received all your e-mails, I answered them. I’ve had inspectors from our urban planning department go into the buildings at your request and anything that the city can do to assist, we do. We’re a municipality and there are things we can do on many of your issues and we have been very responsive. So continue to send me e-mail requests that you think we can help in, and we’ll do it.”

Lewis said she has been stuck in her elevator four times.

“That’s the municipal urban inspecting department, they would have to go in and check,” the Mayor said.

Lewis further told The Suburban that ever since she moved into the building in 2017, there has been “barely any heat.

“When the flood happened, that added to the situation….It’s horrible to live in this situation, I have mould. The city inspector came and did a mould report, and 20 months or so later, they haven’t eradicated it or cleaned it. I’m totally allergic, I get rashes and welts and I have all the symptoms of mould and asbestos.”

Leah Berger, CEO of Les Maisons Kehilla, told The Suburban that “in response to the housing crisis impacting many Montrealers, Caldwell Residences is investing $6.5 million in a renovation project and improvements that involve changing the doors and windows and installing heat pumps and air conditioning in all the apartments so that tenants can live comfortably throughout the year.

“During the year-long renovation process, and to mitigate the disruption caused by this project on tenants, we are relocating tenants to vacant apartments within the building. As work is carried out floor by floor, tenants are relocated when their floor is affected.”

Regarding Lewis, “she was additionally offered the option of moving to another Caldwell building or in an apartment in the building to be renovated before her own. All moving expenses are covered by Caldwell; in addition, tenants are not required to pay rent during the month of their temporary move and are receiving Internet access free of charge while they are temporarily displaced.

“I can confirm that the heat is on in Ms. Lewis’ apartment. We have a negotiated agreement in principle with this tenant that addresses her earlier concerns. As part of the agreement, Caldwell has until Nov. 1 to complete the necessary repairs and will fulfill its responsibilities. The agreement is confidential, so I am not able to disclose the details.

Berger said she did not receive any new requests from Lewis lately.

“In fact, on Oct. 17, 2024, prior to the Côte St. Luc council meeting, I contacted the tenant by phone and offered to meet with her, but she declined. The tenant is aware that the process for requesting repairs is to contact the building Superintendent. Rest assured, we are committed to providing a secure, quality and affordable living environment for all our tenants.” n

Caldwell tenant alleges critical problems since 2023 flood Read More »

What else $30 million can buy for the WI

By Joel Goldenberg

Environmentalists are enthused about the Plante administration’s decision to buy land in the West Island from Hypertec for $30 million, expanding the Sources Nature Park, but there were other ways those funds could have been spent.

One example is $15 million for the long-promised expansion of the Jacques Bizard corridor to relieve traffic in the West Island municipalities, especially the area of Highway 40 and St. Jean, including building a new main road from Shakespeare in Dollard des Ormeaux to Highway 40.

As well, $300,000 a year could be devoted to continuing the fluoridation of West Island water in Pointe Claire and Dorval. Montreal’s decision to halt this in 2025 was based on that figure. The decision is affecting 140,000 people in Pointe-Claire, Beaconsfield, Kirkland, Baie-D’Urfé, Dollard-des-Ormeaux and Dorval.

Also, Beaconsfield is suing Montreal for $15 million, alleging a breach in the 2008 agreement of expense sharing in the island-wide agglomeration that was set up by the provincial government, resulting in what is alleged to be an overcharging of taxes.

Finally, $3 million could be spent for new buses to improve mobility in the West Island. n

What else $30 million can buy for the WI Read More »

CSL declares a Filipino Heritage Month

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Côte St. Luc council passed a resolution at its October council meeting declaring June to be Filipino Heritage Month in the city.

On hand were numerous prominent members of the Montreal Filipino community, as well as Marvin Rotrand of United Against Hate Canada.

Councillor Mike Cohen, who read the resolution, pointed out that in 2018, the Canadian government adopted a motion recognizing the contributions of the Filipino community to Canada, and “the richness of the Filipino language and culture.” The federal resolution suggested local jurisdictions do the same.

The CSL resolution recognized the contributions of Filipino residents. Mayor Mitchell Brownstein pointed out that 2,000 members of the Filipino community live in Côte St. Luc, “and I hope it continues to grow, 2,000 is not enough!

“Keep on coming to our city, we enjoy your presence and we’re happy you participate in our activities.”

Al Abdon, a longtime Filipino community leader and chairman of the Filipino Heritage Society of Montreal, said he and United Against Hate collaborated on a project to promote Filipino Heritage Month, and to encourage the twinning of Canadian cities with Philippines municipalities. Abdon expressed gratitude for the city passing the resolution.

“This resolution will be extremely meaningful to the community. I would like to invite all the council members to attend our Global Zoom call planned for next June with United Against Hate Canada,” which has highlighted the historic friendship between the Jewish and Filipino communities, including taking in Jews fleeing the Holocaust.

