Author name: Townships Weekend

Cyrus and the Husk Ferry

Photo courtesy
Husk Scow Ferry

By Nick Fonda

Local Journalism Initiative

Drummond County was at the northwest edge of the Eastern Townships as they were laid out late in the 18th century.  Unlike most of the Townships, which were first settled by Americans from the New England States, Drummondville was founded by a British army officer.  Frederick George Heriot, who had distinguished himself in the War of 1812-14, was given the mandate to establish a dual-purpose settlement.  This new place would be a farming community, but it would have an armory and a ready militia.  Almost all of the first settlers who followed him to Drummondville were disbanded British soldiers and mercenaries. 

One of those disbanded soldiers who received a 100-acre allotment was John Husk.  Born in 1781 near Plymouth, on the south-west coast of England, he was a married man with a young son when he enlisted and was shipped out to Canada to fight in the War of 1812-14.  He and his fellow soldiers arrived in St. John, New Brunswick and inaugurated their first winter in Canada by marching 1400 km to Niagara, Ontario.  He fought and survived several battles, and at the end of the war, he opted to join Heriot’s colony rather than return to England. His wife, Elizabeth Wood, and son, William, joined him some time later.  The couple had a second child, Mary Ann, whose date of birth is unknown and who passed away in 1881.

The first years, John Husk and his fellow soldiers-turned-farmers had a very rough go of it.  Unbeknownst to them, as they were scurrying to erect shelters and sow crops, halfway around the world the eruption of Mount Tambora was starting to spew so much smoke and ash so high into the atmosphere that the Earth’s climate was changed for the next few years.  Carbon particulate floating ever so slowly downward blocked so much of the sun’s light and warmth that 1816 came to be known as the year without a summer; and 1817 was not much better.  

John Husk’s 100-acre allotment was on the west bank of the St. Francis River, approximately where the Drummondville airport is situated today.  He fulfilled his obligation of building a cabin and clearing a certain acreage of farmland.  Sadly, he was killed in 1823, at the age of 42, while felling a tree.

John’s son, William Wood Husk, perhaps partially prompted by his father’s death, moved upstream to L’Avenir.  Many of the early settlers did likewise as the Drummondville area’s sandy soil—the dried-out bed of the Champlain Sea—was ill-suited to farming.  William moved to another river-front property, a location which would later lead his son to operate a ferry service for almost half a century.   

Photo courtesy
Cyrus Husk, 1870ca

William Cyrus Husk, son of William Wood Husk and grandson of John Husk, the disbanded soldier, was born on the family farm in what is now L’Avenir on September 8, 1847.  In 1868, when he was 21, he married Sarah Ann Barker and the couple had nine children.  Sadly, in 1884, Sarah passed away.  Five years later, Cyrus remarried and with Mary Selina Harriman he had five more children.  At the time of his death, in 1924, 11 of his children were sill living, some of them as far afield as Saskatchewan and Ohio.

Cyrus Husk played an active role in his rural community.  His death notice in the Sherbrooke Record following his passing on May 27, 1924, reads in part:

A long life spent in the service of other—no duty shirked, no task evaded—warrants the statement that in the death of Mr. Husk, Drummond County has lost one of her outstanding citizens.

The relatively long obituary mentions that Cyrus Husk died of pneumonia following a short illness.  He died on the family farm where he’d been born 76 years earlier and where he’d spent all his life.

Cyrus had played a major role in church affairs and this was reflected in his funeral services.  They were officiated by not one but two clergymen, the Reverends Thomas Knowles and J.S. Dickson. 

The Sherbrooke Record noted:

Mr. Husk ever displayed a keen interest in the work of the church with which he was long connected as a member and an official.  For more than 40 years there was scarcely an activity of the Methodist Church or of the Sunday school of Ulverton in which he did not have an important part. 

The obituary notes that Cyrus Husk was keenly interested in education and served as a school trustee.  He was similarly involved with agriculture, serving for 30 years as president of the Ulverton Farmers’ Club.

What is not mentioned in the obituary is that between 1876 and 1920, Cyrus Husk operated a ferry service across the St. Francis River. 

Cyrus was 25-years-old in 1872 when, following his mother’s death, he inherited the family farm on the first range in what is now L’Avenir.  The farm fronted on the St. Francis River and was only a short distance from the road that ran from Richmond to Drummondville.

Four years after taking over the farm, Cyrus invested in a long steel cable, a scow, and a couple of rowboats—all the equipment he needed to begin ferrying people and livestock from L’Avenir and Ulverton near the west bank of the river and St. Felix de Kingsey and St. Lucien near the east bank. 

A vivid description of the ferry is provided by J. Clifford Moore who, in 1996, when he was in his 90s, published a slim volume entitled The Life and Times of a High School Principal in Rural Quebec.  Moore grew up, and later taught, in St. Felix.

Moore wrote:

The ferry boat was able to accommodate two rigs at $0.25 per rig and $0.10 a person for pedestrians.  I don’t think Mr. Husk adhered strictly to that regimen.  This writer remembers helping his dad drive ten or twelve head of cattle to the river en route to the fair in L’Avenir.  Mr. Husk and his sons were very cooperative, loading about four of the animals on the boat and those of us on shore urging the rest of the animals into the water.  As I recall, when we had safely crossed the river, my dad asked Mr. Husk how much he owed him, and Mr. Husk said, “Forget it,” and that was that.

Moore points out that the ferry was particularly important to the younger generation.  While Ulverton’s two-room schoolhouse offered primary education, it was St. Felix that had a Consolidated School—the first such school in the province—that provided high school courses.  Several families, including the Husks, on the west bank of the river, sent their older children to the Consolidated School thanks to the ferry. 

The scow was moved back and forth across the river by one or two men hauling on the steel cable.  Pedestrians, if there were only two or three of them, were ferried over on one of the rowboats.

The ferry ceased operating when the river started to freeze up, usually in December, and, after the ice was thick enough, people crossed on an ice bridge.  In the spring, after the ice had cleared, ferry service resumed.  This meant that for two or three weeks every year, students from the west bank were unable to get to school.

Cyrus Husk operated his ferry service until 1920 by which time roads and vehicles had improved enough that people found it easier to travel to Richmond or Drummondville where bridges spanned the river.  During its four decades of operation, it was one of a handful of ferries that regularly crossed the St. Francis River.  To the people of Durham and Kingsey Townships, Husk’s Ferry was a vital service.

Family lore recounts one other unusual story about Cyrus Husk.  Along with another man, he was hired by a Montreal merchant, James Millar, to drive a flock of lambs to pasture in Vermont.  The trip took several days and was made with a horse and buggy.

After his death, his farm was taken over by Stafford Husk, the oldest of the children of Cyrus Husk’s second marriage.  Stafford would be the last of the Husks to operate the family farm.

Cyrus and the Husk Ferry Read More »

Disturbing Language

Photo courtesy

By Guy R Rodgers

Local Journalism Initiative

In August I had the pleasure of being invited to Bishop’s University to show my documentary film What We Choose To Remember. The annual Bishop’s Forum offers young leaders (18-26) an “immersive look at Quebec’s political, social and economic systems and the opportunity to connect with youth from across the province.” Other presenters at the Forum included Jean Charest, former premier of Quebec, and Éric Girard, Quebec Minister of Finance and Minister Responsible for Relations with English-Speaking Quebecers.

Just a few years ago, I would have expected youth to be preoccupied with environmental and social justice issues, dismissing language conflicts as old fashioned and irrelevant to their reality. However, after two years of Bill 96 and an aggressive government campaign against English-language institutions of Higher Education – because too many English-speakers are bad for Quebec, and because English-language institutions of Higher Education corrupt Allophones and Francophones – I was disturbed, but not surprised, that young English-speakers are concerned about language and have serious questions about their future in Quebec.

“Does our government want us to leave?”

Last year, after a screening my film in the Eastern Townships, a member of the audience stood up to say, “My family has farmed here for 193 years. Because of Bill 96 we are wondering if the government will help us celebrate 200 years in Quebec, or if they would prefer to see us pack our bags and leave.”  No one in the audience jumped up to say, “That’s crazy talk!”

The Coalition Avenir Québec government has polarized language to a degree not seen since le Front de Liberation du Québec (FLQ) was terrorizing Anglo Quebec with bombs in mailboxes while presenting themselves as heroic freedom fighters.  The last period of intense conflict triggered an exodus. 

Does our government want to provoke another Anglo exodus?

 When Anglos and Allophones expressed concerns about Bill 96, their questions were dismissed as predictable rhetoric. “Privileged Anglos fought Bill 101 for decades and will obstruct Quebec every time it defends its language and culture.” Serious concerns about using the notwithstanding clause to negate protected rights were dismissed as routine obstructive rhetoric. When educators and students contested improvised attacks on universities and CEGEPS, they were dismissed as whiners too entitled to appreciate the privileges heaped upon the best-treated minority in the world. More recently, when serious questions were raised about access to healthcare in English, questioners were ridiculed as too concerned with their own ‘privileges’ to recognize the higher right of healthcare professionals to work in French.

What is going on here? Does the government have a sinister plan to progressively eliminate minority rights until all Anglos and Allophones assimilate or pack their bags and leave?  Much of the Francophone media dismiss such questions as Quebec bashing. Quebec’s Francophones-de-souche are “the most tolerant, welcoming and generous people in the world” while Quebec’s Anglos are “the most privileged, pampered and ungrateful minority.”

This irreconcilable culture clash reminds me of an incident when I was on the founding board of le Conseil des Arts et des Lettres du Québec. A fellow board member, an award-winning playwright who would go on to become one of Quebec’s best-selling novelists, loved to demonstrate her urbanity by peppering her speech with English words. Still popular in France, this pretention was fashionable in Quebec prior to the current regime of linguistic puritanism that sternly rebukes public use of English words and anglicisms.

One morning in Quebec City, as we met in the hotel dining room at breakfast, my colleague greeted me with, “Good morning, Mr. Rodgers, how are you?” I replied, “I’m very well and how are you?” Her reaction was extraordinary. The blood drained from her face and she staggered backwards muttering her shock at being brutally accosted in English. My effrontery was particularly inexcusable in public, at a meeting of CALQ, which was created to promote and protect French culture. Shocking!

It was no use pointing out that she had accosted me or that I was merely replying in the language and, seemingly, playful spirit of her greeting.

I had misunderstood the rules of engagement. For her to say a few words of English was a sign of her urbanity. Addressing me in English was a declaration that her Quebec is tolerant, welcoming and generous. But only up to a point. To protect its endangered language, Quebec must enforce zero tolerance on privileged, pampered, ungrateful Anglos imposing their language everywhere they go. If Anglos don’t like it, they are always welcome to relocate somewhere in the vast Anglosphere.    

I understand perfectly why today’s English-speaking youth are confused – and disturbed – by the mixed signals they are receiving.

Guy Rex Rodgers was founding Executive Director of the English Language Arts Network (ELAN) until returning to filmmaking. You can reach him at: GRR.Montrealer@gmail.com

Disturbing Language Read More »

Who’da thunk it?

By Dian Cohen

Local Journalism Initiative

The gentle souls who so astutely peruse this august publication excluded, we are an unenlightened lot that, when it comes to electricity, exhibit a stunning amount of internal conflict.

Electricity is so everywhere all the time that we think about it only when it’s not. And when it’s not, life is really tough. If the power goes out in summer, we can’t have air-conditioning. If it goes out in winter, we can’t have heat. Not to mention light. Or in the country, water. In the space of a hundred years give or take, we’ve gone from zero to total dependence. (How many candles, whale oil or kerosene lamps, ice and iceboxes, wood- or coal-burning stoves do you keep on hand for light, heat and refrigeration?)

We are among the largest electricity consumers in the world – maybe it’s because it’s cold here. Or maybe it’s because we have a huge global advantage – our water resources and our technological resourcefulness have created hydroelectric powerhouses around the country – Quebec alone produces more than half our domestic electricity, BC’s facilities notch it up to two-thirds. These developed natural resources allow us to produce mostly clean energy in sufficient quantities that we can export about 10 per cent of what we produce. And we have a ready taker right next door.

Our World in Data, Energy Institute-Statistical Review of World Energy, 2024

There’s a huge demand for electricity and it’s growing at its fastest rate in years. Leaving aside developing economies like India and China, the increasing uptake of technologies that run on electricity – electric vehicles, a charging system for them, heat pumps and the data centres that teach artificial intelligences – are on course to set new demand records.

Canada’s gearing up for a lollapalooza future, right? Well, sort of.

Clean and relatively cheap electricity is made from manipulating water – Quebec does this most. Less environmentally-friendly electricity is made from fossil fuels (coal, natural gas, and petroleum) of which the western provinces have a lot. More expensive electricity comes from nuclear and renewable energy (on- and offshore wind, solar panels). We make electricity using all these methods and we argue a lot about how bad it is to use less-than-pristine-but-plentiful fossil fuels.   

Ember (2024); Energy Institute – Statistical Review of World Energy (2024);   Our World in Data.org

Our ace in the hole is our water – we’re one of the top five countries in the world with the most renewable fresh water. Here’s the double-edged sword. Unless we live on a reserve, whom the powers-that-be have despicably neglected, we’ve taken it for granted – we’ve failed to look after its infrastructure (think Calgary water main rupture), we haven’t priced it properly, we waste it.  

Not only don’t we have a water conservation ethic, but we’re also oblivious to the dimensions of a world with less of it. Scientists at Environment Canada say that in the past four decades, snowfall in both Canada and the United States has dropped by about 4.6 billion tonnes per year. That’s a lot of lost water. According to a 2019 report commissioned by Environment and Climate Change Canada, temperatures in the country are increasing faster, on average, than the rest of the globe. With hotter summers and less snowfall in winter, water reservoirs aren’t filling up the way they used to. Without water, we can’t make cheap, clean electricity. Overall, exports to the US fell nearly 25 per cent last year, to the lowest level since 2016.  Quebec, BC and Manitoba all reported less hydro production; the latter two reported more power imports from the US.

Less water may not be forever, but greater variability from Mother Nature seems assured. Water inflow variability is actually well understood in the hydropower industry – specialists have many ways to capture what’s available. It’s less clear that we have any interest in conserving water for purposes such as drinking, bathing and other somewhat civilized endeavors.

Government of Canada

We don’t respect our natural resource bounty but we’re ingenious at exploiting it. Along with hydroelectric power, renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, and biomass are practically infinite. We’re in the world’s top-10 in onshore wind capacity, even though it produces only a small fraction of our electricity. The idea of placing turbines at sea to harness wind energy over open water has come to Newfoundland and Labrador – it hopes to have offshore wind areas leased by 2025 and has the federal government’s blessing to proceed with approvals in provincial waters. Unconstrained by hills or cities, offshore winds tend to be stronger and more consistent than onshore ones, able to produce three times the power of their onshore facilities.

We can do solar too, although solar energy’s potential varies across the country. Not so good on the coasts lower because of increased cloud cover, much better in the central areas. Solar panels on the roofs of these sunny residential homes could possibly supply half of Canada’s home energy demands. Notwithstanding the dozens of residential solar incentive programs currently available across the country, we’ve hamstrung ourselves with an equal number of legislative, regulatory, and infrastructure hurdles that prevent these installations.

As for storing electricity, Canada is #1 among 30 countries that were assessed for their potential to build a secure, reliable, and sustainable lithium-ion battery supply chain. “This [2024] marks the first time China has not claimed the number one position. Canada’s consistent manufacturing and production advances, and strong ESG credentials, have helped it become a leader in forming the battery supply chains of the future. Strong integration with the US automotive sector means Canada is also a big winner of the ‘friendshoring’ ambitions of the Inflation Reduction Act. The country’s position in BNEF’s ranking is propelled by policy commitment at both the provincial and federal level,” says a Bloomberg entity that specializes in energy.

Who’da thunk it? Where would we be if we pulled together?

Cohendian560@gmail.com

Who’da thunk it? Read More »

The fall saga – healthy eating that helps the environment

By Pooja Sainarayan

Local Journalism Initiative

Food preservation has been a practice since ancient times, and basically refers to the process of safely lengthening the lifespan of food while maintaining as much of the nutrient quality as possible. There exists various methods – drying, smoking, salting, freezing, canning, pickling and more. With the increasing demand for fresh food and reducing overall food waste to promote a healthier environment, preservation has become increasingly important in food independence and culture.

