Coroner urges UPA to act in wake of farmers’ deaths in manure pit
Frederic Serre
The Advocate
A Quebec coroner examining the tragic 2024 deaths of a farming couple in Montérégie is calling on the Union des producteurs agricoles to alert its members about the importance of wearing protective equipment to prevent the inhalation of deadly gases when working near manure pits.
It was deadly gases that killed farmers Caroline Robidoux, 40, and Éric Jutras, 44, at their family farm, which raises grain-fed calves, in the village of Ste. Christine near Acton Vale on Oct. 4, 2024. At about 6 p.m. that day, Robidoux rushed to try to save her husband as he worked in a manure pit and had lost consciousness, but she, too, inhaled the deadly gases and died from poisoning 18 days later in hospital. Autopsies revealed that the couple died from asphyxiation due to exposure to hydrogen sulphide inside the pit.
“(Éric Jutras) had always worked on a farm, so he had a lot of experience in this area and knew he shouldn’t go down into the pit without equipment. However, according to his loved ones, he was a bit reckless and probably wanted to do something quickly,” said coroner Nancy Bouchard in her report released Sept. 2.
When mixed with water, manure becomes slurry, a form of fertilizer. When stored in an enclosed space, this liquid releases toxic gases as it decomposes, Bouchard said.
“Every year, gases emanating from slurry storage structures claim victims, most of whom die before help arrives,” Bouchard wrote in her report.
She urged the UPA, the province’s professional farmers’ association, to boost awareness activities concerning procedures for entering such pits, which include training, adequate ventilation, and the wearing of respiratory protection equipment.
According to Bouchard, it is “likely” that Jutras was working on the pump inside the pit. When his wife, concerned about his absence, went to look for him, she found him lying face down, unconscious, with his face submerged in manure.
“Instinctively,” she climbed down into the pit without taking the time to protect herself, the coroner said.
After seeing her parents in the pit, one of the couple’s daughters ran to find her uncle, Francis Robidoux, warning him that her parents needed help. Paramedics and firefighters were called to the scene.
Jutras was pronounced dead the same day, while Robidoux was kept in an induced coma for several days before doctors discovered irreversible brain damage. She died on Oct. 22, 2024.
A Gofundme campaign was launched by the family of the couple, raising more than $19,500 to support their three children.
The tragedy was the second of its type to occur in the area. In 2016, a pig farmer and his 18-year-old employee died while trying to do some work in a manure pit at a farm in St. Valérien de Milton, located about 30 kilometres from Ste. Christine.
In the St. Valérien incident, investigators reported that the farmer, who was in his 50s, lost consciousness due to the toxic fumes in the pit, and his employee rushed to his aid but was also overcome by the fumes. Both men died at the scene. It was determined that their deaths were the result of inhaling high levels of hydrogen sulfide.
Cutline:
Éric Jutras and his wife Caroline Robidoux died last October. They were both asphyxiated due to exposure to gases emanated from the manure pit on their farm near Acton Vale where they raised grain-fed calves.
Coroner urges UPA to act in wake of farmers’ deaths in manure pit Read More »