Rotrand told The Suburban that last August, a Zoom meeting was held in which United Against Hate Canada and the Filipino Heritage Society invited the public to discuss next year’s 20th anniversary of the Montreal-Manila friendship agreement, which came about through Rotrand’s outreach as a Montreal councillor and involves twinning agreements.

“Out of that Zoom meeting came requests [from members of the delegation in CSL Oct. 21], why don’t we try to promote Filipino heritage right throughout Canada. We wrote to 60 Mayors and got an enormous response and a lot of interest. We held a call on Aug. 29 addressed by three MPs, members of four provincial legislatures, a dozen mayors and councillors, and school commissioners, and we are now getting dozens of cities across Canada adopting these types of motions. Côte St. Luc is first. It’s a national movement.” n

CSL declares a Filipino Heritage Month Read More »

Former St. Laurent school coach on trial for sexual assault

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Daniel Lacasse, one of three École St. Laurent basketball coaches accused of sexual assault against underage students, is on trial in a case that is expected to conclude this week. Lacasse, as well as fellow coaches Charles-Xavier Boislard and Robert Luu, were arrested in February 2022.

One of the students, who was 16 at the time, testified last week that Lacasse acted slowly and methodically, by insinuating himself into her life and that of her mother, and then committed the assaults on and off the school grounds.

The female student, who cannot be identified, said the alleged assaults took place as much as three times a week in such locations as Lacasse’s car and house, and in the school’s laundry and teacher’s locker room. She said assaults took place from 2010 to 2012.

The former student said the coach’s involvement in her life began with visits, accompanying her to doctors’ appointments, and providing money for food as the mother was struggling financially, working at three jobs. According to the testimony, the helpful actions distracted from the coach’s alleged insulting behaviour at school. The former student also said Lacasse had adult-oriented conversations with her, including what attracted him to a woman.

The student then alleged that the sexual assaults began with Lacasse touching her thighs and then escalated to full sex. She said he was known for sleeping with other female students.

As previously reported by The Suburban, a 2023 Ministry of Education report said the system failed students who complained of sexual assault, which was part of a harmful atmosphere at the school for some 20 years.

The report said complaints were made about inappropriate behaviour and words by coaches to the Marguerite-Bourgeoys Service Centre, the high school itself and the Quebec Basketball Federation, but they did not take action.

The report also pointed out that if complaints were made to the school, or were received by the Réseau du sport sportif du Québec through its “Je porte plainte” website, the entities did not share the information. As a result, many complaints could be made against a particular coach, but the matter would not be investigated. n

Former St. Laurent school coach on trial for sexual assault Read More »

Court rejects municipalities’ stay request against Bill 96

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Superior Court Judge Silvana Conte rejected a request by 23 municipalities for a stay of various aspects of Quebec’s language law Bill 96 until the challenge can be heard on the merits.

The judge ruled that a stay ahead of a full court hearing should only be granted in urgent circumstances and that no serious effects of the law had been proven. This appeared to concur with the position of the Quebec government, which said Bill 96 did not cause harm to the 23 plaintiffs.

The provisions the cities want declared invalid and inoperative are the prohibition for contracts to be written in a language other than French, “even if both parties agree,”; allowing OQLF inspectors to inspect and seize, at any time without notice, any documents, equipment and computers from any municipal body; that cities have to declare in resolutions that they want to maintain their bilingual status if the English mother tongue population is below 50 percent; that the language minister or another designated minister can withhold provincial government grants to a city if they don’t comply with any provision of the law; and that a city has to punish any employee who does not comply with Bill 96.”

Côte St. Luc Mayor Mitchell Brownstein told The Suburban “we are years away from the hearing on the merits and we requested a stay of the law until then. It was the judge’s opinion that Bill 96 will not cause irreparable prejudice to the plaintiffs if a stay/suspension of the law is not granted, since no cuts in government grants have yet occurred, nor has the government exercised its other new powers under the new law.

“Hopefully, this will send a message to the CAQ not to use Bill 96 to penalize bilingual cities in any way before the hearing on the merits. It is difficult to prove a prejudice before it occurs, which is why stays/suspensions are only granted in exceptional cases. The Court did find that the issue of unilingual French contracts and the search and seizure questions raise serious concerns. The 23 cities will review the decision and weigh their options. Plaintiffs have 30 days to appeal the decision.”

The case, first announced last year, is being brought by municipalities that are officially bilingual because they have more than 50 percent mother tongue anglophone populations, and those which have opted in, declaring to the government they want to remain officially bilingual as they are below the 50 percent mother tongue threshold but were officially bilingual according to previous rules.

The municipalities challenging the law, represented by the Grey Casgrain law firm, are Baie d’Urfé, Beaconfield, Blanc-Sablon, Bonne-Ésperance, Chichester, Côte St. Luc, Dollard des Ormeaux, Dorval, Havelock, Hope Town, Kazabazua, Kirkland, L’Isle Aux Allumettes, Montreal West, Mulgrave and Derry, New Carlisle, Pointe Claire, Senneville, Sheenboro, Shigawake, Stanbridge East, Wentworth and Westmount.