One of the oldest methods of food preservation is dehydration. By removing moisture from food, the bacterial growth is inhibited. Depending on the humidity of your location, this method may prove to be a challenge. However, if humidity is an issue, dehydration followed by freezing the food may be the best technique to prevent bacterial growth. Storing dehydrated food in airtight containers is important in maintaining the dehydration levels. Modern-day methods such as water-bath canning which uses heat to kill any bacteria or enzymes in the food products is commonly used for high-acid foods such as tomatoes and fruit jams/jellies. Similarly, pressure canning used for low acid-foods such as vegetables and meats is another method of processing product in a jar. Pickling uses high acid concentration through the pH preservation of food, which needs to be followed by water-bath canning to kill off any potential bacterial growth that remains in the jar. Finally, freezing food is also commonly used and is one of the most affordable methods of food preservation. Freezing slows down the growth of bacteria and enzymes but does not completely eliminate them. For this reason, thawing food in a refrigerator helps keep them safe. So how are the nutrient contents affected by various preservation techniques?

Some vitamins are less impacted by processing than others. Fat-soluble vitamins such as vitamin K, A, D and E are more stable during processing and storage than water-soluble vitamins (vitamin B and C). The most stable vitamins include vitamins B3 (niacin), K, D, B7 (biotin) and B5 (pantothenic acid). The most unstable vitamins are folate, thiamine (B-complex vitamin) and vitamin C. Food processing methods that expose food to high levels of heat, light or oxygen may cause the greatest loss in water-soluble vitamins such as vitamins B and C. However, the fat-soluble vitamins, minerals, protein, fat and carbohydrates would be less affected by processing methods using high heat, such as canning.

Pressure canning may preserve more vitamin content compared to water bath canning, as the food is subject to high pressures rather than heat. Dehydrating food can also reduce the amount of vitamin C, but it can result in higher nutrient contents such as fibre in plant-based foods. As the food becomes more energy-dense when it dries out, over-consuming dehydrated products may result in weight gain. If the dehydrated food is cooked with water, this results in more nutrient loss as they are leached out of the food and into the water. Freeze-drying is also commonly used to preserve food and conserves more nutrients than simple dehydration. In contrast to dehydrated food where roughly 75 per cent of the original nutrients are retained, freeze-dried foods retained approximately 95 per cent of its nutrient value. On the other hand, cooking food has lots of benefits such as breaking down parts of vegetables that are harder to digest, destroying harmful bacteria and releasing phytochemicals (chemicals produced by plants). For instance, phytochemicals are greater in cooked tomatoes than when consumed raw. Freezing food is a great way to preserve the nutrients. The nutrient losses are often due to the processing prior to freezing, such as blanching where the food is heated very quickly with steam or water. Onions, leeks, rutabaga and peppers do not need to be blanched prior to freezing and therefore results in high nutrient yield post freezing. The nutrient loss (mainly vitamins B and C) from blanching is generally only 10 to 20 per cent. Although canning may result in some nutrient loss, other nutrient content may actually increase. Therefore, canned foods and frozen foods are both a comparable means of preservation in terms of retaining the foods nutrient contents.

In summary, there is some vitamin and mineral loss with all preservation methods, but this is relatively minimal. The global impact of food preservation helps the environment by significantly reducing food waste. In addition, there is continual demand for fresh and sustainable food to meet the needs of producers and consumers. Food preservation also faces challenges, in ensuring safety, quality and effectiveness which requires continuous research and education to promote a healthy and durable food system.

The fall saga – healthy eating that helps the environment Read More »

Can Quebec Liberals bounce back?

Despite its fall in 2022, PLQ has voters, ideas and soon a new leader

By David Winch

Local Journalism Initiative

Have we seen this movie before? A restless Quebec electorate tires of a government after a couple of terms. The beleaguered party leader struggles against the new tides of opinion. Then comes the election, and voilà – a brand-new government.

These are the cycles of Quebec politics, both provincial and federal: successive waves of red, blue, orange and light-blue party support. New parties are formed, rise, quickly grow, then get bounced.

Liberals and PQ alternated for decades in Quebec City. Then the CAQ upset the checkerboard.  

Historically, this is quite new. Provincial parties in Canada often used to stay in power for decades. The Union Nationale of Maurice Duplessis retained power for almost two decades, totalling 18 years before 1960. (In Ontario, the Conservatives governed for 42 straight years, from 1943 to 1985.)

By contrast, the last two Liberal and PQ governments were each kicked out after just one term. Maybe it’s the caffeinated effect of new media— voters are often impatient for change.

CAQ failures

In 2018 the Coalition Avenir Québec was elected. Ostensibly pragmatic, the CAQ proposed to move past federalist-sovereigntist debates and focus on practical matters. Health care, for example.

But after six years in power, there’s been no progress on that front. The CAQ’s latest initiative, a large central health agency called Santé Québec, is not trusted by anyone to improve service or access to doctors.

“In their daily lives,” writes soft-nationalist commentator Josée Legault in the Journal de Montréal, Quebecers “are at the end of their tether with a health system which, instead of improving, is deteriorating.”

“If a real change of direction does not occur on this crucial issue, whether or not the federalist-sovereigntist debate returns, there will be no forgiveness in the voting booth.”

Today, given these and other policy shortfalls, the CAQ is viewed as ineffective. It looks like a new Union Nationale, a regional, patriarchal, top-down party losing touch with social trends.

Can the Parti Libéral du Québec (PLQ) now challenge the CAQ?

“Any new leader of the PLQ who is the least bit presentable would pose an additional danger to [the CAQ] on the electoral front,” concludes Ms. Legault. And this, despite what she described as “the historic debacle of the Couillard-Barrette duo” during the 2014-2018 Liberal reign.

Predictions galore

So what will happen in the 2026 election? Nobody knows. Political consensus is often wrong.

A decade ago, Quebec media were unanimous: the 2014 election was the PQ’s to lose. One top writer at La Presse, Lysiane Gagnon, published a guest column in the Globe and Mail titled: “PQ Has Reason to Be Confident”. Gagnon basically foresaw an easy victory for Pauline Marois’ PQ and another defeat for the hapless, post-Charest Liberals.

My political intuitions told me this was quite wrong.

So I published a comment in the Globe pointing out that in British Columbia just a few months earlier, the media had been similarly unanimous that the NDP would win — and yet it was crushed by the Liberals in a huge upset. Conclusion: “It ain’t over till it’s over.”

Indeed, the Liberals in Quebec surged back to power in 2014 with a new majority.

Fast-forward to 2024. The Parti Québécois has moved ahead in most polls. Many voters may be “parking” their votes there, as the nationalist CAQ steadily declines. In April this year, l’Actualité magazine published a poll by Pallas Data showing the PQ in first place, but with the resurgent Liberals moving into second, ahead of the CAQ.

Few polls have repeated this result, but it is credible: Quebec Liberals thrive when sovereignty becomes an issue. Despite its aura, independence is not a winning option with mainstream Quebec voters; it has stagnated in polls for decades.

In a three-way race, the Liberals might just slip up the middle. The Montreal media would again be stunned.

Slow to relaunch

After the Liberals’ humiliating defeat in October 2022, they proceeded slowly toward a relaunch. Many voters asked: Where are they — in hiding? Callers deluged talk radio with complaints about their absence.

Finally, in mid-2023 dates were set for an official leadership race to be held between January and June 2025, leading to a Liberal convention.

Some contrarians argued that the steady-as-she-goes Liberals might be on the right track.

 “With the next [Quebec] election on the distant horizon, the decision to hold off selecting a new leader might not be such a bad idea after all,” wrote former MNA Robert Libman in The Gazette, in September 2023. “Timing in politics, as it relates to election cycles (momentum, peaking too soon, political honeymoons) is a critical consideration that must be managed skilfully to maximize chances of winning.”

This go-slow strategy is largely the work of André Pratte, president of the political commission of the PLQ and former editor of La Presse. An honest man, Pratte quit his plum post as a federal Senator (“I was ‘fed up’ with partisanship in all its forms, which continues to derail debates,” he wrote). Instead, he is carefully preparing a serious Liberal programme to govern again.

 Pratte, in an interview with Radio-Canada in May 2024, described his role as trying to “rebuild, find our values, create an alternative”. He said Quebec Liberals need to stress individual freedoms, along with a commitment to Canada and to economic liberalism.

As for identity politics, Pratte told The Gazette in 2023: “Liberal nationalism is not the same as the identity nationalism of the CAQ or PQ. The nationalism of the Liberals is to make Quebec’s interests in the Canadian federation a priority.”

“We are convinced that there are many more Liberals in Quebec than the ones who voted for the party in 2022.”

Can slow and steady win the race? Pratte’s wager suddenly has decent odds.

Can Quebec Liberals bounce back? Read More »

If wishes were horses…

Photo: courtesy

By Mary Ellen Kirby

Local Journalism Initiative

   Could we have a moment of silence, please? I think a brief acknowledgement of the passing of giants is in order. It is a melancholy thing to wander the back roads of the Eastern Townships this summer and count the increasing number of stalwart old barns falling to wrack and ruin or simply disappearing altogether. Time and gravity have ravaged many; they have succumbed to vicious winds or punishing snow loads. Others have been scavenged, the bones picked apart, reduced to pricey plunder taken away to be repurposed as décor in city homes. Truly, I mourn their loss. It seems to me more than the simple loss of a building; it is also the loss of history and culture those grand old barns represent.

Some barns sit derelict, surrounded by cropland, like ghost ships adrift in a sea of waving corn tassels. Some are still attended by dilapidated farmhouses and decaying outbuildings, so at least they aren’t dying alone. Some have lost various parts of their anatomy, have listed sideways off their moorings or bear the indignity of trees growing through their roofs. They remind me of nothing so much as wounded soldiers, shamefully abandoned on the battlefield. And make no mistake: scraping a living from the land was indeed a battle back when those barns were built. A good, sturdy barn – or the lack thereof – could make or break the farm and the farmer.

   In those days, erecting a good barn was not farmed out (yes, pun intended) to various experts, engineers, architects and contractors. Farmers were both the brawn and the brains behind barn construction, relying on the life experience of older farmers and the willing hands of neighbouring farmers to get a barn raised. At least one winter would have been spent cutting and hauling out the logs to mill into the lumber needed, and a barn of any size at all needed a lot of lumber: no steel trusses or beams in those days. Many barns would have been roofed with cedar shakes, only replaced with sheets of tin as the farmer could afford it. Here in the Townships, many a barn foundation was built of field stones, painstakingly picked by hand, hauled by a team of horses and a dray or stone boat to the rock pile, where they waited patiently for future repurposing. A starkly different proposition than calling the closest cement plant for delivery of already mixed, ready to pour cement, I wager to say.

   Barn design was different in those days, as well. Cavernous hay mows were needed to store a winter’s worth of loose hay, pulled up into the mow with big rope and pulley operated hay forks. Far above our heads in the old barn that houses our sheep, the rusted steel track for the hay rig is still affixed to the cobwebbed ridge beam; it bears mute witness to a way of life that no longer exists. Hay mows are dim, dusty places, redolent of summer sun-warmed grasses; they are full of mysterious shadows, secretive, skittering noises and dust motes dancing in sunbeams slanting through cracks in the wall boards. For generations, hay mows have been beloved by farm kids looking for a dry place to play hide & seek on rainy days, barn cats hiding a litter of kittens, nesting barn swallows and the occasional farm boy intent on stealing a kiss from his sweetheart. Today’s modern barns have dispensed with hay mows as the hay is stored chopped and blown into a silo, stacked in a separate hay shed or left outside wrapped in plastic against our weather. Modern barns are long and low-slung, clad in shiny metal and they sport multiple enormous fans to circulate the air; new barns slouch and sprawl, while the old-timers stand tall and proud: beaten but not bowed. Old barns have tall wooden chimneys at either end. The chimneys were equipped with doors that could be opened or closed at floor level inside the barn and this simple system allowed the farmer to regulate the flow of hot and cold air manually, providing good air flow for the comfort and health of the winter-stabled livestock. Old barns have unique shapes and characters, and no wonder: each one was conceived according to the individual needs, tastes and budget of the farmer. Juxtapose the quirky individuality of ancient barns with the cookie-cutter models that seem to be popping up all over farm country these days; the new ones seem to be much of a muchness in their blandly boring uniformity. Yes, yes…I know: ‘efficiency’, blah, blah blah…’progress’, blah, blah, blah. But have we chosen to trade efficiency and progress for the very soul of the farm? If that is the case, I can’t help feeling it was a very poor trade indeed.

Photo: Courtesy

   I realize my prejudice is showing, but I won’t apologize for that. I prefer grizzled old veteran barns with stories to tell, stouthearted barns whose hand-hewn beams are infused with a century’s worth of memories, generous barns that offer shelter and succour to both man and beast. New barns don’t have time for any of that fanciful nonsense: they are much too busy proudly proclaiming their efficiency. I think their bright and shiny, new and improved allure is a poor substitute for the comforting countenance of an old barn. New barns are brisk, business-like structures; they more closely identify with an industrial setting than an agrarian one. They unapologetically make no provision for mama cats and kittens, fledgling barn swallows, courting farm boys or, most sadly, children at play. If small children can’t exercise their imaginations in the safe embrace of an old barn, how can we expect them to imagine themselves as the farmer? I have been accused of harbouring overly romantic notions about farming and perhaps that is true. Again, I make no apologies. But it is very difficult to fall in love with sprawling industrial facilities, no matter how efficient they are. And, at the root of it all, it is love that makes a farm – and a farmer.

   I am grateful that the old barn I grew up in is still standing resolute; that it still hears the lowing of cattle, the rustle of barn swallows, the mewling of kittens and the laughter of children. Does it still provide the romantic setting for a stolen kiss or two? I’m not telling. The dying barns dotting our countryside haven’t been occupied in decades; they are unequivocal proof that the adage of ‘use it or lose it’ still applies. Most old barns still in use have been modernized: electric lights in lieu of lanterns, mechanical barn cleaning systems replacing pitch forks and wheelbarrows, automated water bowls instead of lugging endless pails of water. I am not opposed to bringing 21st century function to 19th century structures; I just wish the iconic character of old barns could remain intact. I wish the solid legacy of those barns, and their builders could be honoured by continued purposeful use. Those tough old barns and the resourceful, determined farmers who built them, are the rock-solid foundation this country was built on. With the neglect and destruction of every old barn, goes a piece of our history, a piece of our culture. It is a very sad day when another giant topples.

   I wish I could launch an old barn rescue mission. I wish I could save them all, give them the respect they are due. I wish it was contagious, this passion of mine for the weary old warriors still standing; maybe then we could reverse the distressing modern trend of abandoning these monumental old heroes. Oh well…if wishes were horses, then beggars could ride, as the old saying goes. And if my wishes came true, the horses would have beautiful old barns to live in.      

If wishes were horses… Read More »

The sustainable consumption index

Your Personal Carbon Calculator? Photo: Mastercard

By Dian Cohen

Local Journalism Initiative

We’ve been hearing for years now that the big challenge is to limit global warming to below 1.5C above the pre-industrial era. Now comes word from the European Union’s Copernicus Climate Change Service that June was the hottest ever, the 13th consecutive time a month has set a new average temperature record. The average for the year through June 2024 was 1.64C higher than the era from 1850 to 1900. This suggests that, if we don’t want to spontaneously go up in flames, we will have to work our tails off to achieve the emissions targets to which Canada has agreed.

How we get motivated to do that is the challenge. Most of us are broadly aware that a flight from Montreal or Toronto to Rome or Riyadh makes a lot of CO2 emissions. COVID provided concrete proof that less flying reduces CO2 emissions – they went down more than 5 per cent in just the first few months of COVID. But we have no real idea what difference it makes to the environment if we recycle our plastics, or if we go out for a nice steak dinner, or if we buy a brand-new outfit in a high-end retail store.

The fact is that the vast majority of global greenhouse gas emissions are generated from our lifestyle choices. Industry and regulators are unlikely to solve the climate crisis — most emissions are directly connected to consumer demand. So if we’re going reach our global decarbonization targets, we have to change our habits, and it would help if we could know how much our individual actions count.

