PHS welcomes province’s cellphone ban, says nuance will be needed
Sophie Kuijper Dickson – LJI Reporter
The principal of Pontiac High School (PHS) says he believes the province’s recently announced full cellphone ban planned for schools as of this fall will be easier to enforce than the existing in-class ban, and is in line with a policy the Shawville high school already had in the works.
“I was encouraged by the news and as a school community, we were working towards amending our existing cellphone policy to move in that direction,” said PHS principal Dr. Terry Burns.
On May 1, Quebec’s Minister of Education Bernard Drainville announced his government would be implementing a province-wide ban of cellphones on school grounds during school hours, including during breaks between classes and over the lunch hour.
The recommendation for a full ban was made by a special government committee that studied the impact of cellphones and social media on the health and development of young people.
It was one in a series of measures from the minister, all designed to “provide students and school teams with a safe, respectful environment where bullying and violence have no place,” according to the press release announcing these changes.
The ministry says schools will be responsible for determining how to apply this ban, and that certain exceptions should be made for pedagogical or health reasons.
Enforcement challenges
In response to the province’s initial in-class ban, which came into effect in Jan. 2024, PHS installed pouches at the front of every classroom where students were asked to leave their devices for the duration of the class but could still get access to them if they were needed for a learning exercise.
Burns described this system as “a good compromise,” but acknowledged enforcement was challenging for teachers.
“The teachers were conflicted. Some teachers probably would have liked a little more freedom of cellphone use, other teachers wanted them completely eliminated, so it was always very difficult for us to manage,” he said.
PHS math teacher Debra Paquette said while she believes the in-class ban was a good idea in theory, enforcing it was challenging.
“Unfortunately, some students take liberties and keep their phones on them, which means they have them on their persons if they leave the classroom,” she wrote in an email to THE EQUITY. “This often leads to students messaging their friends during class time, causing further disruptions to students who are in class.”
In the spring of 2024, she conducted an in-class data collection experiment with her Grade 7/8 classes to better understand just how disruptive cellphones were.
Over a 70-minute period, she asked students to put their phones on full volume and record how many notifications they received, and from what sources.
“Notifications were coming in fast and furious from a variety of different applications on their phones,” Paquette said. After the Snapchat app, which was responsible for 342 notifications across the four classes in which she ran the experiment, parents were the second-greatest source of phone notifications.
“A number of my students took note of just how disruptive consistent notifications were and for a period of time, more phones were in the provided pockets or lockers,” Paquette said. “But these devices have shown that they have such a grip on teens, that as time goes on, the pull from their devices gets stronger and they are less likely to want to put it away for a 70 minute class period.”
Burns said challenges with enforcing the existing ban led the school to begin a process of revising this policy, in consultation with teachers, its governing board, and parents.
“When the government made that [May 1] announcement, we were feeling we wanted to do something to tighten up our policy here.” Thanks to a survey he conducted with the parents of students, he was confident the school had the community’s support to do so.
He said while the exact nature of PHS’s stricter cellphone policy was still in deliberation, it would have eliminated the pouch system so there would be no reason to have a phone in the classroom.
“The instantaneous social media contact creates problems throughout the day [ . . . ] and causes issues during the school day that we have to deal with,” Burns said. “Because it’s become so difficult for us to manage in school, we would welcome a tightening of the rules.”
Clarification needed
Burns said he hopes to see the new government policy offer more specifics on the management of special circumstances when it comes to cellphone use in schools.
“There are a lot of questions that are going to be answered, and we hope to see some sort of clarification in the policy,” he said, pointing to concerns around implications of the ban for students who use their phones during long bus rides to and from school, as well as for students who are reliant on their devices for medical monitoring.
“And there are kids who have social attachments that would want to be communicating home,” he said, alluding to the challenges he anticipates when it comes to moving towards less frequent communication with parents. He said the school would ensure that families are well supported.
“I think there’s going to be some difficulties as we transition, but in my opinion it’s still the right thing to do.”
George Singfield, director general of the Western Quebec School Board, said he foresees these challenges across the board.
“Not having [phones] at all in school is going to be very challenging to enforce, given the society we live in where people are so connected to their phones,” he said. “I think what we need to really do is discuss and implement how we’re going to educate students to understand the ‘why’ so it’s not seen as a punishment.”
Students push back
Students across the province staged a one-day walk out on May 9 in protest of the province’s new policy.
In a video that went viral on TikTok, young Quebec highschooler Youry Roy called on students to strike, claiming there were far more serious problems in schools than the use of cell phones.
In an email on Thursday, the Centre de services scolaire des Hauts-Bois-de-l’Outaouais, the service centre responsible for École secondaire Sieur-de-Coulonge (ESSC) in Mansfield, informed parents students might boycott classes on May 9 as part of the province-wide protest. “We encourage students to express their opinions respectfully and constructively, within the framework provided by the school,” communications coordinator Monia Lirette wrote in the French email.
On Monday, the service centre said no ESSC students had participated in the walkout after all, and declined to comment on the news of the province’s cell phone ban.
PHS welcomes province’s cellphone ban, says nuance will be needed Read More »
