The municipalities say that Bill 96 “compromises the concerned municipalities’ bilingual status, which is intrinsically part of their cultural identity, but the proposed provisions also extend far beyond language rights and undermine constitutionally protected and inalienable rights that belong to all Quebec citizens.” n

Court rejects municipalities’ stay request against Bill 96 Read More »

The EMSB Election: The Korakakis Team

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

Incumbent Chair Joe Ortona and his team are being challenged by Team Katherine Korakakis. Korakakis is president of the English Parents Committee Association of Quebec. Her platform includes “prioritizing the mental well-being of our students through comprehensive support programs, ensure that every dollar spent contributes directly to the well-being and success of our students and schools,” amongst others. Korakakis herself has said that as EMSB chair, she “intends to prioritize transparency, accountability, and community engagement.”

Her candidates include:

Ward 1: Franco Mazzariello (Ahuntsic-Cartierville-Montréal-Nord): Mazzariell has more than 15 years of involvement in the school board, and has served as Vice Chairman of the Governing Board at both Gerald McShane and Lester B. Pearson High School, which he fought to keep open.

Ward 2: Howie Silbiger (Côte des Neiges): Silbiger has been an educator for 11 years as well as a longtime radio show host, discussing education, community issues, and current events.

Ward 3: Samara Perez (Côte St.Luc, Montreal West, Hampstead): Dr. Samara Perez is an Assistant Professor in the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences at McGill University, a licensed psychologist at the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC), and an Associate Investigator at the Research Institute of the MUHC.

Ward 4: Viktoriya Grosko (Mercier-Hochelaga-Maisonneuve, Rosemont, La Petite Patrie, Mont-Royal, Anjou, Montréal-Est): Grosko is an entrepreneur, artist, and advocate for children’s education; the founder of Art Blooms Club and host of a Ukrainian radio show.

Ward 5: Incumbent Joseph Lalla (NDG): Lalla has been an educator and principal for more than 35 years and a commissioner since 2007.

Ward 6: Tony Aversano (Rivière des Prairies): Aversano has been a member of the governing board of Lester B. Pearson High School.

Ward 7: Vicky Pololos (St. Laurent): Pololos is Chair of the Gardenview School Governing Board and an active delegate to the EMSB Parent’s Committee.

Ward 8: Antonio Zaruso (St. Leonard): Zaruso has served on the governing boards of General Vanier Elementary, Dante Elementary, and Laurier Macdonald High School and is an environmental consultant.

Ward 9: Joanne Charron Yannakis (Villeray-Saint-Michel-Parc-Extension, Mount-Royal, Outremont): Charron-Yannakis was leader of a grassroots movement to prevent the closures of Carlyle Elementary and Mackay Centre and has worked with the English Parents’ Committee Association of Quebec, Quebec English School Boards Association, and the Quebec Community Groups Network.

Ward 10: Shalani Bel (Westmount, Southwest, Ville-Marie): Bel served on the governing board of Westmount Park School (WPS) for four years — two as Chair — and has been the parent delegate of WPS to the EMSB Parent Committee for three years. n

The EMSB Election: The Korakakis Team Read More »

Over 200 antisemitic crimes in Montreal since Oct.7,2023

By Joel Goldenberg
The Suburban

There were 212 antisemitic crimes committed in Montreal since the Oct. 7, 2023 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel and reported to the SPVM, it was revealed during a press conference held by Federation CJA board chairman Steve Sebag and Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs Quebec vice-president Eta Yudin.

“One is too many, and we’re looking at numbers that are just not anything we could have imagined just a couple of years ago,” Yudin said. “This is a beautiful place — Montreal, Quebec— is very special. Anywhere you go in the world, Montreal has this reputation of being such a fantastic place and we have to work really hard to protect that as a society.This is everyone’s fight, it’s an attack on democracy. It begins with the Jews, it does not end with the Jews. If we value and cherish our way of life and our values, we have to fight together to protect them.”

Sebag said that antisemitism is a sickness that touches all of society. “Sadly, it is often a precursor of racism and intolerance…enough is enough.”

The press conference was called last week to send the message that more has to be done to counter the many antisemitic incidents that have taken place in the city, including shots fired at three Jewish schools, firebombings of Jewish institutions, declarations of hate, harassment and intimidation at schools, and much more.

At another point in the press conference, Yudin said that “we know our community underreports [hate incidents], we know that people ask themselves ‘what’s the point of reporting?’ Its important to report. If we want law and order officials and police to do their job, they need to understand statistically and geographically exactly what’s happening.”

“We’re talking about harassment and incitement to violence,” Sebag said. “Those are pretty clear cut.”

In light of the community underreporting incidents, The Suburban asked what the actual number of hate incidents could possibly be.

Yudin responded that “we get a lot of word of mouth stories that we can’t do anything with, so we know they happened to someone’s cousin, someone’s neighbour, but we don’t have, statistically, enough data to use it, so we don’t, but we know it’s out there and I encourage those people to report.” n

Over 200 antisemitic crimes in Montreal since Oct.7,2023 Read More »

Scroll to Top