There may be a way to do just that, although email conversations with the creators leave some doubt. A Sustainable Consumption Index has been developed by Mastercard and Doconomy, a Swedish fintech company. Here’s how they say it works. Mastercard takes its total debit transactions (it makes them anonymous) and categorizes them into spending categories – food, transportation, retail, etc. Then it adjusts for inflation so comparison with past years is possible. Doconomy has created an index of estimated CO2  emissions for each of the spending transactions. The index can create interactive simulations of the impact of a population-wide shift to low-carbon consumption. For example, it can answer the question, “what’s the impact of everyone using a carpool or public transit, or eating less meat, or buying more second-hand ‘vintage’ goods compared to current emission levels from driving a car, eating lots of steak and burgers or buying new retail goods?”

Does it work? That’s as yet unknown. Sweden was motivated to try it out apparently because they already knew that individual Swedes need to reduce their emissions fivefold by 2050 to meet that country’s climate change commitments. So they took it on: the two companies created the index starting in Q1 2021, using Swedish data. The quantitative measure of Sweden’s aggregate consumer carbon footprint was launched publicly this past June.  So far, one example of the consumption index shows that emissions resulting from spending on air travel and fuel are not declining as fast as those on retail spending. It also shows that there’s been a 2 per cent reduction in national emissions from Q1 2023 to Q1 2024.

Maybe this new measurement tool could be a step forward in the battle for a cooler planet. Up to now, we’ve been working in hindsight, looking at what has happened in the past to inform our decisions going forward. The Doconomy index purports to be forward looking, reaching people before they back out of the driveway, book their cabs, buy their T-shirts or fire up the barbeque. The Swedish Environmental Protection Agency says the simulation models can be used by manufacturers, advertisers and policy-makers to encourage Swedes to change their buying habits toward more sustainable choices.

The two companies have also created a personal Carbon Calculator app that’s supposed to show the impact of individual users’ purchases. The idea is that if we have insight into the effect our day-to-day footprint has on the planet, we can make small adjustments resulting in real change. The Carbon Calculator allows us to view the estimated carbon footprint of all our purchases. Our footprint is tracked month by month across a variety of spending categories so we can better understand where we’re having the greatest impact.

Except of course that the index is available only in Sweden right now and it’s still not clear that a majority of Swedes are aware of it. The spokespeople for Mastercard and Docomony were most forthcoming about what they had already published in their own news releases. But then your spunky reporter asked questions like

How would Canada begin if we wanted an index like the one created for Sweden? Who would have to contract with Doconomy and Mastercard? Would it be the government? the financial community? how does that work? How much does it cost to have an index created? How long does it take? Once you were contracted, would you use earlier years of Mastercard spending to create the index? Has there been a lot of publicity in Sweden about the index and how to use it? Have you had a lot of feedback from consumers? Do any other countries have such an index?

Your waiting-with-bated-breath-reporter has been ghosted. It’s been a month since our last correspondence with either Mastercard or Doconomy.

It’s an interesting idea, and maybe the two companies will be more forthcoming. I’m still hoping for a response.

Cohendian560@gmail.com

The sustainable consumption index Read More »

Remembering the International City of Jazz

Guy Rex Rodgers and Alain Simard July 2024. Photo: courtesy

By Guy Rex Rodgers

Local Journalism Initiative

What Quebecer has not enjoyed a summer’s day at the Montreal International Jazz Festival? Over the years, we came to take for granted the throngs of people of all ages and backgrounds happily enjoying the music and the street performances, some scripted and others purely spontaneous. We recalled how extraordinary it was through the eyes of out-of-town visitors marvelling that so much was freely available to so many.

Montreal’s jazz festival was a reflection of its co-founder, Alain Simard. During the 2024 edition of the festival Simard, now retired, launched a book about his dream to create a festival that became one of the biggest and most popular in the world.

Full disclosure, I worked with Alain Simard and the festival for several years, interviewing artists for televised concert broadcasts. The Gatsby-era solid oak desk in my office belonged to Alain when he founded the jazz festival in 1980.    

Simard’s book Je rêvais d’un festival1 is the story of a young man discovering culture, politics, the music business and entrepreneurial skills that would enable him to create Montreal’s International Jazz Festival. The book is also a fascinating encapsulation of contemporary Quebec history.  

Born in 1950 in Villeray, not far from Michel Tremblay’s Plateau, Simard experienced the end of the Duplessis era, now remembered as La Grande Noirceur (the Great Darkness). It is difficult in today’s militantly secular society to imagine that Quebec was so recently deeply religious. Simard’s family was no exception, in the faith of his youth or the subsequent embrace of secularism.  

The 1960s in Quebec were an explosively exciting march to modernity with the creation of a Church-independent education system, CEGEPs and a network of Université du Québec campuses. In Montreal: the metro system, towering steel and glass skyscrapers, demolishing acres of inner-city slums and Expo ’67.

The 60s were also the era of a more violent program of modernization with le Front de liberation du Québec (FLQ). The young Alain Simard had a summer job at Eaton’s, infamous for refusing to serve customers in French, where he discovered that francophone employees were not permitted to speak to one another in their mother tongue. Simard’s girlfriend, who worked for an airline, also discovered that her unilingual Anglo bosses refused to allow Francophone employees to engage in private conversations in a language the bosses could not understand or monitor.  

I found the book’s chapters on the FLQ and the rise of Quebec’s separatist movement particularly interesting. Simard was stopped and questioned twice by police during the October Crisis, under the exceptional powers of the War Measures Act, simply for being a leading figure in the underground music scene. His sister was clubbed by police during Lundi de la Matraque. Simard’s family was a microcosm of the divided society that held two referendums on independence and twice voted to remain in Canada. His father was a militant indépendantiste and friend of René Lévesque, and his mother a discreet federalist whose letters-to-the-editor in support of Pierre Trudeau, written under various pseudonyms, were discovered only after her death. 

Like many Québécois of his generation Simard made a pilgrimage to Vancouver in the 60s where he practiced his English and discovered the kids in BC were more liberated than his religiously repressed peers back home. Simard was profoundly influenced by Expo ’67, which flooded Montreal with modern ideas, global culture and visitors from around the world. The jazz festival he created in 1980 would hold its first edition on Île Ste-Hélène, on stages built for Expo, before migrating to St-Denis Street, where the festival encountered severe opposition from the mayor of Montreal. Jean Drapeau was the father of modernity in the 60s and 70s but Drapeau was also the politician who built his career on cleaning up vice associated with jazz clubs that flourished in Montreal during the years of American prohibition. Drapeau was adamantly opposed to the rebirth of jazz in his city, and ordered city workers to remove the festival’s first street stage during the middle of the night.

Alain Simard’s book is a fascinating account of culture and politics in modern Quebec. His passions are complex. He wanted Montreal to be proudly French but his city also included Oscar Peterson and Leonard Cohen. Simard wanted his festival to be an international showcase for the most talented musicians on the planet and for fans from around the world. Simard’s vision is broad, generous, ambitious and as welcoming as the festival he created. Je rêvais d’un festival is a celebration of things that make us proud of Quebec and happy to call it home.

Guy Rex Rodgers was founding Executive Director of the English Language Arts Network (ELAN) until returning to filmmaking. You can reach him at: GRR.Montrealer@gmail.com

1 Je rêvais d’un festival (I dreamed of a festival) Alain Simard, Les Éditions La Presse (2024).

Remembering the International City of Jazz Read More »

Does it bug you too?

Grest Golden Digger Wasp. Photo: Susan Mastine

By Nick Fonda

Local Journalism Initiative

The neighbour in question lives on the other side of the street, up just a few houses.  His back yard fronts onto the river, and as such, he sees quite a bit of wildlife.  A small telescope set up in his living room that overlooks the St. Francis lets him keep a close eye on local fauna.  This year, he had a resident beaver at the foot of his property for a short while.

Like an expert woodcutter, the beaver felled a couple of trees, dropping them into the St. Francis so they stretched from the riverbank to a small island.  The trees were the starting point for a dam that would have spanned ten metres or more.  Given more time, or other conditions, the beaver would likely have completed the job.  As it was, there were heavy rains, the river rose, and his (or her) hard work was swept downstream.   He (or she) moved on.

Mammals that haven’t moved on, the neighbour said, are the muskrats.  There’s a small colony of them digging tunnels into the bank of the small island.  Eventually, their burrows will hasten the erosion of the river bank and shrink the small island even further. 

The neighbour sees lots of birds.  This year, at one time or another, he has spotted almost 40 different species in his back yard.  He frequently sees two eagles, and he suspects they have a nest nearby.  He has also spotted an osprey fishing in the river.

Still, despite the variety, he says there are fewer birds this year than he is accustomed to seeing.  With the possible exception, he adds, of starlings which are at least as numerous as ever.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, starlings are not native to North America.  The good folks who brought 100 European Starlings to New York City in the 1890s and let them loose in Central Park had no idea how quickly they would multiply and become an invasive species across the city, the state, the country, and the continent.  They thought that, in a very subtle way, they were enriching the culture of their fellow citizens.  They wanted Central Park to have all of the birds mentioned in Shakespeare’s plays, including the starling.   Did any of them know that in Celtic mythology, the starling is a symbol of fertility? 

As for insects, my neighbour hasn’t noticed the same significant decline as he has with the bird populations.

That’s not the case on my side of the street.  In the past, at the right time of the day, our back yard often hummed with insect life. 

Some insects, I consciously hunted and killed.  When I found a wasps’ nest—often up quite high under the eaves of the roof—I resorted to insecticide, a long ladder, and the cover of darkness to exterminate them.  I rationalized that eliminating the wasps would make the garden safer for the bees. 

I now have some regrets.  We had no wasps last year and have not seen any this summer.  As for bees, I have only seen one in our garden this year.  (I’d have seen more had I spent time in the garden in May.)  We still have flies and mosquitoes and other insects, but noticeably fewer than in previous years.

While I am not the resident gardener in our household, I am occasionally called on to help with one small task or another.  In previous years, any job that involved strenuous work like digging was scheduled to avoid peak insect times.  A job might not be finished until the next day because, when the insects got too bad, seemingly not at all deterred by insect repellent, I would abandon my tools and take refuge in the house. 

The other day, I had a couple of small tasks in the garden.  I was not quite finished the first job when I became aware that it had suddenly turned quite hot and it was no longer overcast.  Even before I finished thinking that these were conditions that brought the bugs out, there they were.  No-see-ums are small, black, flying insects that want to get into your ears and eyes.

I was a little annoyed with myself.  I could have started earlier and dawdled a little less.  I could have had both jobs done before the little midges started biting me to death.  I continued on.  If I could finish at least the first job, it wouldn’t feel like a lost morning.  For the moment, they weren’t that bad.  Then, to my surprise, they were gone.  They came back once more, but again didn’t stay long.  I ended up getting both jobs done. 

I know that, in previous years, under the same conditions, the no-see-ums would have driven me into the house.  This year, the swarm that came at me was small, and was disinclined to pester me for more than a few minutes.

Nor is it just in my back yard that there are fewer insects.

It has always been common, in the summer, to return from a road trip with the front of the car encrusted with the remains of insects. 

The other week, a day after getting back from Three Rivers, I decided to take half an hour to give the car an unaccustomed wash.  Because I have an electric car, the front end lacks a grille.  Instead, there’s a solid front panel that stretches from headlight to headlight.

While the sides and back end of the car accumulate a certain amount of dust and dirt, the front end, in the summer time, tends to accumulate a lot of small, dark dots—the tiny carcasses of insects killed by a vehicle travelling at a 100 km/h.

What was surprising, given that the car hadn’t been washed in over a month, was how few insects’ remains I had to scrub off the front of the car.  They were as difficult to wash off as ever, but there weren’t very many of them, not compared to previous summers.

I don’t have any particular fondness for flies, mosquitoes, wasps, and other flying insects.  Scraping them off the front of the car is a bit of a nuisance, even if the water I’m using is hot and soapy.  Having them hover around me like a dark cloud when I’m working in the garden is an impediment that I’m glad to do without.

Still, it troubles me that insects that were once abundant are now scarce.  It doesn’t help that I’m all too conscious of the direct correlation between insect populations and bird populations.

As for the neighbour up the street, it may be that insects are faring better in a riverfront habitat.

Does it bug you too? Read More »

The ever-changing world of AI

Photo: courtesy

By Pooja Sainarayan

Local Journalism Initiative

AI technology allows machines to learn from experience and adapt human-like intelligence. The reality of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is all around us, from its use in banking, GPS guidance, smart home devices and generative AI tools like chat GPT. Humans have been toying around with AI for several decades, however the implication of the technology is evolving now like never before. AI can be traced back to the 1950s, from the design of chess-playing computers to the first artificial neural network. There are two major subgroups of AI – weak and strong. Weak AI, also known as artificial narrow intelligence (ANI) is trained to perform very specific tasks. This is the type of AI that is most common in day-to-day tasks today, some examples include Amazon’s Alexa and self-driving vehicles. Strong AI on the other hand, is a theoretical form of AI where a machine would have an intelligence equivalent to or even greater than humans. It would be self-conscious with an ability to learn, solve problems and strategize. Strong AI only exists in science fiction for now, but research on its development is ongoing. AI technology often goes hand-in-hand with deep learning, which is closely modeled after the adaptability aspect of the human brain, to develop AI algorithms in learning from accessible information and perfect its ability in making predictions over time.

Several cities in Canada have been implementing deep learning AI technology for various projects. For example, Edmonton has integrated AI with remote cameras to monitor wildlife coming into the city. Since 2022, Alberta has been using AI tools to analyze data points and foresee where new fires are most likely to occur the following day, giving firefighters a head start. A powerful tool worth research and improvement, as tech partners predict this investment could save up to 5 million dollars a year. Montreal is experimenting with Fujitsu, an AI tool used to analyze the traffic flow of over 2000 traffic lights in order to help the city take proactive measures in decreasing traffic-related issues. Apart from increasing the flow of traffic and reducing air pollution, it can also help the city plan maintenance routes for snowplows or other service vehicles more competently. In addition, Montreal’s transit agency is planning to use AI to monitor the CCTV footage to recognize any signs of public distress in efforts to prevent suicide in the subway system.

Recently, municipalities in Quebec City have been adopting AI tools to track everything from trees, cars and backyard pools. The Communauté métropolitaine de Québec (CM Quebec) which encompasses Quebec City and its suburbs, states that this project will help municipalities monitor urban growth, parking availability and environmental goals. The geomatics development manager of CM Quebec, Frédérick Lafrance mentioned the organization has worked with deep learning AI technology using aerial photos of the city to identify buildings, swimming pools, backyard trampolines, cars and various other features. As expected, the AI would be able to analyze larger data sets of the aerial photos in a shorter time frame compared to humans, to get more work done in less time. This AI-generated data analysis can be used in several ways, such as measuring urban greening and tree cover versus how much of it has been converted to asphalt over time, said Lafrance. Tracking backyard pools and such features can help the city coordinate inspections. However, the use of AI as a surveillance tool is very different from having an inspector perform the duty, so it remains to be seen how the public reacts to this change. In this case, the AI is using already generated aerial footage to differentiate objects, and not digging into further information such as licence plate numbers or the make and model of any objects.

Interestingly, on the other hand, the impact of AI can go beyond measuring trees and backyard pools. In a 2017 U.S study, an AI deep learning tool was used to characterize the make and model of cars in millions of pictures from Google Street View. Researchers found that in cities where sedans were the majority over pickup truck vehicles had an 88 percent chance of voting Democrat whereas cities with more pickups had an 82 percent chance of voting Republican. Findings like these serve as an important tool for policymakers and pave the way for ethical and sociological questions.

Despite having a relatively brief history, the technology has shaped our lives like nothing ever before. As AI technology grows more and more powerful, we can only expect its impact to increase with the years to come.

The ever-changing world of AI Read More »

The first pint

George B. Capel, 1863. Photo: McCord Stewart Museum

By Shawn MacWha

Local Journalism Initiative

When most people think of Lennoxville and beer, their minds likely turn, perhaps a little fuzzily, to the Golden Lion (or, if you prefer, Le Lion d’Or). First opened in 1986 this pub was at the vanguard of Canada’s microbrewery revolution. Since that time, it has served locals, students, and visitors alike with a variety of bitters, lagers, stouts and ales to sooth the soul and fire the imagination. But long before this institution crafted its first pint, another brewery also made fresh beer for hard-working and thirsty locals.

The Lennoxville Brewery was one of the very first beer makers to be established in the Eastern Townships. Opened by British immigrants Thomas Austin and George Slack in 1837 it was located on four acres of land between what is now Queen Street and the Massawippi River in lot 12, range 11 of Ascot Township. Powered by a water wheel, the brewery pulled the water needed for the brewing process directly from the river via a series of pipes. Inside the brew house there was a large cast iron kiln to dry barley, a malt mill, and other vessels necessary to the art of making beer including two large copper kettles and all of the required cooling and storage equipment. Local wheat, barley, hops and clean water were all readily available and the brewery had an impressive capacity of 1,260 litres per batch.

This was, however, a difficult time for a small-scale brewery to open in the Eastern Townships. The region had not yet been reached by any railways and there was only a rudimentary network of roads and trails. As such it was both difficult and expensive to transport beer out of the area to the larger markets of Montreal, Quebec City or the United States. Additionally, the local population was insufficient to permit the business to grow. Only three years earlier, in 1834, there were fewer than 200 people living in Sherbrooke and while the influx of immigrants to the area following the founding of the British American Land Company undoubtedly brought in additional customers there were simply not enough local drinkers to allow Austin and Slack to make any money. To complicate matters, at least from the perspective of aspiring brewers, there was an active temperance movement in Canada during this time committed to riding the country of alcoholic drink. In November and December 1841, for example, R.D. Wadsworth of the Montreal Temperance Society toured the Eastern Townships and while he made many converts to his cause he also noted that the recent establishment of the brewery in Lennoxville had undermined his efforts.

Lennoxville near the time of its first brewery. Photo: BANQ

In the face of these pressures the owners were actively trying to sell their brewery as early as June 1841, billing it as “a desirable opportunity” for “emigrants and others” in the Quebec (City) Gazette. Unfortunately for them, they were unable to find a buyer and the enterprise went out of business in the summer of 1843. By this point Austin had moved to St. Johns (Saint-Jean-sur Richelieu) where he was working as a trader while Slack had relocated to Eaton. In an attempt to recoup at least some of their investment the defunct brewery was auctioned off by James Scott at the Merrick’s Hotel in Lennoxville on March 11, 1843 and was purchased by Charles Anderson Richardson, the town’s postmaster, for the modest sum of ₤213 (approximately $46,000 today). This sale included the brewery, granary, stables, all equipment necessary for the production of beer and the land upon which it sat. Alas, for reasons that are lost, Richardson could not pay for his newly acquired brewery and the property was seized by Sheriff Charles Whitcher later that autumn. The site was once again put up for auction at Whitcher’s office in Sherbrooke on October 10, 1843 at which time it was purchased by G. Weston who then went on to sell “Lennoxville Beer” throughout the region for the next 15 years.

In 1858 Weston sold the brewery to George B. Capel, a native of Salisbury, England who had just immigrated to the Eastern Townships following a stint in India. Soon after acquiring the brewery Capel partnered with Robert Atto, a local farmer also from England, to run the business. In what must have been a great relief to the drinking public Capel and Atto ran an advertisement in Sherbrooke’s The Canadian Times newspaper that they would “spare no pains to keep up a constant supply of Good Ale and Beer” to the area. Capel, it should be noted, was a man of keen entrepreneurial spirit and less than a year after buying the brewery he also partnered with local soap manufacturer E. Moe and started selling soap directly from his brew house. Much more importantly, in 1863 Capel discovered copper on his farm south of Lennoxville and lost no time in developing what would become the Capelton Copper Mine. He was also instrumental in founding a number of other companies during this period including the Magog Petroleum Company in 1866 and the Dominion Gold Mining Company the following year before he sold his various businesses and returned to England in 1868.

It is not clear if Capel’s departure from Canada marked the end of the Lennoxville Brewery or not. The last mention of the brewery in any Sherbrooke area newspaper occurred in the summer of 1859, long before Capel returned to England. The Coaticook Historical Society, however, has suggested that the brewery was in business until sometime around 1875. This is supported somewhat by a record of a Thomas Guinan working as a barber at the “old brewery” in Lennoxville in 1876. It would certainly seem that the brew house was closed by then, but that the reference to the former establishment was still recent enough to be meaningful. Regardless, whenever its closure occurred it did not appear to be a newsworthy event which is a pity given how important the enterprise likely was to the earliest inhabitants of Lennoxville. Slàinte Mhath.

George B. Capel, 1861. Photo: McCord Stewart Museum

The first pint Read More »

Not all weeds are our nemesis

Photo courtesy

By Pooja Sainarayan

Local Journalism Initiative

Invasive plants and weeds are often used interchangeably, but generally speaking, weeds refer to plants growing where they are not welcome. Weeds can be local or non-local, invasive or non-invasive, and competitive or easy going. However, weeds tend to share certain properties in which they can gain advantage over desirable plants. First, they can reproduce in many way – sexually by seed and asexually by rhizomes. Second, certain weeds can block the sun from other plants by leafing out sooner than slower growers. They can also retain their leaves for a longer time during fall, allowing for a longer photosynthesis period and ultimately increasing their survival. As a result, weeds have populated areas undergoing extreme conditions such as draughts and have come on top as survivors. Apart from their top-notch survival skills that can harm the reproduction of other plant species, can our local weeds serve other purposes?

Weeds can give us a lot of information about soil, as all plants have specific environmental conditions, including soil preferences in order to thrive. For instance, the nitrogen content and whether the soil is too compacted or eroded. Identifying weeds that give hints on these possible issues can help us make the needed changes such as tilling or adding organic matter to our gardens. An example is weeds with deep taproots, such as dandelions and burdocks can be an indicator of compacted soil that lacks air, water and nutrients. On the other hand, weeds are the ecosystems way of correcting the soil to achieve more balance. Dandelions and burdocks have deep and strong roots that also help break up the compacted soil. Similarly, weeds can also be an indicator of good soil. In the case of common groundsel, knapweed, lambsquarters and fiddleheads that are all common weeds of Quebec, signal nutrient-rich and fertile soil.

Apart from providing hints of soil conditions, some weeds have played crucial ecological roles. The milkweeds are a prime example of such weeds. In Quebec, there are four native species – Common milkweed, Swamp milkweed, Poke milkweed (relatively uncommon), and the Butterfly milkweed (endangered species in Quebec). Milkweeds are perennials that carry flowers grouped in umbels. They are called milkweeds because of the milky white sap that leaks when the plant is injured, which may cause an allergic reaction in some people. The nectar of milkweed attracts many pollinating animals such as butterflies, hummingbirds, bees and wasps. Monarch butterflies feed exclusively on milkweed, being the only host plant for this butterfly species. The issue is, despite the importance of native milkweeds, these plants are often mistaken for regular weeds and wiped out causing harm to pollinators and declines in the monarch butterfly populations. In addition, milkweed has been used by the First Nations as food, and to make rope. The common milkweed has made a comeback because of the properties of its fiber, which is made by the silky hairs of its seeds. It is used primarily in thermal insulation, stuffing for quilts and pillow and even as an absorbent material in oil spills.

Other weeds such as dandelions and purslane offer several health benefits to humans. In French, the word dandelion translates to “pissenlit” which translates in English to “pee in bed”. This name comes from the strong diuretic properties of the dandelion leaves. The dandelion plant is edible and has been used throughout history to treat several conditions such as digestive ailments, joint pain and fever, although the evidence of efficacy requires more research. The dandelion leaves are highly nutritious, providing beta-carotene and vitamins C and K. The roots contain inulin, a prebiotic fiber that nourishes the good-gut bacteria. So, skip the weed killer and rid your lawn of dandelions by harvesting them! Similarly, purslane, also known as portulaca is an edible weed. It is known to contain ten times the omega 3 fatty acids found in spinach. It can be served raw in salads where it tastes like pea shoots, or it can be steamed where it tastes like spinach. Of note, beware of toxic imitators such as euphorbias that often grow close by. Euphorbias release a milky sap when its thick stem is broken, providing an easy method of identification.

To conclude, weeds can be detrimental to the garden and in some cases even toxic to humans. On the other hand, they can provide many benefits to pollinators and human health, meriting more respect than they get. It may just be worth it to research our garden weeds in more detail to learn about their possible key roles in our ecosystem and human health.

Not all weeds are our nemesis Read More »

Cacography in the age of technology

Photo courtesy

By Nick Fonda

Local Journalism Initiative

A friend who keeps an eye on a wide variety of topics sent me a link to an on-line article in The Conversation, a nonprofit media outlet.  Written by Misha Teramura, an Assistant Professor of English at the University of Toronto, the article had the long title:  Think tech killed penmanship?  Messy handwriting was a problem centuries before smartphones.

My first reaction was to ignore the article.  I already knew that messy handwriting predated smartphones and computers.  I had firsthand experience with messy handwriting dating back to the middle of the last century. 

I was first made aware of penmanship in Grade 5.  That was the year that pupils were expected to make the big step of graduating from pencil to pen.  In September, we were doing all our work in pencil.  At some point in the year, those whose penmanship was judged adequate began writing with a pen.  This was the late 1950s and a pen consisted of a handle and a nib.  Every few strokes, the nib would have to be dipped into an inkwell.  It could be messy.  Hence, our teacher insisted that we had to write neatly and legibly with a pencil before we were permitted to write with a pen.  At the end of Grade 5, I was one of those still writing with a pencil.  (As I recall, in Grade 6, despite my failures in Grade 5, I was writing cursive with a ballpoint pen.)

It was only on second thought that I scrolled down to scan the rest of the text.  It was written in response to an article in the New York Times several months earlier which attributed the poor penmanship of today to the use of laptops and smartphones.

Teramura begged to differ.  As someone immersed in the world of Shakespeare and his contemporaries, the professor from Toronto had ample evidence that bad handwriting could easily be found 400 years ago.

Teramura wrote, “In countless letters that survive from the early modern period, writers apologize for their bad handwriting.  Sometimes they blame it on circumstances:  they were groggy from just waking up or tired late at night (“scribbled with a weary hand in my bed” reads one sign-off from 1585).”

At other times, he noted, the excuses for poor handwriting were medical:  a broken arm from falling off a horse, a hand injured in a duel, or stiffening joints from arthritis or gout.  A common excuse—as it still is today—was that the letter had to be written in haste and hence the handwriting was poor.

Teramura described cacography—or bad handwriting—as calligraphy’s evil twin.  He pointed out that there is a long list of famous people who had poor handwriting, including Queen Elizabeth I and the Dutch scholar, Erasmus. 

At the time, before typewriters and laptops, handwritten letters were all that could be sent.  Penmanship was a necessary skill, or at least a useful one.     

Strangely enough, although good penmanship was of benefit to the upwardly mobile, it was cacography that that appealed to the ruling class.

Teramura wrote, “The aristocratic nobility was notoriously bad at writing by hand.  Popular dramatists even made jokes about it.  But bad handwriting may have been deliberate.  In fact, Shakespeare’s Hamlet says just that:  I once did hold it, as our statists do,/ A baseness to write fair, and labored much/ How to forget that learning.”

Hamlet had mastered handwriting, but he now intentionally neglects to use this skill.  It was below those born into power and privilege to write neatly. 

Teramura noted, “Writing carelessly could be a way of asserting one’s social or political clout by forcing others less privileged to struggle to decipher what one had written.”

Today, or at least up until quite recently, the medical profession tended to be associated with cacography.  A few decades ago, it was still commonplace for a doctor (sometimes more that one) to run a general practice in a small town.  Typically, a patient would call the doctor’s office, show up for an appointment, and leave with a prescription for the pharmacist.  In my experience, the prescription was always all but illegible.

Cacography is as close as I got to med school.  Perhaps my handwriting wasn’t bad enough.  Equipped with ball point pens, I remember carrying on regular and even frequent handwritten correspondence with friends through my teens and twenties.  (Of course, I made a point of typing my papers at university.)

Today, on my laptop, I type the stories I send to my editor.  The notes I take during interviews however, are scribbled with my ballpoint pen into my notebook.  My handwriting hasn’t improved with age.  I always try to type up a story as soon as possible after the interview.  Even with a fresh memory, I’m not always able to decipher my hastily scrawled notes.  And reading something scribbled three or four days previously is often impossible.

Teramura reminded me that I was in good company, “The Reformation theologian Martin Bucer allegedly couldn’t even read some of his own manuscripts.  Nor was he alone.  As the preacher John Preston (1587 – 1628) observed in a sermon, “One would think a man should read his own hand, yet some do write so bad, that they cannot read it when they have done.””

Teramura finished his article, “Today, the ubiquity of smart phones and laptops has no doubt played a role in the ways we write.  But for those of us who can’t read our own sticky notes and to-do lists, it may come as a relief to know that bad handwriting is not an unprecedented phenomenon, but has its own centuries-long history.  We’re simply living a new chapter of it.”

A quick inquiry into penmanship in school today makes me wonder if handwriting hasn’t already gone the way of straight pens and inkwells.  Has cursive script already disappeared?

Describing her Grade 5 class, one teacher told me that of her 21 students, only one—a girl—always wrote in cursive script.  All her other students wrote in block letters.

As well as being unable to use cursive script, many young people today cannot read a handwritten text.

In 2019, an enterprising teacher at a local elementary school initiated a local history project for Remembrance Day.  The research material included documents from Archives Canada and handwritten letters from WWII.  One of the difficulties the students met was that much of the old documentation was handwritten.  The students had to learn to read and write cursive script to make sense of their research material.  And then, as would those of us long accustomed to handwritten letters, they had to cope with cacography.  The project planned for mid-November was completed in June.

Handwriting was useful until quite recently because writing in cursive script is much faster than printing out words in block letters.  However, it is not as fast as typing and, in most circumstances, not nearly as convenient as a laptop or a smartphone.

Penmanship, in the form of calligraphy, continues to exist as a minor art form.  For those of us who still do put pen (or pencil) to paper, cacography continues to be an occasional—if not frequent—presence, even on things as innocuous as a shopping list.

Cacography in the age of technology Read More »

The wreck of French, the triumph of English

The Raft of the Medusa. Courtesy

By Guy Rex Rodgers

Local Journalism Initiative

This provocative title is borrowed from a new book1 that provides some global perspective on the vitality of French and English. Which language is doing better or worse? Compared to what?  And compared to when?

Lionel Meney is a French linguist, trained at the Sorbonne, who came to Quebec to teach at Laval University. After a lifetime of studying languages in a global context, Meney concludes that the battle between French and English is over. French has been defeated on every significant front and English has triumphed. His assessment is bleak but he supports it with 250 exhaustively documented pages of examples and statistics.

Meney refutes the arguments of naysayers who believe French in Quebec is doing just fine. Global data supports the claims of François Legault’s CAQ and Paul St-Pierre Plamondon’s PQ that French is seriously threatened and dangerously declining. However, while language pessimists are correct about the imperilled state of French, Quebec’s desperate attempts to address global problems with solutions that blame local villains are misguided and doomed to fail.   

The most vivid example Meney offers to make his case is the working language(s) of the European Union. The first six countries to form the Union were France, Germany, Italy, the Netherlands, Belgium, which has three official languages (French, German, Dutch), and Luxembourg, which also has three official languages (French, German, Luxembourgish). The EU operated with four languages (French, German, Italian and Dutch).  Things changed in 1973 when Great Britain joined.

As the EU increased from six members to 28, the cost in time and money of translation rose exponentially. English became the convenient lingua franca. By 2007, 72% of EU documents were written in English.  No single fact demonstrates the irresistible power of the English language more clearly than the predominant role it continues to play in EU communications eight years after Brexit. The English people could vote to leave the EU, and Europe could wave England goodbye, but the EU continues to communicate in English, now the post-national working-language of the global community. 

Other international institutions are subject to the same reality. The UN has 193 member nations that speak hundreds of different languages but the U.N. recognizes only six official languages: English, French, Russian, Spanish, Arabic and Chinese. The languages are not equally utilised.  English dominates 75% to 85% of UN communications. 

Meney documents the triumph of English in academic publications, second language instruction, international commerce and product labels. To have a comfortable mastery of English is a distinct advantage while to be unilingual in any other language, including French, is a handicap.

 “Not long ago you could you could have a successful (international) career as a unilingual Francophone.  That is no longer possible.”  “Failure to master this language (English) has become an insurmountable obstacle.”

In addition, French societies are being invaded by English words and transformed by English syntax, and young Francophones are enthralled by English culture. The internet is massively dominated by English. Despite France’s long history of international influence and the large number of French-speakers globally, the French language is everywhere in retreat.

Is this English domination fair? Is it good? The one thing beyond dispute is that it is a reality.

Meney believes governments can play an important role in support of language by providing first class education and assisting immigrants to acquire language skills. The current government of Quebec prefers to score points among its base by reducing the availability of first class education – when it involves English-speaking universities and CEGEPs.  The current government finds it more popular to deny immigrants services in languages other than French after six months rather than invest necessary resources to enable all immigrants to acquire French skills. The CAQ’s francisation program has been strong on rhetoric and aspirations but lamentably weak on planning and implementation.

Meney’s conclusion is sensible. “If the expansion of the domain of English seems inevitable, to save what can still be saved we must organize the cohabitation of the two languages ​​on our territory.”  The inescapable future is linguistic cohabitation, aka bilingualism. The utility and popularity of English are undeniable. Quebec’s worst strategy is to defend French by declaring English an enemy unwelcome in the workplace, the public square and private lives. That war has been fought and lost. If anyone doubts it, they need to read Meney’s book.

Guy Rex Rodgers was founding Executive Director of the English Language Arts Network (ELAN) until returning to filmmaking. You can reach Guy at: GRR.Montrealer@gmail.com

  1. Le naufrage du français, the triomphe de l’anglais by Lionel Meney (collections L’espace public, 2024) ↩︎

The wreck of French, the triumph of English Read More »

Poverty reduction  – good, bad, and ugly

By Dian Cohen

Local Journalism Initiative

Shortly after becoming prime minister in 2015, Justin Trudeau took Jean-Yves Duclos aside and told him to develop Canada’s first-ever national poverty reduction strategy. Thus began many months of roundtables and town halls, in person and online, via conversations and conferences, informing the then minister of Families, Children and Social Development on how to reduce poverty in this country.

Two and a half years later, “Opportunity for All – Canada’s First Poverty Reduction Strategy” was published. Its primary goal was to reduce poverty by 20 percent by 2020 and 50 percent by 2030 based on the official measure of poverty. (This article won’t deal with the secondary goals of reducing chronic homelessness by 50 percent, ending all long-term drinking water advisories on reserves by 2021 and reducing or eliminating housing need for 530,000.)

There are well over 100 benefit, credit, incentive and other programs offered up by federal, provincial and territorial governments, all designed to transfer cash to low-income Canadians to further the primary goal of reducing poverty. They are all administered, not by the department of Families, Children and Social Development but by the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), the tax-collector-in-chief. In Canada almost all government cash benefit payments require recipients to file a tax return. Individuals who don’t participate in the tax system, often the most vulnerable in society, may forego these benefits or even entitlements to government services when such services are tied to tax return information.

For the 31 million of us who filed a personal income tax return this year, it’s a tedious but necessary pain in the ass. Tedious because the basic tax return has 172 lines and 15 different schedules to pore over before you get to “Refund or Balance Owing”. Necessary, because failing to file gets you the double whammy of draconian interest penalties to pay and missing out on possible cash transfers like the Guaranteed Income Supplement or the Canada Workers Benefit.

Do you know how many of us don’t file a return? Neither does the CRA. They think it’s between 4 and 5 million people. They also don’t know why these people don’t file, since the estimated value of cash benefits lost to working-age non-filers is at least $1.5 billion.

Leaving seniors’ benefits aside, the largest benefit is the Canada Child Benefit, which pays out over $24 billion/year to parents. As an example, a low-income family of four with two young children in Ontario is in line for about $19,000 in federal/provincial child and family benefits. Benefits are similar in other provinces. The growing financial importance of these benefits leaves eligible recipients who don’t file a tax return increasingly penalized. As important, it reduces the effectiveness of our poverty-reduction goals.

Courtesy Statistics Canada

In the interests of getting potential cash benefits into the hands of low-income earners, the CRA has, for the past six years, offered an automated phone service that allows low-income Canadians to file their tax return over the phone by answering a short list of questions. The uptake has not been good, averaging only about 60,000/year. Close to half the people invited to file for free may have paid a professional to help them file. The CRA can’t say why people would choose more expensive filing methods, although to an outside observer it looks like people don’t know about file-by-phone or the benefits for which they may be eligible, or the system is just too complicated or there are other reasons.

Indeed, there’ve been sufficient academic studies that say there are lots of ‘other reasons’. Many low-income people are suspicious of government and unfavorably disposed to tax filing. Some concerns are based on ignorance, like, for example, that cash benefit entitlements administered through the tax system will be clawed back from their social assistance benefits. Or they don’t understand how tax refunds work. Or they’re scared, fearing that by filing they might invite the CRA to dig into past income sources and expose them to serious actions by government.

 In Budget 2023, the government announced its intention to increase the number of Canadians eligible for “SimpleFile by Phone” to two million by 2025, as well as to introduce a new automatic income tax filing service. Budget 2024 says the CRA will pilot a digital and paper version of its SimpleFile by Phone service intended for individuals who have gaps in their filing history or have never filed a tax return. It doesn’t say how the CRA will do that, but it does say it will provide an update in the fall of 2024.

So we really can’t say how much all this will cost – either the administrative costs to develop and deliver the file-by-phone program, or costs related to cash benefits delivered to individuals who would have otherwise not filed a tax return and would have foregone the benefits to which they were entitled. And we can’t say whether the CRA’s renewed efforts will be any more successful at convincing non-filers to file than their past efforts over the past six years.

In spite of the many billions of dollars that have been devoted to this project since 2018, the poverty level has moved from 11.2 percent in 2018 to an estimated 11.2 percent in 2024.

No doubt a lot of bad luck and real time issues – Covid 19, inflation, etc. – have intruded. Nevertheless, there’s a serious question to be asked. Is there not a better way to reach non-filers, get cash benefits into their hands and improve our track record of reducing the number of Canadians living in poverty? Other countries don’t require everyone to file a tax return and they manage to transfer money to low-income earners. Canada’s record on poverty reduction compared to other countries is not good. Is this new CRA initiative that builds on a failed old initiative the best we have?

Cohendian560@gmail.com

Poverty reduction  – good, bad, and ugly Read More »

Wildlife ups and downs

As deer proliferate in the Townships, many residents cry «stop!». Photo by David Winch

Why are animal species both thriving and facing extinction in Townships?

By David Winch

Local Journalism Initiative

Wildlife is everywhere in the Townships. But some animal species are surging, while others are definitely not. Two examples of these extremes are deer and sturgeon.

Everyone sees how ubiquitous white-tailed deer are here. Regional conditions are ideal, with leafy deciduous forests, many farm fields and … tasty gardens.

 Anaïs Gasse, a biologist for the Quebec ministry of forests, wildlife and parks, told The Record in November 2022 that the provincial government is aware of the deer boom in the Townships and has been trying to address the situation. “In the Eastern Townships, we have milder winters [than further north] … and we don’t have very many effective predators in the territory,” she explained.

There are no wolves, a few pockets of coyotes and some bear in the region, but not nearly enough to effectively control the deer. In 2021, the Quebec ministry of wildlife estimated the provincial deer population at 250,000 head— double the number in the 1990s. More control measures are needed.

Hunting licences increased

The province has increased the number of antlerless deer licences, allowing more hunters to target fawns and females, government biologist François Lebel told the CBC.

Hunters are now bagging nearly 50,000 deer a year. “When we are overpopulated with deer, we must reduce the population, and unfortunately, to decrease [that number], it is with a lethal method,” said Lebel.

This reduction may be difficult. Deer are a species known as “synanthropes” – animals that can thrive around human settlements. Deer have this aptitude, along with raccoons, squirrels, geese, rats, coyotes, pigeons, crows and, increasingly, wild turkeys.

Pristine nature is not their sole home. Even the biggest cities feel their increasing presence.

The New Yorker magazine reported in 2021 how deer are thriving in the biggest city in North America. There are now lots of deer in the New York borough of Staten Island; they first swam there from suburban New Jersey. Aerial studies by low-flying planes in 2014 counted 763 deer in the green spaces of the borough’s 18.7 square miles.

This puts local greenery under pressure. And the lack of predators for these urban and suburban deer is obvious.

A much-viewed YouTube documentary highlights how the reintroduction of predators can radically affect deer numbers and forest biology.

Deer in Yellowstone Park had been running wild, with populations booming. They chomped down grass pastures, and reduced the number of full-grown shade trees (see https://www.yellowstonepark.com/things-to-do/wildlife/wolf-reintroduction-changes-ecosystem/ ).

Once wolves were re-introduced there in 1995, deer started to avoid open grassy areas. Vegetation bounced back. This provided more habitat for songbirds. Firmer watersheds were good for beaver, and fish took advantage of deeper rivers. Wolves also killed coyotes, which meant more foxes and small mammals.

We can only imagine – or fear — how a peak predator prowling around the Townships might affect our deer population, and later, local vegetation.

Instead, we will have to rely on hunters. Venison, anyone?

Sturgeon are harmed by dams, limiting their numbers in Townships lakes.. Photo by David WInch

Sturgeon still around?

At the opposite end of the wildlife spectrum are sturgeon, known to biologists as lake sturgeon (or in French, esturgeon jaune).

Many people in the Townships have seen the classic “fishermen’s chart” wall-plaque, sold around Lake Massawippi. Its handwritten text highlights fishing holes and Massawippi-area animal habitats. It states clearly: “Sturgeon, 50 to 75 lbs., once swam in this lake. Last seen about 1927.”

A brief internet search turns up evidence to the contrary. The Eastern Townships Resource Centre site displays several photos of triumphant fishermen with sturgeon; in one catch dated 1969, a sportsman holds up an 86-pounder from Lake Massawippi.

After I asked on Facebook’s “Friends of Lake Massawippi” page for recent sturgeon sightings, one poster replied: “I saw a large one in Bacon’s Bay around 1999. It was in shallow [water], resting on the bottom. It looked like a log. It then slowly rose near the surface when I passed over it on a windsurfer board. There were two other witnesses with me. We’ve never forgotten it.”

Veteran fishermen in the area, however, caution that false sightings are common. The real number of sturgeon in that lake today, they say, is likely “zero”.

The water-control dam built downstream from North Hatley in 1967 effectively ended sturgeon spawning in the Massawippi River. The fish ladder installed there is not appropriate for slow-moving bass or sluggish sturgeon; they don’t leap like salmon.

Lake sturgeon prefer fast-moving water and spawn where they find that environment. They “can be found at depths of at least 5 meters but no greater than 20 meters,” clarifies Nature Canada. Sturgeon can still be found in good numbers further downstream in the St. Francis River, which eventually empties into the St. Lawrence.

Nature Canada notes that lake sturgeon also remains a threatened species because “it was overfished starting in the late 1800s and early 1900s.” Huge sturgeon hauls were even used as farm fertilizer. Their numbers fell steeply.

 Sturgeon have relatively few outspoken defenders, perhaps because they are not cute and cuddly: “The largest freshwater fish in Canada, the lake sturgeon, can be easily recognized by its external bony scutes which are noticeable ridges along the fish’s body … They also have a pointed snout and four dangling, whisker-like organs, called barbells, located around the mouth. The lake sturgeon has shark-like features such as a cartilaginous skeleton”, adds Nature Canada.

One large biological study (Fortin et al., 1992), concluded that “Quebec is one of the rare regions of North America that still has relatively balanced and productive populations of lake sturgeon,” mostly clustered in the St. Lawrence and Ottawa rivers or in northern Quebec. Sturgeon have a long life cycle with relatively infrequent spawning, and they can live over 150 years.

So there is still hope for sturgeon here. But unlike deer, they need our help. That recovery could start with something as simple as a workable fish ladder.

Wildlife ups and downs Read More »

A warm welcome for immigrant artist brought rich rewards

Courtesy McCord Stewart Museum

By Shawn MacWha

Local Journalism Initiative

For hundreds of years the Eastern Townships has been a destination for refugees. Whether it was the first Abenaki people fleeing early European incursions along the coast of Maine, United Empire Loyalists following the Crown northwards, or displaced Scottish Highlanders evicted from their ancestral crofts, people have been seeking new beginnings in this land for generations.

Robert Scott Duncanson was such a man. Born in the tiny hamlet of Fayette in the Finger Lakes region of New York sometime in 1821 Duncanson spent much of his childhood in Monroe, Michigan just south of Detroit. In 1840 he moved to Cincinnati and it was there that he emerged as the first internationally recognized African-American artist. Largely self-taught he first practised his art as a young man by making copies of popular prints while earning a living as a house painter. Later, he progressed to portraits and still-life paintings, gaining commissions from some of the more liberal minded citizens of the time who refused to let the colour of his skin mask his inherent talent. Towards the end of the 1840s Duncanson turned to landscape painting and was a founding member of the Ohio River Valley technique which sought to capture the soft beauty of America’s pastoral scenes. By the 1850s many considered Duncanson to be the premier landscape artist in the United States.

Despite these talents Duncanson faced an unceasing tide of racism during his time in Ohio. As a frontier city on the border between slave and free states Cincinnati saw major race riots in 1829, 1836 and 1841 and these tensions remained part of the city’s fabric throughout Duncanson’s time in Ohio. As art historian Joseph Ketner noted in a 1993 “A major portion of Cincinnati’s booming economy depended upon southern trade, forcing Duncanson to face the spectre of slavery daily in the markets, at the docks, and across the river from his home.”

Courtesy

These tensions were only heightened during the American Civil War and in 1863 Duncanson finally decided to leave his homeland and seek a more tolerant audience. He intended to go to Europe to exhibit his works but first stopped in Montreal which he had visited the previous year. Upon his return to that city he was so warmly greeted by the local artistic community that he cancelled his European plans and took up residence in Canada. In September, 1863 he mounted his first serious exhibition in his new homeland, showing his popular paintings Land of the Lotus Eaters and Western Tornado in the home of local photographer William Notman.

For the next two years Duncanson used Montreal as a base of operations as he travelled throughout Central Canada collecting material for future paintings. The Eastern Townships were a favoured destination for him during this time, and his journeys to this area ultimately resulted in some of his most beautiful paintings including Mount Orford and Owl’s Head Mountain. The first of these landscapes was last sold in 2005 when it was purchased at auction for the impressive sum of $296,000 US dollars. The latter work, Owl’s Head Mountain, now forms part of the collection of the National Gallery of Canada along with several of Duncanson’s other paintings. Other notable works from Duncanson’s time in Canada included Mount Royal, Waterfall on Montmorency, and St. Ann’s River. He also produced a number of other major works during this time not associated with the Canadian landscape including his stunningly beautiful Vale of Kashmir. This work showed the influence of British poetry upon his painting, with Alfred Tennyson, John Keats and William Wordsworth being cited as inspirations for his sweeping landscapes.

Not content to merely paint the local countryside, Duncanson also became an important mentor for several emerging Canadian painters during his time in Montreal. The most successful of these artists was Aaron Allan Edson, a native of the Eastern Townships who became a leading Canadian landscape artist himself and was, in 1880, a founder of the Royal Canadian Academy of Arts. Another close associate at the time was Prussian born Canadian artist Otto Reinhold Jacobi.

Owl’s Head. Courtesy National Gallery of Canada

Following the end of the Civil War Duncanson left Montreal to make his much-delayed trip to Europe, after which he returned to Cincinnati in 1866. He continued to paint for the next several years but by the early 1870s his health was starting to decline. In the autumn of 1872 he suffered from a nervous breakdown while preparing for an exhibition in Detroit and was confined to a nearby “insane asylum.” For the next two months he was beset with dementia and the belief that he was possessed by the soul of deceased artist, with some speculating that his condition was the result of lead poisoning from his earlier work as a house painter in the 1830s and 1840s.

Duncanson died in Detroit on December 21st, 1872 and was buried alongside his parents and several siblings at the family plot in the Woodland Cemetery in Monroe, Michigan. In a sad and troubling sign of the times his obituary in the Chicago Tribune the following week sought to downplay his work, noting that “It added a special feature of interest to his paintings that Mr. Duncanson had negro blood in his veins, and his pictures were, therefore looked upon with more or less of curiosity, and this feat sometimes gained for them a sale which could not always have been secured for them by their real artistic merit…”  Fortunately, a much more enlightened view of Duncanson’s skills holds today, and he is recognized for his fine artworks in leading museums around the world.

While Duncanson’s time in the Eastern Townships was fleeting, limited only to short expeditions to paint the local landscape, his mark on the region is noteworthy. During his short time in Canada he not only shared the beauty of this land with a global audience, but he also helped a new generation of Canadian artists to do the same. No small feat for a disheartened refugee 160 years ago.

Robert S. Duncanson, Waterfall on Mont-Morency, 1864 .Courtesy of Smithsonian American Art Museum

A warm welcome for immigrant artist brought rich rewards Read More »

The Solar Spectacle – Northern Lights explained

Photo courtesy

By Pooja Sainarayan

Local Journalism Initiative

The aurora borealis is a beautiful nighttime marvel that is worth travelling afar to observe. In fact, for most people it is the only way to come across “space weather.” Aurora activity is an indicator of ongoing geomagnetic storm conditions or solar flares. Solar flares are eruptions of energy, extreme ultraviolet light and x-rays that are caused by intertwined magnetic fields at the Sun’s surface. These magnetic fields can abruptly come undone or recombine producing the solar flares. X-class solar flares are the most intense type of flare the Sun produces.

A giant solar storm hit the Earth’s geomagnetic field on the first week of May, resulting in the most intense geomagnetic storm and longest displays of the aurora borealis seen in over two decades. After an approximate two-week break, the sunspot section that resulted in the intense storm seen in the beginning of May named Active Region 3664 (AR3664), had rotated back to face the Earth. Although appearing smaller than when we last saw it, the sunspot now renamed AR3697 still left quite a mark. On May 29th, the returned sunspot blasted out remarkably long intervals of solar flares, which lasted over an hour. According to the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) which assesses geomagnetic storms on a five-point scale, this geomagnetic storm was rated at an average G2 that peaked on Friday May 31st, compared to the severe G4 storm seen in early May. The AR3664 noted in the beginning of May, emitted nearly a dozen X-class flares. As the sunspot was going out of view by Mid-May, the emissions reached X8.7-class, the most powerful flare since 2017. Although the brightness and duration of the aurora activity seen the end of May was not the same as in the beginning, the forecast still showed a likelihood of spotting the northern lights throughout most of Canada.

Solar flares release high energy particles and radiation, amongst which energetically charged particles (high-energy protons) and electromagnetic radiation (x-rays) are the most dangerous emissions. On the surface of the Earth, we are shielded from these emissions by the Earth’s magnetic field and atmosphere. The x-rays from solar flares are halted way above the surface of our planet. However, they do disrupt the Earth’s ionosphere which consequently disrupts radio communications. In combination with energetic ultraviolet radiation, these emissions heat the Earth’s outer atmosphere, causing it to widen. Additionally, emissions and changes in the atmosphere can interfere with satellite communications such as the accuracy of Global Positioning System (GPS) measurements.

It is now known that most of the severe geomagnetic storms are caused by coronal mass ejections (CMEs), commonly associated with solar flares. The precise relationship between CMEs and flares is still not completely understood, as flares can trigger CMEs but sometimes CMEs can be observed without any flares. CMEs carry more material than flares throughout interplanetary space, raising the probability that these dangerous emissions interact with Earth. Solar flares alone produce high-energy particles close to the Sun, some which escape into space. However, CMEs drive a shock wave that can continuously release energetic particles as it spreads through space. When a CME hits the Earth, its impact disrupts the Earth’s magnetosphere, producing a geomagnetic storm. After it leaves the Sun, a CME normally takes three to five days to reach Earth. So, observing the correlated solar flare of ejection of CMEs from the Sun gives an early warning of geomagnetic storms.

Astronauts that are on a mission to the Moon or Mars are in serious danger from the energetic particles of flares. However, astronauts that stay relatively close to the Earth are not in immediate danger as they do not have to worry about the cumulative radiation exposure. A major problem with geomagnetic storms is the temporary loss of electrical power over a large area. The most well-known case of this occurred in 1989 in Quebec. The high flux in the magnetosphere causes elevated electric currents in power lines, exploding the transformers. This can occur more frequently at higher latitudes, where the induced electricity is greatest, and in areas that have longer power lines and where the ground’s conductivity is weaker.

The consequences of geomagnetic storms are more disruptive now than in the past due to our increased dependence on electronics and satellites that can be impacted by electric currents and energy particles up top in the Earth’s magnetosphere. In addition, the cost associated with repairing satellites and large-scale power grids can be very expensive and time consuming.

The Solar Spectacle – Northern Lights explained Read More »

Where have all the farmers gone?

By Mary-Ellen Kirby

Local Journalism Initiative

     Have you ever – literally or figuratively – painted yourself into a corner? I will never forget the first time that happened to me. As a very young and much too-cool-for-the-country adolescent, I made the mistake of complaining to my mother about how tragically bored I was, stuck on our stinky farm with nothing to do. With a sympathetic pat on the shoulder and a big smile, she assured me she could solve my problem. She left me sulking in my corner and disappeared. I was sure she would come back in clean clothes, ready to take me shopping in Sherbrooke. I could almost hear the exciting, new Carrefour de L’Estrie mall calling my name! When she returned a scant few minutes later, not only was she still wearing her chore clothes, but she was also carrying a broom and dustpan, a pail of hot, soapy water and a rag. Still beaming her big smile, she confessed that she was glad to hear that I had so much free time on my hands. She explained that because Dad needed her help outside so often, she had gotten behind in the housework and the living room floor was in desperate need of a good scrubbing.

   “Move the furniture and give the floor a good sweep, then wash it and when it dries, you can wax it, too. The floor wax and cloth are under the kitchen sink.” Stunned into silence, all I could do was nod. In those days, children simply did not talk back to their parents. That floor got the best sweeping of its life: the more I swept, the madder I got. I sloshed that hot, soapy water around and scrubbed till the pattern nearly came off the old linoleum, my sense of injustice building by the second. By the time the floor dried, I had worked myself into a fine lather of martyred indignation. In high dudgeon, I grabbed the can of floor wax from under the kitchen sink and, mumbling and muttering under my breath about the unfairness of it all, proceeded to power wax the living room floor. On my hands and knees, oblivious in all my righteous fury, I laid down a goodly coat of paste wax in warp speed – from the kitchen door right into the proverbial corner. So, there I sat: seething – or “stewing in my own juice” as my father would have said – waiting for the wax to dry enough for me to escape my self-imposed prison. It was a formative moment.

    I have been pondering painted-in corners and self-imposed prisons frequently of late. When I contemplate the subtle but alarming changes to the pastoral landscape of my beloved Eastern Townships, I get that same sinking feeling of rueful recognition. It appears obvious to me that we have been painting ourselves into a corner – agriculturally speaking – for quite some time now. Many of the picturesque villages and quaint hamlets set in gently rolling hills that make the Townships so attractive seem to have fallen on hard times; they are mere ghosts of their former bustling selves. In the village where I attended elementary school, there were two schools, two grocery stores, two hotel/bars, two banks, two gas stations, four churches, a post office, a grist mill, a lumber mill, a doctor’s office and several other small enterprises. Today, the only things still standing are one school, one gas station, one hotel/bar and the post office. We have added a depanneur and a restaurant and while three of the four churches remain open, their congregations have shrunk considerably.

   The decline is obvious, but what is not so obvious is the underlying reason for that decline. To grasp the root cause, a trip into the surrounding countryside is in order. In a five-mile radius around that village were 30-40 small dairy farms. The farm children went to school in the village, the farmers bought fuel and rubber boots and nails and baler twine and fencing wire and animal feed and groceries in the village; they went to dances on Saturday night and church on Sunday morning. The farmers sat on town council, volunteered at church, school, charitable and civic organizations, contributed to fund-raisers and organized events: they were the backbone of that community. In that same five-mile radius today, I can count the dairy farms on the fingers of my two hands…and still have fingers left over. So, where did all the farmers go? Like many simple questions, this one has a complex answer. I think one factor was the burden of increasing government interference: many farmers simply quit because they got tired of jumping through ever more onerous regulatory hoops. The rise of the Parti Québécois also played a role: some farmers just packed up and headed for more Anglo-friendly jurisdictions. Then there is the sad fact that fewer farm kids wanted to take over from their parents so that retirement-aged farmers had no option but to sell off the family farm. The pressures – both natural and man-made – exerted on farmers are formidable, no wonder there are so few applicants for the job.

   In our current agricultural landscape, small family-friendly farms have largely passed away and with them, our once vibrant village life. The farmland itself hasn’t disappeared; it has merely been swallowed up by increasingly larger farms who practice the ‘bigger is better’ business model. But the economic spin-offs from one large farm/farmer simply can’t make up for the loss of numerous small farm families: not in our schools, not in our churches, not in our villages. When numbered companies and foreign investor groups with deep pockets can swoop in and buy up large swaths of agricultural land, it prices our own real farmers out of the market.   Not so long ago, buying a farm – becoming a farmer – was an attainable goal in the Townships. A young farmer could be reasonably certain, that with good management, the farm would pay for itself and could be passed down to the next generation. Alas, this is increasingly rare.

   I was never very good at math, but it seems to me that when it is no longer feasible to buy a farm and pay for it by farming it, we have a huge problem. Land speculators produce nothing edible. When Townships farmland leaves the hands of real Townships farmers, our food sovereignty is diminished, our communities contract and ultimately, these beautiful Eastern Townships are tarnished by the losses. And so, dear reader, I think we have arrived at the corner of this conundrum.  We can see our predicament and we can even see how we got in this mess; what we can’t see is an easy way out of this uncomfortably tight corner. Whatever the answers are, I’m certain it won’t be as simple as waiting for the paint – or wax – to dry.

Mary-Ellen KIrby writes from her small farm in Bulwer, where she lives with her husband (a.k.a. the Shepherd), their dog, assorted barn cats, a motley collection of sheep, chickens, pigs and a donkey named Millie.

Where have all the farmers gone? Read More »

Health for all

Total number of COVID-19 cases reported to WHO January 5, 2020 to May 19, 2024
World 775,522,000
Canada 4,800,000
Courtesy WHO Dashboard

By Dian Cohen

Local Journalism Initiative

We humans are hard-wired to react to immediate threats. So we’ll jump if a speeding car is coming at us or an angry T-Rex is about to pounce. It’s not that we can’t plan for other less immediate threats: we can take an umbrella in the morning if it looks like rain by the end of the day. We can open a savings account that automatically gets a percentage of our paycheque. Our problem is that we aren’t good at hanging onto ideas once the threat has passed.

When the pandemic had us all spooked in 2021, when four million people had already died and were dying at the rate of 100,000 a month, all 194 member countries of the World Health Organization agreed to negotiate a global treaty that would govern their behavior ‘next time’ to make the next health emergency less deadly and disruptive than COVID-19 was.

Cut to today. The pandemic has waned – the immediate threat is gone. The whole world reported only 1,867 deaths in the 28 days ended May 19, 2024. Canada was a hotspot, reporting 30 deaths, although in a country of 40 million, it didn’t make many headlines. So maybe it’s understandable that when the World Health Assembly opened its 77th meeting in Geneva last month, the first announcement was that there was no agreed upon global accord. The high- middle- and low-income countries of the world couldn’t agree on how to share relevant knowledge and technology nor how to produce and distribute vaccines, tests and treatments.

A look at how the market economy works provides the answer to why the global accord never happened. Pharmaceutical companies are in business to make money by developing products that solve medical problems. They can spend tens or even hundreds of millions doing so. Legislation gives them several years’ monopoly on their products so that when they’re successful, they can charge buyers enough to get their development money back and pay dividends to their shareholders and reward their executives.

When COVID was declared a pandemic, scientists all over the world shared their research, otherwise known as intellectual property, freely and urgently. That’s how safe, effective vaccines were developed so quickly. But in this case, the money to develop the vaccines came from governments around the world – estimates are that the US, UK, Germany and others publicly funded (read taxpayer-funded) tens of billions of dollars to help scientists do their work. Moderna, BioNTech and Pfizer turned out to be the winners. At the height of the pandemic, it was assumed that they would share the vaccine technology and know-how with the WHO so that vaccines could be manufactured around the world. That didn’t happen. No restrictions were put on their monopolies over pricing and distributing their vaccines.

Number of COVID-19 deaths reported to WHO 28 days to May 19, 2024
World 1,867
Canada 30
Courtesy WHO Dashboard

All three companies made billions by charging multiple times the cost of production and selling almost all their vaccines to rich countries. Kim Campbell was one of many former heads of state or Nobel Prize winners imploring western governments in 2021 to lift the monopoly protection on COVID vaccines. To no avail.

That’s pretty much the whole story. The sticking points that shot down the global accord were the high income countries’ refusal to share with the low-and middle-income countries their intellectual property and manufacturing rights. The WHO has given their members another year to come to an agreement. It’s not going to happen without some consideration of how a market economy, driven by profit and protected by legislation, works.

Meanwhile, the World Assembly and its 2,000+ delegates proceeded to the week-long meeting at hand, “All for Health, Health for All.” Canada is one of 17 countries championing a resolution entitled “Economics of health for all”. The vision is captured in a 90 second info-clip:  “What if we could design an economy that would prioritize the health of all people and the planet we live on? Where … health is seen not as an additional cost or potential budget cut, but as a necessary investment for our future. A world in which health innovations are shared for the common good, so that everyone can access the health care they need and where governments have the capacity and resources to drive these changes.” In other words, to infuse capitalism with more public interest than private gain.

This resolution has passed, and with it, a mandate to the Assembly to complete a ‘how-to’ manual to transform the world’s economies and report on it at the 79th World Health Assembly in 2026.

The info-clip ends with an inspirational, “the question is not why should we, but what’s holding us back?” The answer to that question is chronicled in our past behavior. Even with the COVID  pandemic raging, we couldn’t agree to share vaccines. Neither did we share 30 years ago when the HIV/AIDS pandemic was raging.

You be the judge of the likelihood of a pandemic accord within the year and/or agreement among all of the 194 member nations that their economy should be built around health and well-being rather than command and control, the market, or whatever else it’s built around now. Humans not only find it difficult to hang onto ideas, but we’re also fundamentally irrational — reasoning, choice, and problem solving are often overwhelmed by fallacies, illusions, biases, and other shortcomings. Vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy mentality are but two more recent illustrations. A more long-standing one related to the economy is ‘the backfire effect’. It describes how we continue to hold onto established beliefs even when faced with clear, contradictory evidence.

cohendian560@gmail.com

Health for all Read More »

Is there a doctor in the house?

Family doctors have many demands on their time and often little flexibility. Courtesy StockCake

By David Winch

Local Journalism Initiative

It used to be so simple!

After we moved in the 1960s, my mother found us a new family doctor, as I recall, by looking one up in the phone book. She likely asked: when can you see us?  — “How about next Tuesday?”

It was often that easy to book a GP.

This has all changed in recent decades, as everyone sees. Finding and keeping a family doctor today is a real worry.

Somewhere between 15 and 20 per cent of Canadians have no family doctor. In B.C., roughly one million people have no GP, while a McGill survey concludes two million people in Quebec have none. In Ontario, the figure is officially 2.2 million; the Ontario College of Family Physicians said that by 2026 that shortfall may rise to as high as 4.4 million.

Alarm bells were ringing throughout the early 2000s, as hospital emergency wards became clogged with people seeking basic care.

Now we face a Boomers’ Crunch: boomer-age doctors are retiring in large numbers, just as their cohort seeks more medical care as seniors.

In my Townships village, two doctors retired in the last decade, with no replacements in sight. We joined a cooperative clinic 20 km away for nursing services and referrals, as needed, to an MD. That works, but nobody thinks it is ideal.

Overall, the doctor shortage risks getting worse before it gets better.

Canadian Medical Association data show government recruitment websites advertised full-time positions for 2,571 family doctors in late 2022. But only 1,461 completed the postgraduate training required to become licensed family doctors that year.

How did this crisis come about in a rich, developed country?

Specialization an issue

Many analysts point to budget cuts. In the early 1990s, during a deep recession, Canadian governments agreed to reduce medical admissions.

As the Toronto Globe and Mail reported in 2022, “Much of the decline in the share of younger doctors can be traced to 1992, when provincial health ministers agreed to cut medical school admissions as part of a plan to curtail mounting health care costs. A Canada-wide 10-per-cent reduction in admissions in the 1993 academic year left the country with fewer doctors entering postgraduate training for the first time, beginning with the graduating class of 1997.”

These cuts, concludes the paper, “resulted in Canada losing part of a generation of doctors”.

Another point of view is put forward by Dr. Anthony Sanfilippo, professor of medicine at Queen’s University. He wrote a 2023 op-ed titled, aptly, “This is why you don’t have a family doctor” and he is author of a new book, The Doctors We Need (Sutherland House Experts).

Dr. Sanfilippo stresses that medical education has changed, with more specialist training. This downplays general practice. When Sanfilippo graduated from medical school in the early 1980s, he was fully trained to start a practice after one year of internship. Today’s graduates are not, given the number of specialties that crowd medical training.

“Canadian medical schools graduate approximately 3,000 new doctors each year … but only about 45 per cent are choosing to engage in family medicine as a career, and just 50 per cent of those are opting to provide the continuing and comprehensive care that would address the needs of unattached patients”, he writes.

Sanfilippo spoke with Townships Weekend recently, and noted that, while each institution in the doctor-certification process does its job well, there is “no consolidated oversight”. We are left, for example, with family doctors working at a piecework rate, while a team approach and single fees might serve patients better.

A career full of obstacles

Some medical students avoid a career path that seems full of headaches.

Most family doctors, after all, must run a small business whose expenses —from office rental and computer service to staff —are entirely dependent on them. Patients suffer from multiple, complex issues. Time is short with many demands in doctors’ workdays. Paperwork stifles any extra time with sick people.

Macleans magazinein 2021 published the personal account of a youngish doctor, a female with four children, whose life in small-town B.C. might resemble the rural Townships.

In “A doctor’s dilemma”, Dr. Kristi Herrling recounted her daily life, starting with 6 a.m. wakeups, managing her children through school prep, then opening her medical office. After a workday often disrupted with emergencies, she helps her husband to make the family supper. She is finally free at 8 p.m. for a further 2-3 hours of paperwork and clinical data.

This includes all manner of tasks: “charting patient visits, checking labs, reviewing imaging, requesting consults, reading specialist reports, filling out forms, researching unusual presentations, advocating for patients, answering pharmacist queries, speaking to home care nurses, and discussing cases that can’t wait with specialists”. Such administration often takes up 25 per cent of a doctor’s time.

As for time off, Dr. Herrling despairs that a “locum”, or replacement doctor, is often elusive to cover her small-town practice.

Before we can graduate more doctors, governments across Canada must act to get the most patient hours from the existing pool of doctors. To this end, several provinces have expanded the responsibilities of nurse practitioners. Pharmacists in Alberta have been granted more initiative in issuing prescriptions.

Quebec has taken welcome steps to reduce paperwork: signing notes to certify student or employee sick leaves have traditionally made doctors “the police arm of human-resource departments”, said observers. Bill 68 has made this optional. Doctors will also be exempted from approving insurance and workers’ compensation claims. Quebec estimates these reforms will cut unnecessary appointments —up to 750,000 annually.

More practical action is needed, and more general-practitioner grads must be graduated for a growing country. Otherwise, regular appointments with the family doctor could become a thing of the past.

Is there a doctor in the house? Read More »

The Lionel Groulx School of History

Courtesy

By Guy Rex Rodgers

Local Journalism Initiative

Lionel Groulx – priest, historian, public intellectual and nationalist – understood the power of history to shape a national identity and make youth proud of their nation. Other countries had real and mythical heroes. Groulx wanted to make the descendants of Nouvelle France proud of heroes like Champlain, Radisson and Dollard des Ormeaux. Groulx’s idea of a good hero was based on the triple criteria of religion (Catholic), language (French) and race (European French). These criteria have exposed Groulx to accusations of xenophobia, and worse.

The CAQ government has resurrected the Lionel Groulx school of history. Francois Legault wants the new National History Museum in Quebec City to celebrate Quebec’s heroes and make young visitors proud to be Québécois. Legault belatedly conceded that the museum would need to find room for some non-Francophones.

I have been accused of ethnic bias in my documentary film What We Choose To Remember, although I have always made it clear that my film is an eyewitness account of contemporary Quebec history from the perspective of Anglos, Allophones and immigrants. One of the reasons I felt the need to make a film about Quebec history from this perspective is that the Lionel Groulx school dominates Quebec’s textbooks.

Last January I was speaking to a group of McGill students studying to become history teachers. I asked how many of them saw their family’s story reflected in the history they had been taught in high school. One student raised her hand, looked around and saw she was alone, and then offered an explanation. “My mother is French…”

I first realized how deeply Quebec history biased while working for the Pointe-à-Callière history of Montreal museum. In 1999 I was hired to write the large multimedia show because the version written for the opening of the museum had been accused of being too Franco-centric. I was hired to diversify the history and make it more inclusive of all Montrealers. 

The group of content experts overseeing my work was happy with a scene in which recent immigrants wrote postcards to relatives back home in Italian, Greek, Yiddish and Mandarin. 

The content experts were not happy with my proposed opening scene that presented several indigenous groups conversing in different languages, negotiating and arguing, and then falling silent as the first French explorers arrived. The museum’s content experts vetoed the scene because, “That would make it look like we stole the land!” The museum wanted the new history show to be inclusive, but the politics of land rights were incendiary in the wake of the Oka Crisis. The official story had to be that Indigenous peoples were nomadic and therefore had no specific land claims.

The rigidity of the official history became clear when I wanted to present a working-class Irish Montrealer. Using the city’s flag as a large visual image, I associated the fleur de lys with Montreal’s French history (the wife of mayor Viger), the rose with British immigrants (John Molson), the thistle with Scottish immigrants (John Young, chairman of the Montreal Harbour Commission), and the shamrock with an Irish immigrant who was digging the city’s sewers and had risked his life labouring on the Victoria Bridge.  

The oversight committee said ‘No!’ and was intractable. They would only agree to present a bourgeois boarding-house keeper whose fancy Victorian gown made a much louder statement than the words she spoke to an invisible audience of Irish labourers. It took quite awhile for me to figure out why the subject matter experts refused to show a labourer. During the next ten years, the multimedia history of Montreal I wrote for Pointe-à- Callière would be seen by two million visitors, mostly school students with impressionable young minds. A working-class English-speaking character would have undermined the popular myth that all Anglos are part of a powerful, wealthy elite. 

Pointe-à-Callière’s management and staff were sincerely trying to make the history of Montreal more inclusive, yet some myths were too sacred to challenge. The CAQ government has given this new museum a mandate to present the Lionel-Groulx version of history. Non-Francophones will feel their stories are excluded.  Some nationalists will celebrate the victory of reclaiming Quebec’s history for its rightful owners – the descendants of Nouvelle France.  The museum will stir up divisive identity politics but will not convince young Quebecers to reject global (English) culture. It will also fail to persuade bilingual youth to share the Groulx-CAQ dream of restoring the unilingual world of pre-Conquest Nouvelle France.

Guy Rex Rodgers was founding Executive Director of the English Language Arts Network (ELAN) until returning to filmmaking. You can reach Guy at: GRR.Montrealer@gmail.com

The Lionel Groulx School of History Read More »

The tiny town of Weedon yielded supplies of copper, zinc, silver, and gold

Weedon, c1950s. Courtesy BANQ

By Shawn MacWha

Local Journalism Initiative

Following the end of the War of 1812 in North America and the Napoleonic Wars in Europe the British government decided to set aside large swaths of Lower Canada to provide the soldiers who had fought in those conflicts with farms. Weedon Township, located 50 kilometres northeast of Sherbrooke, was one such tract and although it was surveyed in the spring of 1818 no veterans came to the area until Major Toussaint Hubert Goddu was granted 202 acres on May 4, 1835. Goddu, accompanied by two friends, moved from his farm at Sainte-Marie-de-Mannoir outside of Montreal to his new home that summer, but seeing the loneliness of the place promptly turned around and returned home.

The township remained empty until 1841 when Germain Biron arrived at the site of what would later become the town of Weedon. His family lived there, alone in the wilderness, until 1847 when they were finally joined by several other French-Canadian families who were seeking opportunities away from the crowded seigneuries along the St. Lawrence River. These new arrivals included the Brière, Fortin, Fontaine and Gauthier families and together they formed the basis of a new community.

Courtesy The Montreal Gazette, March 26, 1858

In August, 1848 Pierre Founier constructed the first saw mill in the area and later, in 1854, the town’s first chapel was erected. It was also around this time that the government began to offer over 12,000 acres of Crown Land for sale along the First, Second, Third, fourth and Fifth ranges of Weedon Township for the astounding price of 60 cents an acre. Fuelled by the new families coming in to open farms on these lands a growing settlement was established around the church and saw mill and on June 21, 1886 the village of Weedon was officially incorporated.   

By the turn of the century Weedon was a thriving commercial hub of almost 400 people which included two sawmills, a hotel, a creamery, a small carriage factory, and a bustling station on the Quebec Central Railway. As with so many other towns in the Eastern Townships it was the railway which formed that backbone of the community, connecting it and its products to the wider world. When James Miller, the local station agent, discovered rich copper and sulphur containing pyrite deposits about six kilometres east of Weedon in 1908 it was the proximity of the railway that permitted the development of a profitable mine. 

Hunting in Weedon, late 1940s. Courtesy BANQ

As it so happened these deposits were the largest ones in Canada east of the Great Lakes and mining operations began at this site in 1913 under the direction of the East Canada Smelting Company, which leased the project to the Weedon Mining Company the following year. Over the next eight years the mine produced almost 585,000 tons of ore containing an average of 3.5 per cent copper and 40 per cent sulphur. After a failed experience with trucks, the ore was shipped from the mine to Weedon Station by means of an ingenious aerial tramway. From there it was shipped directly to markets in the United States where it was used primarily in the production of copper and sulphuric acid, a key industrial chemical. The mine closed in May, 1921 following the discovery of larger and more economical pyrite deposits in Texas and Louisiana and two years later the pumps were turned off, allowing the shafts to flood.

This was not, however, the end. As 1930 the provincial government had recognized that the mine appeared to contain sufficient copper reserves to warrant a salvage operation to reopen the pit. Unfortunately, this did not happen until the 1950s when, as the Montreal Gazette noted, a “boomlet” of mining activity occurred in the Eastern Townships that saw several decommissioned mines brought back into production in order to meet the post-war demand for minerals. One of these facilities was the old Weedon Mine and in February, 1951 the Weedon Pyrite and Copper Company began the process of bringing the old mine back into production in order to access the estimated 500,000 tons of viable ore that still remained in the ground. Tests showed that this ore averaged 1.5 per cent zinc, 2.5 per cent copper and 35 per cent sulphur content, more than enough to make the effort to recover it worthwhile.

Weedon Ferry circa 1920s. Courtesy BANQ

The reopening of the mine was facilitated by the fact that the original operations had seen the construction of three inclined shafts that accessed 13 subterranean levels. It was the existence of this infrastructure that made reopening the mine economically viable as the most significant work required to access the ore was to de-water the old mine. This took place throughout the summer of 1951 and the flooded shafts were pumped out at a rate of about 70 feet per week. Once reopened in 1952 the mine remained in service again until 1960 when a series of cave-ins halted production. By this time the original deposits discovered by Miller had yielded over 19 million pounds of copper, five million pounds of zinc, 113,500 ounces of silver, 11,000 ounces of gold and 200,000 tons of sulphur bearing pyrite. The mine was briefly reopened again in 1969, this time by the Sullivan Mining Group before finally closing for good in 1973.

With the mine closed the focus of the area’s economy returned, once again, to the agriculture and forestry that it has relied upon 100 years earlier. For the most part, that remains the case even today, although over the past few decades tourism has become an increasingly important economic driver. Today Weedon is a thriving town of about 3,000 people living within Le Haut-Saint-Francois Regional County Municipality. An overwhelmingly francophone community its historical path has taken it a long way from its intended destination as a home for retired British soldiers. But such is the nature of the Eastern Townships, and the manner in which First Nations, English, French and more recent arrivals have all come together to form the rich cultural tapestry that runs so deeply through these hills.

Weedon c1900. Courtesy BANQ

The tiny town of Weedon yielded supplies of copper, zinc, silver, and gold Read More »

Chaga – The medicinal mushroom

Photo courtesy

By Pooja Sainarayan

Local Journalism Initiative

Chaga, Inonotus obliquus is a fungus that grows on tree trunks, mainly on yellow and white birch trees found in Quebec as well as other parts of Canada. Chaga flourishes in extreme cold environments making Canadian chaga highly valued. The fungi exists as an encrusted black growth on the trunks called a conk, which absorbs nutrients from the wood. Chaga mushrooms can be found on wounded trees where the conk grows out of the broken branches or trunks. The fungus shields the tree’s wounds and protects it from invasive microbes. Although loggers referred to this fungus as “tree cancer”, it has recently exploded in popularity in the west due to its many natural medicinal properties. The host tree and chaga can co-exist in symbiosis for several years, and the mushroom can be collected up to three times over the course of its lifetime. The chaga actually extends the life of the host tree so that the fungi can survive.

Trees that look similar to birch such as aspen may sometimes be infected with the chaga mushroom, however chaga taken from these species of trees is thought to contain less medicinal properties than the birch chaga does. To harvest the mushroom, it is important to leave enough behind so that the fungus is still touching the exterior of the tree. This ensures that the tree remains protected against any further environmental damage or future infections. Chaga usually grows high up on the tree, so in order to harvest the fungi, one would need to climb the tree. In addition, chaga that is found higher up is speculated to be more potent. Harvesting chaga from fallen or dead trees, or chaga that has fallen to the ground is not advised as it may be contaminated with mycotoxins. This is known as “dead chaga” and is black from the inside and out. Trees containing chaga growing on or close to contaminated lands, mills and industrial areas is also not recommended to harvest. When harvesting the fungi, it should be the size of a large soft ball at minimum and using the proper tools such as an axe, machete, or battery-operated saw is required as it is difficult to separate from the trunk. Proper harvesting and handling methods are key to reaping the most benefits.

Once the chaga has been harvested, it can be processed for consumption. The black outer crust should not be discarded. An air compressor can be used to blast away any dirt and bark. Chaga must be dried immediately following harvest in a well-ventilated area, or kept in a deep freezer if processed at a later time. Placing the chaga to dry quickly in a hot oven is speculated to remove most of its biologically active nutrients, however a commercial food dehydrator can be used. The fresh chaga must be cut into approximately 2-inch pieces to dry until the pieces are stiff and crumbly. The dried chaga can then be storied in an air-tight sealed container for several years.

The history of the chaga mushrooms dates back to centuries, where it was used in ayurvedic and traditional Chinese medicine. Chaga tea has also been used in Russia since the 16th century, as well as in Poland and other Baltic countries. The fungus is believed to have several health benefits such as antioxidant and anti-cancer properties. In addition, it was also used to treat gastric problems, tuberculosis, diabetes, arthritis, and cardiovascular disease. Chaga was also used for centuries by Canadian aboriginal First Nations people. So, let us look at any possible scientific evidence to support the medicinal properties of chaga.

According to a 2021 article published in the Polymers journal, the extract from chaga mushrooms, known as Inonotus obliquus polysaccharide (IOPS), which is a major bioactive component present in the mushrooms, exhibited significant hypoglycemic, hypolipidemic, antioxidant, anti-fatigue properties, as well as cytotoxicity towards several cancer cells such as hepatic carcinoma, lung cancer, ovarian and cervical cancers. In addition, the low toxicity of the chaga mushrooms makes it more attractive for further investigations. However, the polysaccharide composition and content variations between the natural habitat environment and extraction methods are not the same. Therefore, the standardization of planting and extraction is of high importance. Other studies have shown that the various bioactive compounds, including polysaccharides, triterpenoids, polyphenols, and lignin metabolites are responsible for the many health-benefiting properties of the fungus.  Further investigations in the precise mechanisms of the compounds found in chaga and its interactions with enzymes or proteins of the relevant pathways are required to establish more concrete scientific evidence in its health benefits.

Chaga – The medicinal mushroom Read More »

Danny Perkins moves to St. Andrew’s

Danny Perkins. Photo courtesy

By Nick Fonda

Local Journalism Initiative

The official opening won’t be until mid-May, so right now the interior of the new Perkins Art Gallery is a vast, near-empty, well-lit space with newly sanded floors and white walls.  The renovation work, including the entire electrical re-wiring of the building, was started the first week of January and is now down to the final details. 

The only change to the exterior of the building, aside from signage, is visible only at night, when coloured lights illuminate the spire of the new gallery, a building that for almost two centuries served as St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church.

“We had been looking for a new space for the gallery for about a year,” says Danny Perkins.

“We’ve been in the gallery on the Danville Square since 2020,” adds Rebecca Taylor, the gallery director.  “We only had 500 square feet on the ground floor.  The basement, which was much larger, was useable space but access to it was difficult.  Here, 95 per cent of the building is wheelchair accessible.”

“And here, we have 8,000 square feet of space,” Danny continues.  “The basement is only a little smaller than what was the church sanctuary and the church hall.”

Built between 1841 and 1842, St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church had some unusual features, including box pews.

“We had requests for some of those pews,” says Rebecca.  “The Richmond County Historical Society next door kept a couple and a few other organizations kept some as well.”

“We recuperated all the wood from the pews,” Danny adds.  “A lot of it is stored in the basement, and we’ve been using it in our renovations for door and window frames, for molding and baseboards.  We’ve even cut some of it into thin strips to fill the cracks between the pine floorboards.  The wood they used for the pews was butternut and some of the boards are as much as 20 inches wide.  In the long run, it’s all going to be used.  An artisan in Victoriaville is using some to make pens.  Another artisan will be using some to make jewelry.”

The cracks between the floorboards were the inevitable result of the wood shrinking. 

“Two coins were found when the pews were removed,” says Rebecca.  “One with the date 1829 and the other dated 1781.”

The coins, American halfpennies, are about the diameter and heft of a loonie.  They are, understandably, quite worn.  The older coin would have been in circulation for over 60 years if it went lost when the church was first built. 

“The coins will be on display with several other artefacts,” Danny explains.  “We want to acknowledge the history of St. Andrew’s and we’re planning to have an area set aside for a permanent exhibit dedicated to the church.  It will certainly include one of the box pews, some of the organ pipes, and a much-used roll-top desk.”

In addition to a history space, the Perkins Gallery will also have classroom space.

“We are setting up a multi-purpose studio,” Rebecca says.  “We want to host open workshops.  Visual artists who work in anything from ceramic to watercolours would have space to accommodate a workshop of a dozen or more participants.  It could be used for a Saturday morning art class, for example.  It could also be used by an artist from someplace distant who comes here to give a multi-day workshop.”

“Our aim,” she continues, “is to bring people in.  Some people might feel intimidated by the name, art gallery.  We want to be just the opposite.  We want people to feel welcome to come in and look.  We will be displaying the work of 30 artists who span all the spectrums, from emerging to established, from young to old, from local to international.  Similarly, the artwork we sell will go from very affordable—like cards that cost no more that $5—to quite expensive artworks that cost as much as $75,000.”

The Perkins Gallery wouldn’t be the Perkins Gallery if it didn’t include Danny’s artwork, which is now also being exhibited and sold across North America.  As well, his work has found its way to Japan, the Bahamas, and Australia. 

Only seven years ago, Danny was bringing his metalwork to the Richmond Craft Fair and attracting local notice with the three sets of metal gates at the Richmond fair grounds—work he did pro bono.

Since then, he has shown his artwork well beyond Cleveland Township.

“In 2018,” he recalls, “I brought some of my work to the Royal Agricultural Winter Fair in Toronto, which lasts 10 days.  I’ve been back every year since.  This year, I was asked to prepare an entrance piece—something that will be seen by visitors as they arrive.  I’ve also been asked to prolong my stay.”

In 2022, Danny’s work was exhibited in Miami and in Los Angeles the following year.

“Often,” says Rebecca, “an artist, or a gallery, can apply to attend a show.  Some only take artists, while others only accept galleries, and some are open to both.  If the show likes the samples that are submitted, the artist or gallery will be invited.”

“Other times,” she continues, “we’ve received an invitation to attend.  That was the case at the Hamptons Fine Art Show in New York in 2023.”

“That show was memorable for all the wrong reasons,” Danny adds.  “The area was hit by a violent rainstorm.  We were set up in tents and pavilions.  As the rain continued, we found ourselves standing in several inches of water.  Everybody was told to evacuate but all the artwork was left behind.  In my case, it didn’t really matter if my metalwork got wet, but other artists, those displaying watercolours for example, were not so lucky.”

“Another show we’ve attended is in Perth, Ontario,” he continues.  “It is also an outdoor art show.  In terms of the ratio between investment and return, it has been a great show for me.”

Artwork by Danny Perkins can now be found in widely disparate places including an outdoor sculpture garden in Los Angeles, a gallery in the small town of Ellaville, Georgia, the boutiques of the Royal Canadian Mint in Ottawa and in Winnipeg, and the Hockey Hall of Fame in Toronto.

“Something that’s become popular recently,” Danny explains, “is fingerprint art.  Imagine a small statue, about 12 inches high with all the ridges and whorls of a fingerprint.  I made Darryl Sitter’s fingerprint for the Hockey Hall of Fame.  Typically, I’ll make six copies of a fingerprint, of which one goes to the individual, three stay with me, and the two others are often auctioned off at a fundraising event.”

The first event that is going to be held at the new Perkins Art Gallery will be the Salon Empreinte d’Art.  Last year, the Perkins Gallery held the show in June at Parc Marie-Victorin in Kingsey Falls.  This year it will be held on May 18, 19 and 20 at the old St. Andrew’s church in Melbourne.

“We’ll be holding an official opening on the 17th as a VIP event,” says Rebecca Taylor.  “The following day the Salon will be open to the public.  After that, we’ll be open on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays, and also by appointment.  We’re also planning a commemorative event in November for Remembrance Day.”

“The gallery opening is the first step,” Danny Perkins adds.  “Possibly as early as next year we will be installing an artistic garden on the five-acre plot of land around the gallery.”

St. Andrew’s transition from place of worship to art gallery will not be an easy adjustment for everybody.  Just a few years ago the Conseil du patrimoine religeux invested considerable sums of money to preserve St. Andrew’s when it was a church.  There were restrictions on what could be done with the building, for example a prospective investor couldn’t subdivide it into housing units.  Its new vocation as an art gallery had the consent of the Conseil.

In its new incarnation, it will again draw people.  They won’t be coming to reflect on the spoken word, but, Danny Perkins and Rebecca Taylor hope, they’ll be prompted to reflection by the visual art.

Danny Perkins moves to St. Andrew’s Read More »

Look closely: can you see steam coming out of my ears?

By Dian Cohen

Local Journalism Initiative

I’m also tearing my hair out trying to imagine how we have collectively elected such dunderheads to manage the part of the economy they are responsible for managing.

My rant today focuses on healthcare. The Quebec government has just announced yet another of its seemingly endless ‘innovative’ ideas that, if we’re lucky, will be forgotten before millions of our tax dollars are spent. If we’re unlucky, they’ll spend millions on “mini-hospitals to bridge the gap between family medicine groups (GMFs) and hospitals.”

Leaving aside a description of this profligate idea, remind yourself of our possibilities to access healthcare.

  • We can go to a GMF.
  • We can go to a hospital.
  • We can go to a doctor in private practice.
  • We can go to a health co-op.  

With regard to GMFs, last time I looked, most GMFs weren’t taking new clients. That’s one reason there are at least 834,000 people on the government’s Family Doctor Finder list. And why Quebec now allows primary care nurse practitioners to register patients.

Most emergency rooms are operating over 100 percent capacity and wait times range from 5 to 14 hours – something that hasn’t changed despite the many promises and numerous ‘reforms’ over the years aimed at reducing wait times.

There are about 600 Québec GPs working in private clinics, where patients pay for all services from their own pockets. The government has already gotten rid of family physicians who hung out a shingle and practiced on their own, and they have recently said they want to get rid of physicians who have opted out of the public sector.

Health cooperatives are our last, best hope. Quebec’s co-operative movement traces its history back to 1900, when Alphonse Desjardins opened the first Caisse Pop —  Desjardins is now the largest cooperative financial group in North America and fifth largest in the world. Agropur and La Co-op Federée are two of the biggest farm co-ops in the world. This is not an untested business arrangement.

There are 40 health co-ops in the province managing the medical files of 300,000 Quebecers. They have been created by their communities – ordinary people who got together to fill a need. They voted in a board of directors, raised money for the building, furniture and fixtures, hired the doctors, nurses and staff. Start-up costs range up to $500,000 – money raised in the community, unlike the ‘mini-hospitals’ now being touted.

These co-ops are non-profit organizations that for years have been meeting healthcare needs not met by the public network or the private clinics. Most of them most of them are located in rural areas far from the main hubs of integrated health and social services. Their mission is more than helping sick people get well – they are strong proponents of preventative care and wellness. Funding to operate a co-op comes mainly from an annual membership fee by regular users and extends benefits beyond access to a doctor. Non-members also have access to a doctor, as prescribed by the Canada Health Act.

Yet the Quebec government is not benignly oblivious to health co-ops, it is actively discriminating against them. Here’s how:

Family medicine groups (GMFs), which are mostly profit-making corporations, are heavily subsidized by the government. Health co-ops, which are non-profit organizations, have been excluded from any financial subsidies. On March 29, 2022 the CAQ signalled a major shift in the organization of healthcare – it wanted to “think and do differently”. That was Bill 15, creating Santé Québec. What a perfect opportunity to right the wrong of excluding health coops from financial subsidies. Asked specifically by the Federation of Health Co-ops (FQCS) whether health coops were included as eligible organizations, the minister confirmed that they were. Yet nothing has changed.

Health co-ops are specifically excluded from financial subsidy because they’re not designated Non-Profit Organizations (even though they are). They aren’t designated non-profit organizations because they’re incorporated under the Cooperatives Act rather than the Corporations Act. Talk about convoluted! Because of this, co-op fees have been deemed to be “extra billing”, which is a no-no under the Canada Health Act.

The CAQ knows better. Extra-billing is the difference between the provider’s charge and the allowed amount. For example, if the government rate for a procedure is $100 and the doctor wants to charge $150, the doctor would have to bill you for the remaining $50. That’s the no-no. Co-op fees cover the operating costs to run the health facility – offices equipped with examination tables and diagnostic aids, nurses who triage patients, receptionists who make appointments, everything except the doctors’ fees, which are paid by RAMQ, the government’s Health Insurance Agency. These are the same expenses that the government subsidizes in larger, for-profit GMFs.

The Federation of Health Coops delivered a pre-budget paper asking the CAQ to create a funding program to put health coops on an equal footing with everyone else in the public network. Their ask was $2 million/year — not $2 million for each of the 40 co-ops, $2 million/year to be split between all the co-ops. The 2024 Quebec budget documents spending $62 billion on health and social services this year with nary a word about bringing health co-ops — the one group that’s in place and ready to meet the  needs of regular citizens – into the fold. Meanwhile, Health Minister Dubé’s office has confirmed that the government will allocate $35 million in public funds (borrowed or taxpayer) annually for each non-existent, start-from-scratch mini-hospital.

cohendian560@gmail.com

Look closely: can you see steam coming out of my ears? Read More »

Downtown? What downtown?

Wellington North at Frontenac should be bustling, but downtown often lacks oomph. Photo by David Winch

Sherbrooke struggles to establish an attractive, walkable central city

By David Winch

Local Journalism Initiative

The pop tune “Downtown” was a perky 1965 hit by Brit singer Petula Clark (ask your parents) that captured the allure of nighttime streets:

Just listen to the music of the traffic in the city

Linger on the sidewalk where the neon signs are pretty

How can you lose?

The lights are much brighter there

You can forget all your troubles, forget all your cares

So go downtown, things’ll be great when you’re

Downtown, no finer place for sure …

Clark evokes the fun of “movie shows” and “little places to go to” to forget all your troubles.

Sadly, that kind of city sparkle is missing in Sherbrooke — and has been for decades. Sure, there is some downtown life on Wellington St. North and King West, a good cineplex here or a nice Thai restaurant there, but overall, the area comes off as shabby and undistinguished. Red-brick industrial buildings and 1920s-vintage banks sit listlessly waiting for some purpose — anything.

“It’s just ugly”, said one dinner companion bluntly, speaking of central Sherbrooke.

To be fair to Wellington North, the main downtown street, walking around there on a sunny Saturday recently I noted the many restaurants, Asian-fusion, Lebanese, Iranian and Italian, the clothing boutiques, the excellent book and magazine outlets, and the Granada concert hall with its full slate of concerts. But somehow, this didn’t make for a bustling street scene. There was barely any bustle.

Longtime Townships residents recall nostalgically being drawn to the big Woolworth store on Wellington or to nearby Tony’s Pizzeria. But retailing has mostly moved to suburban outlets. The food court at the Carrefour de l’Estrie mall today matches the fast-food variety available in downtown Sherbrooke.

City of Sherbrooke’s revitalization plan for downtown focuses on six ‘quartiers’. Courtesy Ville de Sherbrooke

Plans to revitalize

As in cities throughout North America, Sherbrooke became progressively more suburbanized from the 1970s onward, with malls and autoroute-accessible restaurants, cinemas and shops dominating the retail trade.

Across Canada, a range of mid-sized cities resembling Sherbrooke – from Thunder Bay and Sudbury to Moncton and, in Quebec, Trois Rivières – also suffered the impact of declining industries: pulp and paper, forestry, mining, railroads and shipping and, in the Townships, the textile industry. This affected these cities’ dynamism.

A year ago, I wrote about my pleasant experience in Vermont’s capital (“Sherbrooke and Burlington: Twin cities?”, June 3, 2023). I enjoyed Burlington’s picturesque and walkable urban setting. A broad pedestrian mall straddles the downtown, the result of a push by key town councillors to follow examples in Europe, notably the Stroget in Copenhagen.

Can downtown Sherbrooke ever compete with that? Planners are aware of the stagnation issue. The “Mon Centro” revitalization plan posted on the city’s website “is the result of an initiative that began approximately 10 years ago, and culminated in 2015, with the adoption of the Downtown Sherbrooke Sustainable Development Master Plan (also known as Centre-ville 2020)”.

Its goal is ambitious: “The master plan aims to double the population living in the city’s downtown within the next 20 years, while greatly increasing availability of retail and office space” (for English summary, see www.sherbrooke.ca/en/major-projects/mon-centro ).

Pursuant to this plan, downtown Sherbrooke is now seeing “many large-scale projects materialize at the same time: construction of the Espace Centro project, redevelopment of a section of Galt Street West, moving the Grandes-Fourches Bridge … And that’s only the beginning!”

Sherbrooke planning chief Yves Tremblay is a believer; he lives downtown by the river on King. He says he can walk to everything, from the local Maxi to his work at city hall. He agrees there is “no magic formula” for downtown revitalization, especially when Internet is changing shopping habits so fast.

The rugged topography of Sherbrooke also affects its downtown. “Its geography is not linear; there are about six different ‘plateaux’,” which affect neighbourhood character. “Some streets such as rue Alexandre, stand out for their distinct local feel”, notes Tremblay.

Upgrades coming

Other experts in urban planning, however, stress that mid-sized cities don’t often have the downtown population or the geography to maintain a lively scene. The success of Burlington is a special case.

Planning specialist Pierre Filion of the University of Waterloo, for one, has studied dozens of mid-sized cities, ranging from 100,000 to 500,000 residents. He concludes they have to be “very lucky” to bring together all the plusses needed to revive a downtown. Filion also chronicled the “Eaton’s effect” that killed other Canadian downtowns – one department-store closing greatly reduces pedestrian traffic.

Among the successful mid-sized cities that Filion cites — standouts include Madison, Wisconsin, and Kingston, Ontario — there is often a built-in downtown population around a university campus, a major public employer such as a state or provincial capital, and geography that discourages sprawl. Madison’s centre, for example, is built on an isthmus squeezed between two lakes.

Sherbrooke has none of these advantages. And it never even had a downtown Eaton’s.

Today, you can see upgrades on Wellington St. South (until recently a headache for drivers): the broken pavement was replaced with brick and concrete squares, sidewalks have been widened, with planters installed for small trees, and parking made more convenient. Two new office towers of 6 and 10 stories anchor a young working population. Software developer Ubisoft and the school of digital arts (NAD) of the Université du Québec have already moved in. Trendy coffee outlets have followed.

In coming months, the city will adopt “intervention plans” for five more neighbourhoods, denoted as Galt; Alexandre; Marquette, Dufferin and, crucially for downtown life, Well Nord.

But, will these earnest revitalization efforts work?

Filion cautions: “All the elements have to be present for a downtown to be revitalized; above all, there have to be people living and working in the area”.

A tall order, for sure. But well worth it if locals can, some evening soon, like Petula, cheerfully head downtown.

Downtown? What downtown? Read More »

Scroll to Top